One of my favorite plant geek authors, Alan Armitage, once wrote, "There are certain plants that no matter how easy they are, we love them and don't mind if they take root on the back of our cat."

Granted, I don't have a cat, but for me, that plant is Japanese honeysuckle.

Weedy it is. Numbered among the 100 most invasive species, Lonicera japonica is often the most common plant in urban forest understories. Its vigorous growth allows it to grow up trees, carpet hillsides and outcompete most native groundcovers. This twiney vine can even choke the plants silly enough to shade it, winding itself so tightly about their trunks as to restrict the sap flow.

This competitive advantage is bolstered by its lack of natural enemies. Simply put: Deer don't eat it.

Advertise with us

Asian honeysuckles are a weedy bunch. Lonicera mackii, first introduced in Philadelphia, has become so rampant as to earn the vaunted title "noxious" in a number of states. Another weed, L. tatarica, seems to be the only shrub on forest edges in the Northeast.

Aside from being very closely related, atrociously weedy and the bane of foresters everywhere, the above three honeysuckles were all intentionally released into cultivation. It seems that gardeners, in our zeal for the newest thing, can be -- gasp! -- somewhat shortsighted.

Weedy plant, weedy relatives and tree-killer. Why do I love Japanese honeysuckle? Well, some say that the way to a man's heart is through his stomach. Being a very strange man, the most direct way to my heart is through my nose. And let's face it, honeysuckle puts out some rockin' pheromones.

I live in an apartment. No, I would never, ever willingly plant honeysuckle in my backyard, but there it is anyway. I absolve my conscience by telling myself that it's my landlord's backyard, not mine. Every night, when the sun goes down and the plant moisture content rebounds, my window smells better than a florist shop.

I go to bed intoxicated. But like so many other drunken nights, I wake up and hate myself. I see that vine on my way to work, see all its pure white flowers fading to eggshell and see the graveyard of shrubs it has choked out. What really kills me is a walk through Schenley Park.

Advertise with us

A quick walk through some areas of our city's treasured park will reveal a veritable mat of honeysuckle where once was an assortment of other groundcovers.

The textbook definition of an invasive species is an organism that causes economic, ecologic or emotional damage. I'm not too sure about the economic damage, but the ecological upsets seems readily apparent. As for the emotional harm, does the guilt after enjoying its delicious aroma count?

While, yes, I do love Japanese honeysuckle, I nurture an ardent hatred toward it. Sure, it smells great and can spruce up an otherwise unsightly privet hedge. But in a forest ecosystem, where it does the most harm, it does a whole lot of nothing. Japanese honeysuckle will not flower in the shade. Thus, all its redeeming qualities are lost in the context of our city parks.

Am I suggesting that you underplant your unsightly privets with honeysuckle? Absolutely not (unless it's the adorable, noninvasive native Lonicera sempervirens). While delicious in my (landlord's) backyard, there is no way to keep those plants from making their way to Schenley Park. The seeds of honeysuckles can hitch a ride in a bird's intestinal tract, traveling miles in a single digestive cycle.

Where does that leave me, the aroma-phile gardener? There are plenty of other alternatives to Japanese honeysuckle in the garden. Hardy kiwi has fragrant flowers and the added benefit of grape-sized, delectable kiwis if both a male and female plant are present. A number of clematis cultivars are superbly fragrant. If you wanted to try your hand at tropicals, marginally hardy vines or annuals, the world is your oyster. Try snail vine, moonflower or Carolina jasmine, all of which are delightfully scented without the unpleasant habit of eating forests.

Advertise with us

If a weed is a plant out of place, then where is the place for Japanese honeysuckle? Japan is the short answer. But where does that leave the host of foreign plants that do not invade our forests and strangle trees? I vote we look into further assessment of introduced plants' invasive potential, in addition to halting installation of known invasives.

Does "abscents" make the heart grow fonder? And if so, then how much more alluring would the scents of Lonicera japonica be if you could smell its intoxicating fragrance only in Japan, where it belongs?