The transformation is shocking. Mellon Park's walled garden has been denuded; all the perennials, grasses and vines removed, even the two large hornbeams, favorites of tree-climbing children, that flanked the fountain.
It feels like overkill.
"The hornbeam trees were assessed by an arborist," said landscape architect Fred Bonci. "One was dying and one was in decline."
Will the former estate garden's $500,000 renovation be worth the immediate loss of the trees and use of the space for almost a year? It appears that it will.
The garden, installed around 1930, was designed by the New York firm Vitale and Geiffert and replaced a U-shaped garden by Alden & Harlow, the Pittsburgh architecture firm that designed Richard Beatty Mellon's 65-room house at 6500 Fifth Ave. The octagonal bay of Mr. Mellon's study looked directly onto the garden.
"When you entered the house through the porte cochere, you could see straight through to the fountain" in the walled garden, Mr. Bonci said.
The new scheme for the garden, by LaQuatra Bonci Associates, was guided by photographs of it from the 1930s and the original planting plan of 1929.
"We're trying to get as close to the historic image as we can while providing some amenities that people expect" in a public park, said Mr. Bonci, whose firm collaborated with Vermont preservation landscape architect Patricia O'Donnell.
The ongoing renovation, a project of the Pittsburgh Parks Conservancy and the city, retains the garden's original architectural features: the red brick and limestone walls on three sides, the flagstone paths, the Edward Amateis fountain, and the iron gates by Samuel Yellin.
The flagstone paths and the gates were restored a few years back and a new connection added: a flagstone path on the end opposite the fountain, where a path had never been. By completing the open-ended rectangle, the new path allows visitors to keep off the grass while walking the garden's perimeter. New plantings of holly along the new path, replacing the long-lost yews, will help frame the garden and restore the gateway experience of entering it from the wide limestone steps, where the lions had been.
The current phase of work will re-create the planting beds that lined the original flagstone paths on their lawn side. Six Stewartia trees, which bear large, camellia-like blossoms in spring, will be planted in each linear bed, for a total of 12.
"The trees will bring back the structure and form of the garden and provide more intricate seating areas" with limestone benches, Mr. Bonci said. "We wanted to make those a little more intimate and also provide some shade."
To replace the hornbeams, LaQuatra Bonci specified blackgums, but those may be changed to another species due to a dearth of large specimens. Hornbeams were not chosen because over time, "they just totally overwhelmed that part of the garden," Mr. Bonci said.
For a few years after its completion, the walled garden had two flanking rows of cherry trees in the lawn; for unknown reasons they were gone by the mid-1930s, when the Mellons had the garden photographed. Although those images show lots of spring-flowering bulbs, the 1929 planting plan has a mix of densely planted perennials in the long beds. In the renovation, those beds will be filled with bulbs and perennials with three-season interest, including tulips, narcissus, iris, allium, black-eyed Susans, lavender, hosta, phlox and peonies.
Serviceberry trees will hold the corners on the fountain end, and dogwoods will be planted on the rise near the rock outcropping and on the opposite corner, close to where the house had been.
The walled garden will require skilled, intensive care; a plan for maintenance, to be funded by an endowment now being raised, is in development. The conservancy and city parks staffs will install and maintain the garden.
The walled garden's lions, thought to have come from one of the Mellon houses near Ligonier, have been placed in storage. Mr. Bonci said they will be returned to another, still undetermined, location in the park. On the plinths where the lions had been, large urns will be placed and two more added on the nearby lower plinths, as in the original scheme.
One of the biggest changes will be the introduction of a memorial artwork by Brooklyn artist Janet Zweig, honoring the life of Ann Seamans of Point Breeze, a Wesleyan University sophomore who died in a car accident in 1999.
I'm not convinced that a historic landscape is the right place for an individual memorial, but Ms. Zweig has found a sensitive and unobtrusive solution that will be largely invisible by day. Softly glowing lights will be embedded in the garden's new structural soil lawn, representing stars in their pattern over Pittsburgh when Ms. Seamans was born in November 1979.
Vandalism has been a problem in the park, however, and the memorial is an invitation to visit after dark, when it has occurred. The star-lights will be turned off before the park closes at 11 p.m., when the gates should be closed.
The conservancy estimates that it will cost $1 million for the entire walled garden project, including re-plumbing the fountain in a later phase. It has raised about half that amount and is actively seeking contributions.
There is still much work to be done in the park and more immediately pressing needs, such as the terraced gardens where walls and balustrades are crumbling or missing entirely. Let's hope there's enough money in town to go around.
No revitalization of the park would be complete without establishing for visitors the location of the house, which could be outlined in stone in the lawn as garden historian Barry Hannegan, a consultant to the park's 2001 master plan, has suggested.
"I would absolutely love to do that," Mr. Bonci said. "It would help people understand the whole context."


Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.