It appears that a tumultuous year for Penn Brewery is going to end with a soft landing as the historic brewery is set to get new owners.
John E. Graf, Eric Heinauer and an as-of-now anonymous partner closed on the brewery on Friday night, the new owners said Monday — just in time for Oktoberfest.
“It’s going to happen. Tents are up, and the bands are lined up,” Heinauer said, referencing the annual celebration starting next weekend.
Heinauer, director of sales at Wigle Whiskey and Threadbare Cider, will run the day-to-day of Penn Brewery as chief operating officer.
He has decades of experience in the hospitality and liquor industries, and a long history at Penn Brewery. He started working at the brewery in 1996 and was part of the group that helped revive it in 2009.
“The real plan is to rediscover our roots,” Heinauer said. “At our core, we are a German brewery. Pilsners and other German-style beers are popular right now. We just need to return to that because we do that better than anyone else.”
Penn Brewery’s two current full-time employees — head brewer Christopher Rudolph and director of sales and marketing Amy Huseman — will remain with the brewery.
Graf is the president and CEO of Priory Hospitality Group. He has a deep appreciation of adaptive historic preservation in Pittsburgh.
In 1986, his parents, Ed and Mary Ann, opened the Priory, a rehabilitated Benedictine monastery built in 1888. Graf joined the family business in 1995, the same year they transformed the adjacent St. Mary's German Catholic Church into The Grand Hall. He rose to CEO in 2002. The former lawyer purchased The Mansions on Fifth, a boutique hotel built from two Gilded Age homes in Shadyside, in 2016.
“This place opened the same year as the Priory. We got to know [co-founder] Tom [Pastorius] as we both opened in historic buildings," Graf said.
In April, owner Stefan Nitsch announced his company had filed for Chapter 11 bankruptcy to restructure the business.
“We want to address this directly and transparently before any speculation begins: Penn Brewery is not closing,” Nitsch said in a letter at the time.
Around the same time, the Troy Hill brewery closed its satellite location at Pittsburgh International Airport.
A month later, Nitsch’s creditors, First Commonwealth Bank, put the property, as well as two adjacent lots owned by Nitsch under his Arkham Realty banner, up for sheriff’s sale. The sale was later postponed, and Nitsch ended bankruptcy protection last month.
As of July 1, Penn Brewery still owed more than $5 million, with the bank holding collateral valued at about $3.3 million.
Tom and Mary Beth Pastorius founded Penn Brewery and released its first beer, Penn Pilsner, in 1986, well before the craft brewing trend swept the nation. In 1989, it opened a restaurant in the historic Eberhardt & Ober brewery, the first in Pennsylvania to use a brewery license since Prohibition.
Ownership of Penn Brewery and its real estate passed through several hands, including Birchmere Capital and E&O Partners, after the Pastoriuses divested to a minority interest in 2003. The couple returned in 2009 as part of a small group of investors including Sandy Cindrich, Corey Little, and Linda Nyman. Tom Pastorius died from prostate cancer in 2012 at age 67, lauded for his contribution to craft beer in Pennsylvania.
Nitsch purchased the brewery and its property in 2022.
As of now, the ownership group has purchased the brewery but not the real estate. Graf said “there are larger discussions happening at this point” when asked about the land.
Graf and Heinauer are childhood friends. Both said they feel a deep connection to the landmark brewery, the oldest craft brewery in the city. On Monday, just prior to a press conference, Graf recalled how his father would come here in his custom German St. Nicholas costume, and Heinauer recalled how Graf’s father made the introduction that helped him land the job in 1996.
“It felt like Tom and Mary Beth lived here. If you came here you were greeted by them. We need to get back to that kind of hospitality,” Heinauer said.
He plans to be a hands-on presence in the revived operation and spearhead the plan to ensure Penn Brewery’s lagers are distributed widely though its network of distributors “wherever you can find high quality beer” in Pittsburgh and the region.
Penn Brewery’s restaurant should be back up and running by October with a limited menu of German dishes and Pittsburgh favorites such as pierogies, with a larger renovation to happen following the holiday season, which will include Krampusnacht.
“It was a roller coaster, but we got it done,” Graf said. “We’re building the airplane as we’re flying it.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.