On a chilly morning, Chuck Page, 71, stands in a T-shirt and gray-brimmed hat in the back of the South Side ice cream shop where he has spent decades of his life.

There, in black-and-white photos affixed to the building, is his family history — stretching back more than a century in a history that parallels Pittsburgh’s own.

Page’s — originally Page Dairy Mart — opened in 1951 and launched its 75th season this month. The seasonal business, open from March to October, has long been more than an ice cream stand. Its history tracks the arc of the city around it, a history that has endured floods, explosions, declining steel mills and a worldwide pandemic.

But key in Page’s particular history is Chuck’s grandfather, who decided to turn a gas station into a soft-serve ice cream stand.

Advertise with us

Charles Alexander Page encountered soft serve on a trip to Florida in the early 1950s and brought the idea home.

“Soft ice cream was just a new thing coming out. So he decided that he wanted to do it. … He said it was an instant success. He made more money in ice cream than in gas,” Chuck says.

The roadside business gradually became something woven into everyday life. When the mills were still operating, steelworkers and railroad crews were its customers.

“There were 8,000 people right down here,” Chuck says pointing to the location of a former J&L Steel mill. “They all had families, and they were making good money,” and they wanted to buy their families “a nice treat.”

As a young man, Chuck did not plan to spend his life selling ice cream. He studied accounting and computer science at Robert Morris University but graduated in 1981 into a regional economy hollowed out by the declining steel mills.

Advertise with us

“There were no jobs in Pittsburgh, and I wanted to stay here,” he says. “So I decided to do this. I’m glad I did.”

Margie Page Prusia and her father, Chuck Page, in front of the new Page's food truck. (Sono Motoyama / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A flood, an explosion and a pandemic

The prospering business, located improbably almost under a railroad trestle on a noncommercial strip of East Carson Street, is known for lines of customers that snake around the building. But the property, like the city, has seen its share of troubles.

The Page family’s ownership dates to 1916, when it was home to a general store and gas station serving local residents and coal miners.

The two buildings were destroyed in the St. Patrick’s Day flood of 1936, after which two gas stations were rebuilt at the location. In 1958, a gas explosion caused by a leak that seeped through the sewer line again wreaked destruction.

“No one killed,” Chuck says. But several people were burned or injured, including his father and grandfather, who suffered third-degree burns.

Advertise with us

“Some people were thrown across the street because the explosion was so bad.”

Still, the family rebuilt. They added food, like steak sandwiches and hamburgers, to the menu along the way.

Now the business has passed from father to daughter, into the hands of Margie Page Prusia, 33, one of Chuck’s six children. She bought it with her husband, Jared, in March 2020.

Like her father, she did not initially imagine herself taking over.

“Honestly, I never really expected it to play out the way it did,” Margie says. “I’m a nurse by trade.”

Advertise with us

She worked briefly as a nurse, then decided, with her husband, to buy the business from her parents. The timing could not have been worse.

“We bought it the beginning of 2020, March, and then two weeks later, COVID hit,” she says.

Customers line up for their first treats of the season at Page's on East Carson Street, South Side. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Page’s for a new generation

Though there were tears and frustration, Margie says, the business survived and thrived. Under their ownership Page’s has expanded its reach without losing the essentials that made it a Pittsburgh icon.

“We are at a different level, which is amazing, what she has done with the business,” her father says proudly.

“Be realistic, Dad,” Margie kids him. To a visitor she says, “He acts like I’m the one doing everything.”

Advertise with us

She quickly also credits her manager, her husband and a social media manager, who creates alluring Facebook and Instagram posts depicting spooling swirls of ice cream, luscious fruit, gooey caramel and homemade dessert mix-ins.

Still, her imprint is unmistakable. She shortened the name of the business, modernized operations, introduced a vegan frozen dessert, leaned into limited-time offerings and embraced social media as a way of sustaining a legacy business in a new era.

“I wanted to have more of a social media presence when I took over,” she says. “That’s where all the new eyeballs are. So you have to kind of be on those platforms to get new people down here.”

That effort has helped build a younger customer base while preserving the old one. On opening weekends, she says, “a lot of college students” now join the annual rush.

At the same time, Chuck sees the same families returning in new formations.

Advertise with us

“When I worked [here], people my age, their grandparents brought them here. Now they’re bringing their grandsons here.”

That blend of continuity and reinvention also shows up on the menu.

Chuck helped drive one of the biggest changes years ago by bringing local baked goods into the mix. The business had reached a plateau.

Then, he says, “we started using local bakery products, giving us uniqueness.”

“I call it the taste of Pittsburgh.”

Advertise with us

Collabs with other local businesses

That taste now comes layered into sundaes and sandwiches and mixed into Arctic Swirls — an admitted copycat of Dairy Queen’s Blizzard. Page’s is now known for collaborations with local bakeries, including Potomac, Bethel and Oakmont, among others.

The most famous example may be the Nancy B’s Cookie Sundae, one of Page’s signature items and one of its most popular. It’s a generous helping of three peaks of vanilla ice cream, hot fudge, house-made whipped cream with real vanilla and warm peanut butter-chocolate chip cookies.

Michael Runco, owner of Nancy B ’s Bakery in Homestead, says the partnership between Page’s and his mother, Nancy B’s founder Nancy Bertram Runco, goes back nearly two decades.

“Mr. Page — Chuck — and my mom got together and decided to go and do something where two staples, Page’s and Nancy B’s, could get together and actually make a very awesome item.”

The collaboration has benefited both businesses.

Advertise with us

“We get tons of customers from Page’s,” Runco says. “[Customers] go there and they have a chocolate chip sundae or a Large Marge … then they’ll come in here.”

Similarly, Page’s signs in his bakery generate interest from his customers, Runco says.

Preparing a mix-in at Page's. (Maya Giron / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

28 flavors and counting

Meanwhile, Page’s has maintained a large range of flavors and expanded seasonal specials that keep customers coming back. Banana, Birthday Cake, Cotton Candy, Dreamsicle, Key Lime Pie, Mango, Maple and Toasted Coconut, among many more, are on the unusually long list of soft-serve flavors.

All are built on a soft-serve mix from local Turner’s Dairy, which produces a dense, creamy base. The stand goes through about 16,000 gallons per year.

“I think we have over 25 flavors of soft serve that we can do,” Margie says. “And we have probably 40 Arctic Swirl flavors. So pretty much unlimited options.”

Advertise with us

Some flavors are built from house ideas and ingredients rather than industrial flavorings.

“We make the peanut butter-chocolate chip flavor with real peanut butter, real chocolate chips,” Margie says.

Chuck points to another favorite.

“When blueberries are in season, we use fresh blueberries in it. ... It’s really a different eating sensation.”

And Page’s keeps innovating around the calendar. Fall specials now push business beyond the traditional summer peak. Chuck, who has spent decades in the trade, still sounds amazed.

Advertise with us

“In the ice cream business, usually after August, everyone’s sales go down,” he says. “ [Margie] made our sales in September higher than August. I never heard anyone doing that.”

“We just do a limited-time fall menu” — offering things like Pumpkin Roll Arctic Swirls — “and people go bananas for that,” she explains matter-of-factly.

In its 75th year, Page’s is also going mobile, with a new truck that will bring the brand to events around the region. The expansion feels fitting for a business that has spent decades rooted to one corner while becoming a destination for the whole city.

Chuck sums up his own connection to the business and its regulars, some of whom he has helped move and visited in the hospital.

“This is more than business for me,” he says. “This is almost a ministry.”