The 1990s was a dire time for cocktails in the United States. Most drinks were being poured with bottom-shelf liquor into plastic cups and sweetened with neon high-fructose corn syrups.
Even so, some cities had curious outliers — bartenders who still knew how to stir a proper Manhattan or shake a refreshing scratch-made daiquiri.
In Pittsburgh, the keeper of the flame was Don Bistarkey.
“He wasn’t a ‘name,’ necessarily, but he was the inspiration for all of us,” says Leslie Donovan, a friend and former employer of Bistarkey, as well as a former co-owner of Harris Grill.
“Don was our ‘Mr. Boston,’” Donovan says, referring to the famed post-Prohibition cocktail guide. “He had all that knowledge inside his brain. And then he went deeper.”
As word of Bistarkey’s untimely death at age 55 circulated on Christmas Eve, tributes poured in for a central figure in the blossoming of the South Side’s East Carson Street as a nightlife destination in the ’90s and a mentor to the bartenders who would forge Pittsburgh’s craft cocktail scene a few decades later.
Read More
“He was so humble about his influence, but his influence was felt on all of us,” says Sean Enright, proprietor of Poetry Lounge in Millvale and one of the bartenders widely credited with shaping Pittsburgh’s cocktail revival in the late aughts and early 2010s.
Donovan and Enright, who is co-author of the book “Pittsburgh Drinks: A History of Cocktails, Nightlife & Bartending Tradition,” say Bistarkey’s work helped set the stage for an era when a boulevardier became standard at neighborhood bars and bespoke cocktails were a central part of restaurant menus.
“Back in the ’90s it was, ‘Let’s go to the Lava Lounge and throw a random cocktail name at the bartender,’” Donovan says. “Even if it was five-deep at the bar, Don could turn them out.”
“He had me drinking cosmopolitans before ‘Sex and the City.’ I think that was the first real cocktail I ever had,” Enright says.
Bistarkey had not planned on a career behind the bar or, later, in management. His first love was music.
According to Enright, he was working as a sound technician at Lava Lounge when he was asked to cover a bar shift at the hip South Side spot.
It stuck.
With an encyclopedic appetite for learning and an outgoing personality, Bistarkey proved a natural fit behind the stick.
“One thing people keep telling me is how he was meant to be a bartender because of how he welcomed people,” Enright says. “He loved the details of hospitality, and he knew how to talk to people.”
Bistarkey went on to open Tiki Lounge and work at a wide range of Pittsburgh bars and restaurants, including Cafe Allegro — where he first mentored Enright — Harris Grill Downtown, Double Wide Grill, Spoon, BRGR and The Livermore.
At Tiki Lounge, Bistarkey would prove to be an influence not only in Pittsburgh but also the entire budding craft cocktail scene in the United States.
Phil Ward, now one of the most notable bartenders in the world, credits Bistarkey in the foreword to “Pittsburgh Drinks” with opening his eyes when he was a young drinker without the “slightest notion of what a well-made cocktail was.”
On a slow night at Tiki Lounge around the turn of the millennium, Bistarkey made Ward a mojito — now commonplace but at the time “the tastiest alcoholic beverage I ever had tasted,” Ward writes. Bistarkey then introduced him to Heaven Hill rye whiskey and, as Ward put it, “planted a seed.”
“As Don Bistarkey taught me, you just need to plant the seed, and a cocktail culture will flourish. Would you have thought five years ago there would be a Pittsburgh cocktail book?” Ward wrote.
Ironically, by the time Ward returned to Pittsburgh as a consultant to launch a high-end cocktail program at The Rowdy Buck in the early 2010s, the movement Bistarkey helped spark had already spread across the city. East Carson Street, meanwhile, had shifted toward a louder party culture.
Enright said one of Bistarkey’s most defining traits was his lack of ego, which allowed him to keep learning from bartenders he had once mentored. When the craft cocktail boom arrived in Pittsburgh, Bistarkey became an enthusiastic student.
“It was a weird experience teaching him all the methods of craft cocktail boom technique and watching him apply it to the knowledge he already had,” Enright says. “A lot of people, especially older bartenders, could be, ‘Well that’s not how I do it.’ Don was really open.”
Music remained a constant throughout Bistarkey’s life. He played percussion and sang in several bands over the years. Celebrated Pittsburgh musician Slim Forsythe met Bistarkey in 1990, when the former was known by his given name, Kevin Forsythe, and managing the band A.T.S. Bistarkey was a roadie for the group, and the two struck up a friendship while the band was on the road.
Two decades later, when Forsythe formed Slim Forsythe & His New Payday Loners, he recruited Bistarkey to sing bass and play washboard for the group.
“I really didn’t know how wonderfully he could sing up until that point. But he could, he really could,” Forsythe says. “He had an instinctive knowledge of what to do no matter what.”
Bistarkey also never lost his ear for audio. Forsythe says he would often speak with venue technicians before shows to fine-tune equipment.
“No matter what the room, he knew what levels should be set. You’d always sound great when Don was playing with you,” Forsythe says.
Bistarkey — who had been living in Oakdale and caring for his mother, who remains in hospice — died in early December from a pulmonary embolism, according to Enright. Friends grew concerned in late November when he stopped responding to calls and texts, which was out of character.
After multiple wellness checks, his body was found Dec. 11, a little more than two weeks before what would have been his 56th birthday. A group of friends and colleagues threw a birthday gathering in his honor at Tiki Lounge on Dec. 26.
A tribute show celebrating Bistarkey’s life is scheduled for Feb. 22 at Spirit Lodge, with a lineup that includes A.T.S., Submachine, Alexi Morrissey, Becky & the 67s and The Reckoning.
“So many of us were inspired by him. Don cared so deeply about the people around him,” Donovan says. “Above and beyond anything I’ve said, Don was my friend. A very, very good friend.”







Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.