Empty your kids’ Halloween bags after trick-or-treating and their haul is bound to include miniature Twix bars, fun-sized bags of Sour Patch Kids and snack-sized Reese's Peanut Butter Cups. If they’re lucky, maybe a generous neighbor even threw a full-size candy bar into the mix.
Not bad for a few hours work, but in my mind, I’ll always associate Halloween with the bright-red candy apples Mrs. Hopkins always handed out from the end of her sidewalk — usually while dressed as a scary old witch.
Georgie, as we all knew her, lived across the street from where I grew up. A talented home cook, she made the best handmade chocolate bunnies and eggs at Easter and was famous for her homemade cinnamon rolls. In summer, there were always Popsicles in her freezer. In winter, she simmered big pots of “real” hot chocolate on the stove.
But it’s her candy apples that always stick in my head, especially these days, when most homeowners get their Halloween goodies in big bags at the supermarket or big-box store.
The combination of sweet apple and crunchy, sugary candy shell is just so satisfying, and fun. I could eat an entire batch in an afternoon, even when my husband warns me people “our age” shouldn’t be eating hard candy.
I made the treats a few times with my mother, too, who sometimes liked to sneak in flavoring extracts like cinnamon and strawberry. And on occasion, I’ve dipped apples into the hot red candy with my own children.
It’d be too much work and, given the high cost of apples, too expensive to churn out enough treats for the hundred-plus trick-or-treaters who will show up at my doorstep on Halloween night. And I doubt anyone would take a homemade snack from a stranger anyway, no matter how fabulous they look or how friendly the white-haired lady handing them out seems.
But there’s still time to whip up a batch for your family and friends.
It’s apple season, after all, and the candy coating requires only three ingredients you probably have in your pantry — sugar, corn syrup and red food coloring — plus water and a handful of wooden or paper lollipop sticks.
A tart and sturdy apple like Granny Smith is best (though you can use whatever you’ve got on hand) and you probably want to stay on the small size so they’re easier to eat. I like them best unflavored, but you also can add flavorings like cherry, grape or cotton candy.
A couple cook’s notes: Once the candy starts boiling, stop stirring or the sugar could crystallize. Above all, remember the candy coating isn’t just hot — it’s molten. (At least it feels that way if you accidentally drip a ribbon of it on your hand while dipping the apples.) Heatproof gloves are not a bad idea.
Also be sure to line a cookie sheet with a piece of buttered parchment paper to cool the candy apple on after they’re coated. That allows for easy release without cracking the bottoms.
Old-Fashioned Candy Apples

PG tested
Candy apples will remain fresh in an airtight container in the refrigerator for a day or two.
Unsalted butter or baking spray, for parchment paper
2 cups sugar
¾ cup water
½ cup light corn syrup
3 or 4 drops red food coloring
6 wooden or paper sticks
6 medium tart apples, such as Granny Smith
Line a baking sheet with parchment paper, smear it with a little butter or baking spray and set aside.
Scrub apples with cold water and dry well with paper towels.
In a medium heavy-bottomed saucepan, combine sugar, ¾ cup water, corn syrup and enough food coloring to get desired color.
Bring to a boil over high heat, then reduce heat to medium-high. Clip candy thermometer on side of pan, and continue to boil until temperature reaches 300-310 degrees (hard crack stage), about 20 minutes.
Meanwhile, insert a stick into the top of each apple, pushing about ¾ of the way through; set aside.
When candy mixture reaches the hard crack stage, immediately — and very, VERY carefully — remove from heat. Working quickly, dip apples in sugar mixture until completely coated. (I had to spoon the hot liquid onto the last two apples to cover them.)
Transfer to prepared baking sheet; allow to cool.
Makes 6 candy apples.
— Gretchen McKay, Post-Gazette






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.