Like apparitions from a strange sci-fi universe, giant white plastic tubes lie sprawled across farmland in Washington County.

Perhaps odder than these silent creatures is simply the continued existence of Twin Brook Dairy farm in Bentleyville. After assaults from local mining in the 1970s, battles with increasingly tumultuous weather and constant lashings of the unpredictable commodities market, the family farm was close to shutting its barn doors for good a few years ago.

A fat ration of father-daughter support, gallons and gallons of ice cream, and a tiny pinch of Billie Eilish-approved social media magic helped pull the family farm from the brink.

The white tubes represent the farm’s seasonal preparations as winter approaches. John Marchezak, who took over the dairy from his father, also named John, stuffs the tubes with his farm’s fall harvest. Each sack contains 25 acres’ worth of chopped up corn cobs and corn stalks — good eating for a cow after the feed has fermented in the tubes.

Advertise with us

“It is completely airtight, so it cures better,” Marchezak said. “You just take a little bit every day off the end.”

He also wraps hay he grows in plastic — he calls the bales “white marshmallows.” This method is both time-saving and keeps the forage from degrading in the sun or rain.

His herd of 115 mostly Guernsey cows eat a precisely calibrated diet — one that is monitored by an animal nutritionist — in order to keep the animals healthy and able to produce the milk for his business.

Though he worries about the effect of badly timed wet weather on his crops — he lost about $80,000 this year, he said — and his ability to feed his animals, eight years ago his concerns were even more dire.

He and his accountant had been having discussions.

Advertise with us

“The farm wasn’t making any money. It was costing me money,” Marchezak said. “So it was time to quit.”

That’s when he had a heart attack. The stress of thinking about shutting down his father’s farm was the cause, he believes.

“It was very emotional,” he said.

Millie's Homemade Strawberry Jam ice cream featured local strawberries, house-made jam and Twin Brook Dairy milk. (Adam Milliron)

A new beginning

After returning from overseas following World War II, Marchezak’s father, a coal miner’s son, opened a dairy in the region where he’d grown up. He bought his first farmland in 1952, raising Guernseys, and opened a bottling plant in 1961.

In the early ’70s, however, longwall mining in the area stripped the farm of much of its water supply, so Marchezak’s father had to shut down the bottling operation.

Advertise with us

When his son took over the farm, he continued to operate the dairy, selling most of his milk in bulk to a regional dairy. Over the years, his father had converted his herd to Holsteins — the most popular breed in industrial dairy farming — which produce more milk than Guernseys.

The farm had retained some Guernseys, however, and Marchezak’s children and his sister Patty’s children had taken to raising Jersey cows to show at 4-H competitions.

In a quirk of nature that would become important to the farm, both Guernseys and Jerseys have richer, and many say, higher-quality milk than the behemoth black-and-white Holsteins.

When the moment arrived to shut down operations, Marchezak sold his Holsteins. However, the market was not good, so he held on to his other breeds, hoping to get a better price later.

Spurred to action by the sale of the herd, Marchezak’s daughter Randi told her father she wanted to help save the farm.

Advertise with us

“I said, ‘If you don’t want to completely get out of [dairy farming], let’s do something about it,” she recalled.

Her father gently suggested that she do something about it. Coincidentally, she had heard that Chad Townsend of Millie’s Homemade was looking for high-quality milk.

Late one night, she emailed Townsend, whom she met when he was a chef and fledgling ice cream maker and she worked for a farm coop that provided products to restaurants.

“I got an answer back immediately,” she remembered. “He was like, ‘I want the milk. I’ll take all of it.’”

Of his impromptu decision, Randi said, “That’s kind of Chad. That’s how he is.”

Advertise with us

She suggested he come out to the farm and try the milk first.

“My dad put [raw milk] in a bucket and Chad took the bucket and drank it,” she said.

Recalling that moment in the barn, Townsend said, “All it took was one sip, and we knew that we had found exactly what we were looking for.

“The richness of it, the quality of the taste, the freshness,” he said. “It is what I imagine in my brain milk is supposed to taste like.”

Despite Townsend’s initial enthusiasm, the young ice cream company was unable to use the 2,000 gallons per week that Twin Brook was producing. Randi estimates that it was closer to 50.

Advertise with us

Randi decided to bottle Twin Brook milk to start a parallel business of selling at local markets. When Millie’s moved into a new facility in Homestead, Townsend offered her space for bottling in his factory. Both businesses began production from the ice cream works in early 2020.

Twin Brook Dairy milk bottles are filled at the ice cream works. (Justin Guido / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Cream-top milk

Today, Randi, as bottler-in-chief, is her father’s biggest customer. She buys her father’s milk at a steady price that is twice what he would get in other markets. He delivers it to the Homestead facility, and she pasteurizes about 500 gallons a week — at the lowest possible legal temperature, which, she believes, is beneficial for taste and health qualities of the milk.

After processing, she sells some of her output to Millie’s, her top client, and uses some to sell at local markets and some for her nutty Alpine-style Farm Girl cheese.

Any surplus is sold to a regional dairy.

The little marketing Randi does includes a charming online Instagram account, which reveals life on the farm. One video, which showed one of the farm’s Labrador retrievers being licked by two calves, got 5.1 million views, including a thumbs-up from singer-songwriter (and vegan) Billie Eilish.

Advertise with us

Twin Brook milk is able to claim a unique place in the market partly because of its makeup. The luxurious output of Guernseys and Jerseys constitute the bulk of the output, with Guernsey milk lending its characteristic slightly golden hue, due to the beta-carotene in the milk.

Townsend explained that standard supermarket milk is 3.25% fat because “fat is where you make money.”

Industrial producers skim the cream to sell on its own, or turn it into other, more lucrative products such as butter.

“[Industrial producers] are very intentional about hitting that 3.25 window exactly,” Townsend said. “Whereas the Marchezaks’ milk is in the mid to high 4s.”

For his ice cream, Townsend said, the extra richness “just adds to the decadence.”

Advertise with us

Twin Brook milk further separates itself from the herd, so to speak, with its cream top. The milk is not homogenized — meaning that the cream rises to the top. Which may be startling to those unaccustomed to the style.

Randi says it just requires a slight shaking. Another trick she recommends is to lay the bottle on its side so the cream is distributed through the milk.

She promises that the oddity has its benefits. The fact that the milk and milk fat is not altered either by homogenization or high pasteurization temperatures — but it is heated enough to kill pathogens — yields tastier, creamier yogurts, cheeses or whey products (like ricotta).

She said her father, ironically for a dairyman, used to think he was lactose intolerant, but later found he could drink her milk with no problem. Customers have told her similar stories.

Moreover, it just tastes good.

Advertise with us

“People tell me all the time, ‘This is the best milk I’ve ever had,’” she said, a moment of pride for a businesswoman who has helped return her grandfather’s farm to its roots as a Guernsey dairy farm that does its own bottling.

“We’ve come full circle,” she said. Next year, she plans to bring an expanded bottling plant back to the farm in order to increase her product line and customer base.

Her father noted that Millie’s brings potential franchisees to Twin Brook Dairy as the last stop on a tour.

The prospects take a swing through the ice cream factory, the ice cream maker’s chocolate provider “and then they come here,” he said. “They tell me I’m the closer.”

Twin Brook products are sold at its dairy farm store at 429 School Road, Bentleyville, and can be found at Mediterra, Fat Butcher, East End Coop, Wise County Biscuits, Mayfly Market, Millvale Market and Market District and Giant Eagle stores, among others.