I posted a run of sandwich photos on Instagram recently, which prompted a flood of “best sandwiches???!?” DMs. I’m not (for now) working on such a list, though a streak of standouts over the past few weeks has me tempted to do so at some point next year.
If I ever do write it, one of the first three paragraphs will start this way: “More than anything else, using the right bread to accentuate and support the fillings is essential to building an extraordinary sandwich.”
Three of the sandwiches in this short list use bread from the outstanding Allegro Bakery in Squirrel Hill.
Allegro’s been around for quite some time — owner Omar Abuhejleh purchased the bakery (then known as Allegro Hearth Bakery) in the mid-2000s — but it has soared to new heights over the past few years. In 2020, Abuhejleh made the bakery an entirely vegan enterprise, a huge task for an operation with a wide range of products that typically rely on animal-based ingredients such as butter, milk and lard.
Through meticulous testing, he and his team have cracked the puzzle on pretty much everything Allegro offers (try a croissant and tell me there is no butter!), including its French-style pan loaf. It took me until the denouement of tomato season to find the perfect BLT bread, but this superior sandwich loaf is it.
Ask for it thick-sliced for a tangy and airy bite bolstered with crispness when toasted or a sturdy base for your stacked summer sandwich dreams. (Shout-out to Coldco Farm, too, for the crunchy Little Gem lettuce I used for my BLT — and to all of Pittsburgh’s farmers for carrying on through a hot, dry summer.)
Stuntpig, Rockaway and Alberta’s
Allegro also works with a few local sandwich stars. Stuntpig uses larger regional brands for many items, but takes advantage of its proximity to Allegro for the baguettes on its Murray turkey. Turkey sandwiches are often overlooked — and at an all-out stellar sandwich spot such as Stuntpig, I get it — but this deeply flavored build, with juicy, house-brined and roasted turkey, butternut squash cheese, garlicky kale and sumac red onions is one for the books.
The bakery goes a step further with Rockaway Pizzeria. The pizza shop’s owner, Josh Sickels, asked Abuhejleh for custom hoagie rolls for Rockaway’s new Regent Square location. Proper hoagie rolls should be crackly yet feathery, airy batons — preferably coated with sesame seeds — and they’re almost impossible to find at commercial scale in Pittsburgh. Next time you head to Rockaway, order the meatball hoagie, which had me cheering as my pals and I crushed one with bouncy meatballs (cut in half for easier eating) dressed with sharp provolone, creamy ricotta and rich red sauce.
While we’re talking meatballs at the city’s destination-worthy pizza shops, consider the spicy meatballs at Alberta’s as an alternative (OK, let’s get real, an augment) to Beau Mitall and crew’s wood-fired pies. The racquetball-sized rounds, with enough panade to keep the texture light, are a Sunday gravy-worthy plate served in a full-bodied tomato sauce. The liberal addition of pickled hot-ish peppers adds tart, tang and a welcome kick, which makes the spicy version the move here.
Common Oven Pizza cheesesteak
Staying with pizza destinations, I’m impressed by how far Common Oven Pizza Co. has come in the two years since I last visited the cool spot attached to Strange Roots in New Kensington (one of the region’s most surprising food hubs, with options such as Jillian’s and Taqueria El Pastorcito). The dough bakes to a crisp on the burnished underside, with a sweet ferment in the lofty edges, and the toppings are balanced on the hot-honey build (pepperoni, banana peppers, honey, basil, mozzarella, red sauce).
My pals and I also made the drive for the cheesesteak, which another friend raved about at a party the night before.
We all thought the seeded, house-made roll was quite good, though it could be a little less dense or cored a bit for the filling. Why? Because that mix of shaved ribeye, caramelized onions and Cooper sharp cheddar was the most spot-on cheesesteak build I’ve had in the region, and I wanted every last bite.
Speckled Egg and Thyme Machine
While the Common Oven cheesesteak was a revelation, the turmeric chicken salad sandwich from Speckled Egg was pure comfort. The savory-sweet build has been a go-to since the dark days of the COVID-19 pandemic, and it’s something I order nearly every time I visit one of the region’s most delightful daytime restaurants.
One last August sandwich of note came from Thyme Machine. Bloomfield’s beloved breakfast-sandwich guru Ryan Chavara is still cleaning up after a fire devastated his kitchen in June, but he’s doing his best to keep things moving in the meantime. I was stoked to see the Thyme Machine cart pop up at Spirit for the Lawrenceville spot’s annual Summer Recess.
Chavara offered several options, and I opted for a classic bacon, egg and cheese on a house-made English muffin. You can find Thyme Machine popping-up from time to time at its Bloomfield neighbor Brothmonger (check social media for details) and we will keep you updated as any developments happen with Chavara’s home base.
We also had the scoop on Spirit's massive expansion as part of my fall dining preview. Have a look if you missed it to get a sense of all the exciting developments in store for the last part of the year. One more bit of good news jumped out since that story published, too. After a series of delays caused the project to get pushed back for more than two years beyond its originally anticipated opening date, Julio Peraza’s Torogoz finally opened in Sewickley this week.
More on that, soon.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.