Jeff Carr grew up helping his parents make the handcrafted confections that have been sold for decades at Yetter’s Candies, the old-fashioned candy and chocolate shop his maternal grandparents, Elmer and Gert Yetter, opened in 1950 on Millvale’s main drag.
But he never considered continuing the business into its third generation and becoming a chocolatier himself until about 10 years ago. For that, you can thank his children.
After graduating from Shaler High School in 1989, Carr left town, living for a time in Myrtle Beach, S.C., before moving to California in his 30s.
In 2014, the divorced father of two was doing lab work for a biomedical company in San Diego and very much missing his daughters (who lived with his ex-wife in Michigan) when he decided to return to Pittsburgh to be closer to them. Back in familiar territory, he quickly fell back into the rhythms of the family business.
He had worked at Yetter’s Candies as a kid with his younger sister, Jennifer, doing everything from filling metal candy molds with chocolate and dipping ice cream cones to stocking shelves and sweeping floors.
“I knew what I was doing here,” he says.
He ended up buying the shop from his parents in 2016, and nine years later, still loves the day-to-day business of making nonpareils, chocolate-covered turtles, molded chocolates, chocolate-covered fruits and pretzels and dozens of other delectable treats.
Making candy is a sweet life, but that’s only part of the appeal, says Carr, 54.
“It comes down to being my own boss, and having the freedom to take time off” whenever he wants to see his two daughters, who are now 20 and 18.
Survivors
Here’s fun bit of history: At one time, Millvale actually boasted two confectionaries known as Yetter’s.
Elmer Yetter’s brother Albert opened the original Yetter’s at the corner of Evergreen and North avenues in 1940, and for eight years happily churned out homemade ice cream in the basement along with chocolate.
After a holdup near Christmas in 1948, however, Albert was so unnerved that he sold the shop to Elmer and his wife, Gertrude. But he missed it so much that Elmer ended up selling it back to him in 1950 and opened a second Yetter’s at its current location on Grant Avenue.

“There was no feuding, no drama,” says Carr. “They just wanted to do their own thing and shared the name.”
Albert would eventually sell his shop in 1972 to his nephew, Regis Steedle, who put his own name on it, leaving just one easy-to-find Yetter’s. (Regis Steedle Candies and Ice Cream closed in 2006, following a bitter family dispute.)
Gert, as Carr’s grandma was known, continued running the store after Elmer’s death at age 56 in 1966. Her daughter, Arlene, who worked in the store as a girl, and son-in-law Ed “Butch” Carr — who was working for Pepsi at the time — took the reins in 1969. Then, as now in their retirement, they lived above the shop that previously held Kings Hardware before the family turned it into a confectionary.
While the location has never changed, the store has expanded multiple times over the last seven decades. One of the biggest and most memorable renovations wasn’t planned; it was the result of a natural disaster.
Along with so many other businesses on Grant Avenue, Yetter’s was under 5 feet of water following a devastating flood in 2004 caused by the remnants of Hurricane Ivan. It took nearly a year to clear away all the dirt, muck and broken machinery, and rebuild the store from the basement up with help from community donations.
All the chocolate equipment had to be torn down and put back together, and in every room moldy drywall had to be replaced. The only positive was that because it was summer — a relatively slow period for candy stores — they didn’t have as much inventory.
<

“The community wouldn’t let them close,” says Carr. “They would find envelopes of money in their mailbox.”
While the wholesale business, which was growing before the flood, didn’t survive the high waters, most of the couple’s antique metal candy molds were salvaged. They also rescued the giant Vulcan gas-fired kettle stove that can cook up to 100 pounds of sugar at a time, and which Carr uses to make the shop’s egg creams and caramels.
“It’s probably as old as the store,” he says.
Solid and semi-solid milk chocolate bunnies and novelties in just about every shape imaginable (teddy bears, flip-flops, cell phones, dinosaurs and dump trucks, to name a few) carry the business during the busy Easter season, along with a bounty of colorful foil-wrapped chocolate eggs and peanut butter meltaways. Other old-school treats that still find an audience for candy lovers include half- and 1-pound fruit-and-nut eggs.
During the Christmas season, chocolate Santas and boxed, molded chocolates “help keep the lights on,” says Carr.
The recipes are based on a Swiss chocolate.
To keep up with consumer trends, Yetter’s Candies also sells newer treats like barks, chocolate-covered potato chips, Oreos and bacon and chocolate emoji pops. In all, Carr estimates the shop easily carries at least 100 products, including a vegan line that’s made with sunflower oil instead of dairy.
The store also has a refrigerated case that stocks deli items such as lunchmeat and cheeses.
Despite the rising cost and global shortage of cocoa beans, Carr — who is expecting his first child with his wife, Natacha, any day now — says he has been able to keep costs down to manageable levels.
“A lot of it has to be with me being back here by myself,” he says with a wry smile.
Blast from the past
The store, with its centerpiece classic soda fountain, has remained basically the same over the years.
Ten red vinyl-topped stools similar to the originals washed away by the flood welcome customers at the original yellow counter, and you’ll still find old-fashioned treats like Indian Salted Pumpkin Seeds, Smarties, Cow Tales, pastel-colored Satellite Wafers and bubblegum cigarettes in glass cases and on shelves near the front door.
The luncheon menu, posted in white letters on red signboards, is another delightful throwback. It features the same simple soups (tomato, minestrone and chicken noodle) and humble sandwiches topped with lettuce, tomato and cheese that the Carrs likely grew up on: chipped ham, tuna and egg salad and peanut butter & jelly. All are under $5.
The ice cream sodas and sundaes — now made with Ashby’s Sterling Ice Cream instead of homemade — are a little more expensive at $7.99, but it’s fun to watch modern-day soda jerks prepare them. They include manager Ashly Abel of Bauerstown, who grew up going to the store with her paternal grandfather, Robert, and started working there five years ago.
“Everyone knows the Yetters,” she says, noting that it’s fun place to work.
“You can’t beat a kid walking into a candy store.”
The only thing that’s really changed since she was a kid is the countertop card readers that allow for quick and easy payment.
“It’s the most modern thing in the store,” Abel says.
Carr estimates the store will go through 2,000 pounds of milk chocolate leading up to Easter. White and dark chocolate, he says, is “its own thing” that ebbs and flows in popularity.
While Millvale’s old world vibe is changing, with more young people making their homes there and filling up storefronts, the typical customer is one for which Yetter’s Candies is a beloved tradition.
“It’s a lot [of people] who grew up here and come back with their own kids,” Carr says, though it draws plenty of Gen Z’ers and millennials who appreciate the store’s old-school feel and affordable prices.
Once he can relax a bit after the holiday crush eases, Carr says the shop undoubtedly will have some sort of special event when it officially celebrates its 75th birthday on Dec. 13.
“There will be a party,” he says. “We’re still figuring it out.”






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.