All Saints Greek Orthodox Church in North Strabane will hit a culinary milestone when it kicks off its annual Greek food fest on June 3.

2024 marks 50 years in the festival business for the Washington County church, which was founded 99 years ago on Blaine Avenue in Canonsburg and moved to its much larger location on West McMurray Road in 1995.

Once again, thousands of food lovers will descend upon the church throughout the five-day event to indulge in a homemade Greek lunch or dinner, either indoors in the dining room or outside under a giant white tent in the parking lot. Many more will call ahead and take their orders to go for a quick meal at home or the office.

Because everything is made fresh by volunteer hands, the event takes months to plan — and includes a detailed work schedule that would make even an Army general proud.

Advertise with us

Longtime church member and event co-chair Becky Pihiou and more than 100 volunteers have been chopping, mixing, rolling, twisting, layering, baking and generally singing the gospel of Greek food since January to drum up interest for the golden anniversary party.

On a recent Tuesday, more than a dozen women sat along a super-long table in the parish hall, their fingers flying as they rolled walnut-sized scoops of dough into ropes to be twisted into a buttery Greek cookie called koulourakia.

“And we’re starting to chop nuts for our next cookie next week,” Pihiou said of a sweet treat called finikia that’s made with honey, walnuts, lemon juice and lots of sugar.

One of the cookie makers was 86-year-old Penny Toras, marking her eighth year as a fest volunteer, and Sevasti Kouparis, 77,  who has been helping to prepare the event’s authentic Greek dishes almost since its beginning — a whopping 48 years.

Sevasti Kouparis, in blue,  has been helping with the church’s annual Greek Food Festival for 48 years. (Lucy Schaly/Post-Gazette)

It’s work, of course, but the coffee’s plentiful, the company’s great and it’s extremely gratifying to contribute to a good cause, the women noted.

Advertise with us

Or as Kouparis exclaimed when kidded about developing carpal tunnel from all the repetitive hand work:  “I love it. I get to help my church.”

At the other end of the assembly line in the church kitchen, Peggy Moniodes — who has been volunteering for at least 40 years — placed trays of cookies into the oven and baked them for around 14 minutes, or until they have a “nice little color on there.”

“When they come out, they have to look like this,” she said, holding up a baking sheet stacked with 2½ dozen perfectly golden brown cookies.

A walk-in freezer just around the corner holds more savory goodies. Weeks before, with help from some male parishioners, whose strong fingers make easy work of squeezing liquid from countless pounds of cooked spinach, volunteers prepared 235 pans of spinach pie, or roughly 7,520 servings.

“These ladies don’t mess around,” quipped Zachary Loutsion, 26, an eighth-grade social studies teacher at Canon-McMillan Middle School who serves as the church’s activities and social media director.

Advertise with us

The festival was founded in 1974 at the parish’s original location behind Sarris Candies in Canonsburg by Manuel Johns and Becky Pihiou’s uncle Bill Pihiou. Like many inaugural food events, it started small with just a handful of food items. That’s because the courtyard on which it was held wasn’t very large, Pihiou said, and organizers weren’t sure of the interest.

It was an instant success, with hundreds of people lining up for more than a half-hour to buy authentic Greek foods such as moussaka, spanakopita, baklava and galaktoboureko, a crispy dessert made with filo and custard.

“Back in the day, we thought it was a big event, with hundreds of people,” said Pihiou, who grew up in the church and for more than 30 years served as a Greek dance instructor after dancing there as a teenager.

The All Saints Greek Food Festival was originally held in a much smaller space in the courtyard of the old church on Blaine Ave. in Canonsburg.(Courtesy of Jimmy Gregorakis)

With help from festival chairs, the crowds only grew after the congregation moved to the newly constructed church at 601 West McMurray Road in the mid-1990s. Where the fest drew hundreds in the 1970s, today upwards of 40,000 people come through the church’s doors over five days.

Pihiou, who has been a festival co-chair for the past 10 years, estimates that volunteers will serve some 30,000 meals start to finish, along with untold a la carte orders for sides such as Greek green beans, “upper tent” items such as gyros, as well as pastries and desserts. It’s expected to raise around $300,000, which will be directed toward church expenses and its community outreach efforts.

Advertise with us

“It’s very generational,” she says of the fest. “We’re just like family here.”

Thanks to twice the amount of kitchen space for prep, the menu has grown along with the crowds to about 16 items in 1980 (including smelts) and nearly 30 items today — everything from lamb shish kebab and baked chicken dinners to gyros, lamb burgers, Greek salads and a host of homemade desserts.

One thing that hasn’t changed are the recipes. Most are ones that have been handed down over the generations to parishioners by grandparents, aunts or uncles, says Pihiou, “and that’s why people come back.”

“We’re blessed with community members who continue to support us and are always excited,” agreed Loutsion. “They’re always asking, ‘When is the fest?’”

Organizers are particularly proud of the festival’s homemade (and they say unique) keftedes, or Greek hamburgers. Ground beef is mixed with chopped tomatoes, cumin, mint and onion, formed into patties, then floured and deep fried.

Advertise with us

They occasionally add new items, to keep things interesting. This year, for example, they’re bringing back fried calamari and saganaki, a pan-seared Greek cheese appetizer, said Loutsion.

To accommodate the increase in quantity, some recipes have been gently adapted to make it easier on the volunteer cooks. Pihiou remembers her grandmother buying cases of fresh green beans to make Greek-style green beans; today the legumes come in 6-pound cans. The church also no longer uses fresh grape leaves for the dolmathes.

“All the yiayias would pick them from their yards and bring them to the church to be canned,” she remembers with a smile.

Prices, understandably, have also gone up over the years. The a la carte spanakopita that cost 75 cents in 1980 and $2.25 in 2004 now runs $3.

“We try to be as reasonable as we can,” says Loutsion, “so everyone can enjoy it and come back two or three times.”

Advertise with us
Zachary Loutsion and festival co-chair Becky Pihiou with volunteer cookie makers in All Saints Greek Orthodox Church in North Strabane.(Lucy Schaly/Post-Gazette)

Volunteers started preparing for the fest not long after New Year’s Day by rolling thousands and thousands of dolmathes using 22 cases of filo and 680 pounds of  ground beef mixed with rice, onion and lemon. In the months and weeks since, they’ve also stirred multiple gallons of meat sauces for the pastitsio and moussaka (100 pounds at a time) and crafted tray after tray of tiropita, a filo crust pie filled with eggs and a mixture of cheeses.

The fest eventually grew to six days before it was scaled back to “make it a little easier on our bodies,” said Pihiou. They also changed the dates so as to not compete with other annual Greek festivals in Aliquippa and Mt. Lebanon.  “But we also have a mini, three-day fest in October.”

Nights are generally busier than days, because that’s when there’s live entertainment with music and dancing. But expect to see a lot of people during lunch hours and in mid-afternoon, too.

“The past couple of years it’s just been constant,” said Pihiou.

The 50th annual Greek Food Festival at All Saints Greek Orthodox Church, 601 W. McMurray Road, North Strabane, runs 11 a.m.-8 p.m. June 3-7. Online orders are taken from 11 a.m.-3 p.m. daily except June 7 at www.allsaintscbg.org/food/festival. Admission and parking are free. More info: 724-745-5205.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on X @gtmckay.