Dorothy Ratesic and Dee Dee Baskot know a thing or two when it comes to the Serbian stuffed cabbage dish known as sarma.
For instance: A blend of twice-ground beef and pork from Lampert’s Market spiced with a generous pinch of Vegeta all-purpose seasoning makes an excellent filling. And if you refrigerate the cabbage leaves after boiling to make them pliable, don’t forget to wipe each one dry with a paper towel because “they’ll get wet” in the fridge, Baskot says.
Cooks also will want to remove the hard triangular rib from the base of each cabbage leaf with a paring knife before adding an ice cream scoop of filling — it’ll be hard to roll otherwise. Also, to replicate St. Sava’s signature sauce, you’ll need to hand squish the canned tomatoes for a smooth texture.
“All that diced stuff [in a can] ... It tastes like something’s in it,” says Baskot.
Because the hearty, stick-to-your-ribs dish takes longer than you might think, especially when prepared for a crowd, it’s also good to have a great cause to motivate you in the kitchen. On a recent Saturday, their inspiration was St. Sava Serbian Orthodox Church’s 122nd anniversary celebration on Nov. 4-5.
With roots stretching to 1901, St. Sava was the first Serbian Orthodox parish established east of the Mississippi River and is the third oldest in the U.S., says member Mike Vranesevic. That’s why every anniversary merits a bash for its 120 or so members, considering how many local churches have closed or lost many members over the last few decades.
The original church was in a former Presbyterian church building on Hazel Street in downtown McKeesport. During its heyday in the early 1950s, when manufacturing flourished along the Monongahela and Youghiogheny rivers, the congregation moved to its current location on Hartman Street to accommodate 300-plus families, says Vranesevic. It’s been building on tradition ever since.
Ratesic was baptized in the church decades ago and Baskot is a lifelong member of the parish started by Serbian and Russian immigrants and now under the leadership of Rev. Stevan Rocknage. They and others have tucked and rolled so much sarma over the years for church functions that it’s almost second nature.

Pros who roll
For the church’s 4th annual Taste of Serbia event in September, volunteer cooks made — and quickly sold — 884 cabbage rolls.
“Everyone likes this dish,” says Vranesevic.
It also explains why, when fellow parishioner Ellis Cannon succeeded this fall in a years-long campaign to add a sarma cook-off to the church’s roster of events, the women didn’t bat an eye. Even though it meant cooking even more sarma for those who come to the church to watch and participate in the taste-off starting at 3:30 p.m. Nov. 4. ($1 buys you half a stuffed cabbage, and the chance to vote for the event’s best.) They’re pros, after all.
A recent Saturday prep session confirmed it.
Within the first hour of arriving at St. Sava at 9 a.m., the women crafted nearly 90 of the meat- and rice-stuffed rolls. They’d go on to make another couple hundred before wrapping up operations around lunch time.
Every Eastern European food tradition includes some version of the rustic, humble cabbage roll. What they’re called just depends on who’s making it and the filling they choose. It’s holubtsi in Ukraine, galumpki or golabki in Poland, balandeliai in Lithuania and halupki in Slovenia.
How they do it
All start basically the same way — boiled cabbage leaves filled with a plump mixture of meat and rice (or sometimes just vegetables) before being baked in a tomato-based sauce. At St. Sava, cubed kielbasa, slab bacon and sauerkraut also go into the pan.
The women get a short head start by boiling and peeling off the cabbage heads (from Jordan Banana in Dravosburg) the day before. That’s also when they chop all the onions and make the rice used in the filling. So when they arrive at the McKeesport church, they are ready to rock and roll (and roll and roll).

Taking one of the de-ribbed leaves, Ratesic demonstrates her expert rolling technique, honed over the decades. After flattening the leaf on a parchment-lined baking sheet, she places a ball of pre-portioned filling in the center — they use a 2-ounce ice cream scoop to keep the size uniform and their hands clean — gathers the two sides between her fingers, folds them up and across each other and starts to roll.
“You just fold one side, and tuck in the other side,” she says, until it’s nice and tight.
The finished roll goes onto another parchment-covered tray to await the roasting pan.
The ladies used to make the rolls in bigger batches, in big aluminum pans in the oven, says Baskot. “Now, it’s in these,” she says with a chuckle, pointing to an electric roaster on the counter, “Because we’re old and can’t lift them!”
Roasting rolls
Cooking the rolls is nearly as easy. After lining the bottom of the electric roaster with a few large cabbage leaves and a small amount of sauerkraut, the women place cabbage rolls on top, seam side down. They then add sliced kielbasa and fat chunks of slab bacon, more sauerkraut, any leftover chopped up cabbage and the crushed tomatoes with a little bit of water; a second layer of the same goes on top. They’ll cook for about 2½-3 hours, says Baskot, after which they’ll be portioned into aluminum pans for serving at the fest, where two sell for $8.
Which brings us back to the cook-off, which Cannon, who came up with the idea more than a decade ago, believes might be the first of its kind in Western Pennsylvania — if not the entire state.
The TV talk show host who grew up in Midland, Beaver County, and started attending St. Sava two decades ago liked the sarma served at events so much that, in January 2011, he asked the priest’s wife, Protinica JoAnn Rocknage, for her recipe and then went home and made it.

Over the years, the Churchill resident added his own touches to the recipe he jotted down on the back of a church calendar and still keeps in a notebook.
That led to some lighthearted trash-talking among members about who made the greatest sarma, with Cannon joking they should hold a cook-off.
“It’s one of those foods where everyone thinks they make it the best,” he says.
Cook-off takes off
Yet it wasn’t until he was mowing grass during the COVID-19 pandemic and thinking about new ways to reach and reconnect with former church members that an actual plan started forming in his mind.
It took until February to get a formal proposal off the ground to make this year’s homecoming celebration extra special.

“His enthusiasm got everyone excited,” says Vranesevic, who is chair of the church’s health team and is assisting Ellis with the cook-off.
“These events also provide an opportunity for us to enjoy special church memories and life lessons from parents, families and previous generations,” Ellis wrote in a homecoming letter to parishioners.
“Indeed, we consider this a responsibility to those who have gone before us. From them, we learned a commitment and dedication to our Orthodox faith, Serbian culture and support and sustainability of our parish.”
Organizers are hoping to draw upwards of 100 people to the cook-off, which will have as many at 10 competitors.
The event runs from 3:30-6:30 p.m. Saturday in the church hall at 901 Hartman St., McKeesport. Its winner will walk away with a sarma-shaped trophy. Afterward, there will be dancing and music from the Serbian orchestra Orkestar Pobeda from 7-11 p.m.
Sunday’s liturgy at 10 a.m. will be followed by a homecoming-themed banquet from noon-3 p.m.
“We want to draw in people who moved or were somehow disconnected for the full weekend to celebrate with the church community,” says Vranesevic. “We’re a friendly and open community.”
“It’s all about outreach and fellowship,” agrees Ellis. “We believe in evolving and continuing to be active in our community.”
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.

St. Sava’s Sarma Recipe
PG tasted
2 large heads of cabbage
2½ pounds ground pork
2½ pounds lean ground beef
1½ cups diced onions
4 tablespoons butter
2 27-ounce cans sauerkraut
2 eggs, lightly beaten
1½ cups cooked rice
2 28-ounce cans whole tomatoes
1 cup warm water
Vegeta all-purpose seasoning, to taste
Pepper, to taste
Kielbasa and/or slab bacon, if desired, cut into chunks
Remove core from cabbage. Wilt cabbage by placing in boiling water. Loosen leaves with fork, removing a few leaves at a time. Set them aside to cool. Save cooked core of cabbage; chop into pieces and set aside.
Melt butter in pan over medium heat and saute onions until golden brown (be careful not to burn). Rinse sauerkraut well and squeeze out water.
In large bowl, mix ground meat, egg, rice and sauteed onions, and season with Vegeta and pepper. Into second bowl, squeeze or tear tomatoes with hands or fork, retaining the juice. Add water.
Preheat the oven to 350 degrees.
To assemble, remove the hard triangular rib from the base of each cabbage leaf with a small paring knife. Spoon 2 tablespoons of meat mixture into each leaf, then fold up toward the outer edge, tucking the sides in as you roll.
Line bottom of roaster with a few large cabbage leaves and a small amount of sauerkraut. Place cabbage rolls on top, seam side down. Add pieces of kielbasa and/or slab bacon, if using.
Spread remaining sauerkraut, chopped cabbage and tomato mixture on top.
Bake, covered, at 350 degree oven for 3 hours. Serve hot.
Makes about 35 cabbage rolls.
— St. Sava Serbian Orthodox Church






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.