Millie’s Homemade Ice Cream started as a home delivery operation based in the Edgewood kitchen of Chad and Lauren Townsend. Now, it’s poised to become the region’s ice cream titan as it expands its reach with new scoop shops and coffee options.
A lot has happened for the Townsends in less than a decade.
Back in 2014, Chad Townsend was looking to do something between restaurant jobs after he’d left his position as executive chef of Salt of the Earth. While at the restaurant, he’d toyed around with preparing ice cream in a chef-loved appliance called a Pacojet and figured he’d offer a few pop-ups in a side room at The Livermore (now Lorelei) in East Liberty. It was such a hit that the Townsends decided to deliver it to people’s houses.
“I was so overwhelmed and didn’t know what I was doing. I’d literally drive around and set single pints on people’s porches. We’ve learned a lot of lessons since then,” Chad Townsend says.
Eventually, in 2015, the Townsends moved Millie’s into a small production plant in Homewood and, in 2016, opened their first scoop shop in Shadyside. They grew the business slowly but significantly over the next few years, the centerpiece of which was opening a 7,000-square-foot manufacturing facility in Homestead in 2019.
The Townsends’ recent focus has been on growing its wholesale business — you’ll find pints of Millie’s in Giant Eagle and Whole Foods stores, neighborhood grocery shops and even on the menus of Pittsburgh-area restaurants.
Read More
Now, Millie’s is set to refocus on its retail trade. The key to making it happen: franchises.
“The largest, most important reason for moving to more franchises is that it’s been eye-opening to see what it’s like from a bandwidth perspective to operate a bunch of shops. If we want to keep expanding, it’s difficult to do that owning and running the shops ourselves,” Townsend says.
Case in point: The Lawrenceville scoop shop Millie’s opened in early 2020 is now owned by longtime friends Jason Horowitz and Tina Scheuring. Establishments in Wexford and South Fayette are similarly run as franchises, as is a food truck that operates in the South Hills. Millie’s only stores that continue to be owner-operated are its original Shadyside location, its Market Square location (shop number 2) and a small stand on the Carnegie Mellon University campus.
“What we found with franchising is nobody is going to operate the stores like people who have skin in the game. As we expand, we’re moving to communities where people who live there, who are ingrained in the community, can better connect with the people who live near them than we can,” Townsend says.
The 2023 expansion begins in Oakland on Jan. 9. That’s when a new Millie’s operated by Mike and Stephanie DiPaolo opens on Oakland Avenue in a building owned by the University of Pittsburgh. Longtime friends of the Townsends’, the DiPaolos say they decided to open a franchise because of their friends’ passion for high-quality products. Mike DiPaolo also has long ties to Oakland; he’s a University of Pittsburgh alumnus and, when he was a kid, his father lived in the neighborhood.
“The neighborhood means a lot to me,” DiPaolo says. “I’m excited to be part of the University of Pittsburgh again. As an alumni I have a lot of pride in that.”
DiPaolo believes heavy foot traffic in Oakland from the medical and educational workforce, as well as the sizable residential student population, will be a draw for the store, which will offer six of the top-selling Millie’s flavors and two rotating seasonal selections. The Oakland location will also be the third Millie’s to offer a robust coffee program, which Townsend thinks might eventually become a fixture at most scoop shops.
“If you pay rent 24 hours a day and don’t have a lot of people coming in before noon for ice cream, it makes sense to offer something else. It also adds to the experience. There’s a connection between ice cream and coffee,” he says.
The DiPaolos are partnering with Redhawk Coffee Roasters. The Sharpsburg-based roasters operate a shop near the Oakland location.
Next year will also mark the first expansion of Millie’s outside of Allegheny County, as it moves into neighboring Westmoreland County with Brian and Lori McBarron as the holders of franchise rights to the territory. The couple was considering a selection of franchise opportunities earlier in the year when they noticed a post on Millie’s Instagram announcing that the company was looking to expand its reach.
“We’d had their ice cream when they first started. We love how they’ve developed since then, and we love their focus on local ingredients,” says Lori McBarron, who holds a degree in nursing and recently went to school for pastry arts.
The McBarrons are aiming for a springtime opening for a Murrysville storefront. They live in the community, and it also happens to be where Townsend grew up. But it also makes good business sense to put a Millie’s there. Townsend says that the Market District in the city is the second-largest seller of Millie’s pints in the Giant Eagle chain.
“I don’t think it’s just all my high school friends that are buying all the Millie’s,” he jokes.
The Murrysville shop will have a first for Millie’s.
“We want to have a dedicated events space in the shop. We don’t have anything firm yet, but we’re hoping to have some trivia nights and game nights in the spot,” says Brian McBarron, a software engineer and independent game developer.
Greensburg and North Huntingdon will likely follow later next year, though leases are yet to be signed in those locations. In the meantime, theMcBarrons are launching a Millie’s ice cream truck, which will start rolling next month.
The big push forward for Millie’s won’t just bring sweet joy to the communities they’ll soon serve. It also deepens Millie’s relationship with Twin Brooks Dairy Co. The third-generation dairy, founded in 1952, supplies the creamery with all of its milk. Last year, Townsend said, he purchased 20,000 gallons from the Bentleyville farm, and that will grow exponentially this year. Townsend says the farm is going to be able to keep up.
“It’s important for us to support this farm in any way that we can. The relationship we have with them is a key to our product,” Townsend says. “The bottom line to all of this is I’m trying to make the best ice cream. That’s what we do.”
Hal B. Klein: hklein@post-gazette.com, Twitter @halbklein and IG @halbklein.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.