When it comes to Pittsburgh’s food festivals, perhaps no event carries the prestige of the Western Pennsylvania Lamb Fest.

First held on a street behind the former Ace Hotel in East Liberty in 2017, the fest — which draws more than 1,000 people — features a fun but still-competitive cook-off that pits some of the region’s best chefs against one another for the coveted People’s and Critic’s Choice awards.

The esteem that comes with winning the “best chef” title is one reason Jacqueline Schoedel and her husband, Nathan, of The Speckled Egg were on a team last year. It’s also why she elected not to enter this year’s open-air fest at SouthSide Works on Oct. 23: the expectant couple was due to have a baby in June, after which they’d be too busy to come up with a winning recipe, prep all the ingredients and then cook for a crowd.

At least that was the plan.

Advertise with us

Baby Bennett ended up coming three months early in April, weighing in at just 2 pounds 12 ounces. But as Schoedel happily noted earlier this month, “he’s a fighter and doing so well,” that she ended up going back on her pre-baby decision, and will now join Speckled Egg chef Sarah Baugher on a team with Cody Maze and Ariel Alexander of Stuntpig.

The Speckled Egg’s Jacqueline and Nathan Schoedel, with son Bennett. (Jacqueline Schoedel)

Why, when she’s still in the midst of endless diaper changes and bleary midnight feedings?

“Because it is so much fun and a good, healthy competition with the rest of the restaurants,” Schoedel said.

This is the fifth year for the festival, which will feature 11 collaborative teams composed from more than two-dozen of Pittsburgh’s top restaurants. Other than changing locations, the format has remained pretty much the same as in the beginning: Each squad is tasked with turning two whole lambs provided by Waynesburg-based Pure Bred and other locally sourced ingredients into something bite-sized and incredibly delicious for two very different audiences — the general lamb-loving public and of a team of celebrity judges and local food experts.

Last year, in something of a surprise victory, Chris Bonfili (Bonfire) and Cory Hughes (Fig and Ash) of Team Woodfire out-cooked three-time consecutive champion Roger Li (The Parlor Dim Sum, Umami, nanban) to take home both the People’s and Critic’s Choice awards with their lamb-filled lettuce cups. Schoedel warned the pair shouldn’t get too comfortable with the trophy.

Advertise with us
Sarah Baugher. (The Speckled Egg)

“We’re coming for them,” she said with a laugh.

Because it’s a breakfast restaurant that doesn’t normally see a lot of lamb on the menu, Schoedel acknowledges some might see The Speckled Egg as a dark-horse candidate for a top prize. “But it’s always delicious when we do get to cook with it,” she quickly added, “and we have so much great talent in the kitchen.”

That would include chef de cuisine Sarah Baugher, who spent several years cooking in fine dining and managing kitchens in Charleston, S.C., before moving to Pittsburgh in 2018 to work at the now-closed Dinette in East Liberty. Team Stuntpig/The Speckled Egg also benefits from the expert meat-cutting skills of the classically trained Alexander, who was a butcher at Whitefield in the Ace Hotel before launching the food truck with Maze in 2021.

Ariel Alexander and Cody Haze of Stuntpig. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

“I’m just the brains behind the operation, with these wonderful women backing me up,” said Schoedel, adding, “It’s really a team effort.”

Rather than go fancy, the team is going old-school familiar with a twist on an American classic you can find (and smell cooking) at any amusement park or carnival in the U.S.: a  savory, spicy cornmeal-battered lamb dog. It will come topped with a late-harvest chow chow Baugher crafts from pickled tomatillo, peppers and onions with a nice, bright vinegar pop.

Advertise with us

“When we fry it all together, it will really bring it home,” Schoedel said.

And if you want to judge for yourself whether their creation is a winning combo? Tickets are still available for the fest, which runs 1-5:30 p.m. Sunday at 27th and Sidney streets in the South Side and in the brand-new Town Square of SouthSide Works.

Or gather your own culinary crew and take the Stuntpig/The Speckled Egg festival recipe offered below for a test drive. Just know it feeds a crowd.

Lamb Corn Dogs

(Dave Bryce Photography)

Stuntpig’s lamb dogs paired with Sarah Baugher’s cornmeal topping and late-harvest chow chow make for one heck of a seasonal corn dog. This recipe makes enough to feed an entire team of lamb lovers.

Advertise with us

For lamb dogs

1 tablespoon coriander

1 tablespoon cumin seed

1 tablespoon fennel seed

1 tablespoon cinnamon

Advertise with us

2 teaspoons turmeric

1 tablespoon dried oregano

2 teaspoons ground pepper

3 tablespoons minced garlic

1 tablespoon dried ginger

Advertise with us

5 pound lamb shoulder, cubed

3 tablespoons salt

2 teaspoons sugar

2 teaspoons pink salt

2 cups ice water

Advertise with us

¼ cup dry red wine

2 tablespoons harissa

2 tablespoons dextrose

5 feet sheep casings

Oil for frying

Advertise with us

Wooden skewers

For chow chow

1 teaspoon chili flakes

3 bay leaves

1 tablespoon mustard seed

Advertise with us

1 tablespoons dried cloves

1 white onion, diced

1 pint diced red bell pepper

4 quarts diced pickled tomatillo or green tomatoes

3 cups sugar

Advertise with us

5 cups white vinegar

2 tablespoons salt

1 teaspoon mustard powder

1 teaspoon ground turmeric

For corn dog batter

Advertise with us

1½ cup cornmeal

1¼ cup all purpose flour

¼ cup sugar

1 tablespoon baking powder

¼ teaspoon salt

Advertise with us

1¾ cup buttermilk

1 egg

1 tablespoon olive oil

1 tablespoon honey

Prepare lamb dogs: Heat a dry pan or skillet under medium heat. Add coriander, cumin, fennel, cinnamon, turmeric, oregano, pepper, garlic and dried ginger, and toast for 2-3 minutes, stirring occasionally, until mixture is fragrant and visibly darker. Remove from pan, cool and grind.

Advertise with us

Grind lamb through small die. Combine meat with salt, sugar, pink salt and water. Mix by hand. Refrigerate overnight.

Add red wine, harissa and dextrose to lamb mixture, mix well, and then spread on sheet tray, and partially freeze. Grind through small die again. Spread on sheet tray. Partially freeze again.

Place meat mixture in food processor and puree into a paste. Check seasoning by frying a little of it in a pan, and adjust accordingly.

Stuff meat into casings and twist into 6-inch sausages. Hot smoke at 275 degrees to an internal temperature of 156 degrees, then chill in an ice bath. The dogs are now ready to label, date and refrigerate.

Prepare chow chow: Make herb sachet by placing chili flakes, bay leaves, mustard seed and cloves in the center of a square of cheesecloth. Gather the corners together to make a small pouch, tying it with kitchen string. Place sachet in a large pot with onion, pepper, tomatillo, sugar, vinegar, salt, mustard powder and turmeric. Cook over low heat until onion and pepper are tender. Cool, then pull out sachet.

Advertise with us

Strain off any excess liquid and pulse in food processor; set aside in jars or bowls.

Prepare batter. Mix dry and wet ingredients separately. Whisk wet into dry. Add buttermilk to thin out if needed.

When ready to make corn dogs, preheat oil in a deep saucepan over medium heat. Insert wooden skewers into lamb dogs.

Dip lamb dogs in batter until well coated. Add to hot oil and fry until lightly browned, about 3 minutes. Drain on paper towels.

Serve with chow chow.

Serves a crowd.

— Stuntpig and The Speckled Egg