Donatelli’s Italian Food Center will close its doors in August, after its owner was unable to find a new buyer to take it over. The family-owned specialty food store, with a slogan of “where traditions last a lifetime,” has operated in Bloomfield for 90 years.

Russell Donatelli, 62, the store’s owner, announced in November 2021 that the business would have to shutter unless he found a new buyer. In the intervening months, Donatelli said, “several people” were interested in buying the business, but after much back and forth, those opportunities ultimately “fizzled out.” “People wanted to get things a lot cheaper than what they are really worth, let’s put it that way,” he said.

The store announced its official closure today on its website and on Facebook late Tuesday, to an outpouring of comments mourning its loss. Donaelli’s will officially close once it sells out of its current inventory, which Donatelli estimated will occur before the end of August. All dry products will be 20% off.

“It hurts because I thought I had a few more years in me to continue doing this,” Donatelli said about the store’s closure. “It’s just not feasible for me to continue doing what I’m doing.”

Advertise with us

Donatelli has been the sole owner of the business since his father and brother passed away in 2015 and 2016, respectively. For the past six years, he’s been working overtime to pick up the slack himself, regularly putting in 12-hour days to keep the business afloat. “It’s been pretty brutal on me,” he said. “It was overwhelming.”

Russell Donatelli hands an order to Bloomfield’s Gloria LeDonne, who said she shops at the store often, on Wednesday. (Vanessa Abbitt / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

COVID “absolutely” impacted his decision to close the business, he said. “The other big box stores around and their ways of delivering food to people and shopping for them left a small businessman like myself out of the loop.” Donatelli also had trouble finding employees he felt were a good fit for the family-owned store.

"I hate to see the place go, but what can you do?,” said employee Chrissy Octavi, of Bloomfield, who has worked at the shop for 11 years and known Russell Donatelli across three decades.

The business’ closure marks the end of a family tradition. Donatelli’s was founded in 1932 by Frank Donatelli and George Rosato, and served deli meats, fresh pasta and other Italian specialties to Bloomfield’s Italian immigrant community. After Russell Donatelli’s grandfather bought out Rosato in 1960 and added his son Paul Donatelli as a partner, Donatelli’s became a true family affair. Russell and his brother Paul Jr. were the third generation to take it over and, under their ownership, the business expanded its menu and maintained a loyal customer base.

This deli counter comes with advice. (Vanessa Abbitt / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Russell Donatelli, who has worked at the store since the age of 8, has fond memories of spending time with his family at Donatelli’s over the years. Every New Year’s Eve growing up, three generations of Donatellis would spend the holiday eating sandwiches and doing inventory. “You just can’t forget things like that.”

Advertise with us

Without a fourth generation to take it over, the family business is coming to an end, but Russell Donatelli said his extended family fully supports his decision. “They know I’ve done everything I can possibly do to keep this place going,” he said.

After the store’s closure, Donatelli said he’s not sure what he will do next, though he’s not quite ready to retire. “I’m going to have to go out and shop around for a new opportunity for myself,” he said. For now, he is focused on the logistics of Donatelli’s closure. The family will still try to sell the building.

“All I can say is: Thanks to everyone in the area and the surrounding area for patronizing our store,” he said. “We will miss you.”

Donatelli's has been a Bloomfield staple for nine decades. (Vanessa Abbitt / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Maliya Ellis:mellis@post-gazette.com and Twitter @EllisMaliya.

Additional reporting by Vanessa Abbitt.