Customers waiting in the deli line at Donatelli’s Italian Food Center in Bloomfield on Wednesday ordered pulled pork sandwiches (fish was sold out), sausage and other meats -- and pondered the market’s future. A woman standing at the bread rack looked especially worried. When owner Russell Donatelli walked past, she asked, “You’re going to close?”

“We’re going to try to stay open as long as we can,” he replied.

His grandfather Frank Donatelli and George Rosato opened the store in 1932 on Liberty Avenue, and it quickly became a place where Italian immigrants could go to catch a whiff of the old country and pick up some of the items they remembered eating in Italy. Russell Donatelli represents the third generation of his family to operate the market (his family bought out Rosato in 1960). There is no fourth generation to continue the tradition. Mr. Donatelli is looking for a buyer. The question everyone asks is: Will someone with the resources and commitment to the community step up?

Sandy Falcione awaits an answer. Standing at a butcher block table near the back door, she fed strips of dough into a machine that turned out small pasta shells called cavatelli. She’s been performing work like this at Donatelli’s for 28 years. “My great aunt worked here when I first started,” she said. “She worked on this very spot.”

Advertise with us

A picture of that great aunt, Rose Acquafondata, is taped to a nearby wall, as is a playful picture of a longtime customer sticking out her tongue. Ms. Falcione knows all the regulars, like Linda Ficorilli, 80, who paused her shopping to sit on the lip of a produce counter and reminisce. Ms. Falcione stood nearby and listened attentively. At one point, the two clasped hands and pondered the potential loss of the market.

“I come here every day,” Ms. Ficorilli said. “I miss it already.”

This picture of Donatelli’s is dated November 1964. When Donatelli’s opened in 1932, the neighborhood was filled with Italian immigrants. (Steve Mellon/Steve Mellon/Post-Gazette)
A picture of a playful and longtime customer named Mary stares out at Sandy Falcione as she makes cavatelli at Donatelli’s. Ms. Falcione has worked at the market for 28 years. When she started, her great aunt Rose Acquafondata also worked at the market. (Steve Mellon/Steve Mellon/Post-Gazette)
Carmela and Bill Wolf look over the selection of meats at Donatelli’s. (Steve Mellon/Steve Mellon/Post-Gazette)
A bit of humor is taped to the meat display case at Donatelli’s. (Steve Mellon/Steve Mellon/Post-Gazette)
Russell Donatelli waits on customers during the lunch rush. (Steve Mellon/Steve Mellon/Post-Gazette)
A customer exits Donatelli’s at 4711 Liberty Ave. in Bloomfield. (Steve Mellon/Steve Mellon/Post-Gazette)