Ben Fine studied communications at the University of Pittsburgh. Yet even before graduation, the Squirrel Hill native knew he’d never use his degree to make a living, because it was food that made him truly happy.

Like a lot of millennials, the 35-year-old co-owner of BB & Bur Pastry Kitchen and Bakery in Wilkinsburg watched his share of cooking shows on TV as a teen. He was particularly bowled-over by pasties and other baked goods. Recalling a Jamie Deen coconut cake he made long ago still makes him smile.

Co-owner Will Marrow, 33, was simpatico in every respect. An artistic kid who grew up in a large, extended family in McKeesport —  he has 27 first cousins — he baked with his mother for every holiday and family party. Along the way, he went from the child who sat and unwrapped the hundreds of Hershey’s Kisses for peanut blossoms to the teenager who translated the painting and drawing skills he honed in high school into decorating sweets.

Always-popular cupcakes come in inventive flavors. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

They met in 2008 at Pennsylvania Culinary Institute’s pastry arts program. Kindred spirits, they ended up working together at East Liberty’s Vanilla Pastry Studio for around two years, after Marrow’s first job at Oakmont Bakery. Fine then got into restaurant management at the Bagel Factory and Square Cafe, while Marrow moved on to jobs at Eleven and Bella Christie & Lil Z’s Sweet Boutique.

Advertise with us

They married in 2016 and two years later, while Marrow was working as the bread maker at Eleven, started a side gig making cakes and pastries in a church basement in Verona.

They’d been baking for friends and family at their Blackridge home for a while, Fine says. Yet in order to pursue their dream of someday opening their own bakery, they needed a dedicated space, “and the church had a big kitchen.”

Word soon spread, much like their gourmet melted chocolate, about their all-natural offerings — many of them gluten-free or vegan — and before long, the couple was also making treats for friends of friends. They also supplied local shops including Mechanic Coffee Co. with product and did a bang-up wholesale business for all six of Coffee Tree Roasters’ locations, 7 days a week.

Fine fills orders. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

In May 2021, after Fine left his job at Square Cafe, they decided “now or never, “ and signed a lease on a former art gallery space in Wilkinsburg. Following a 3-month renovation, they opened, while everyone was still wearing masks on Sept. 7, and were immediately overwhelmed with business, says Fine.

The tiny storefront at 317 S. Trenton Ave. has not missed a beat since, becoming one of the neighborhood’s most popular destinations not just for grown-ups, but for kids walking home after school in search of a snack.

Advertise with us

“We get all different walks of life, because there’s something for everyone,” says Marrow, with most of their pastries costing $3 or less.

Each day brings something a little different in the shop’s display cases, depending on what strikes the bakers’ fancy that morning; one recent Thursday, applesauce chai muffins and vegan brownies joined a giant jar of their famed burnt sugar ginger cookies on the counter. Over in the cupcake corner, flavor choices included chocolate espresso and red velvet along with vanilla brushed with an Earl Grey glaze.

It took Marrow six hours to create this SpongeBob SquarePants groom's cake, using fondant on top of a vanilla cake layered with raspberry buttercream. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The bakery also boasts a wide variety of brownies, scones, blondies and sandwich cookies, including its signature oatmeal cream “pies” filled with homemade marshmallow buttercream. Among the bakery’s more nostalgic offerings, they bring to mind Little Debbies, were the snack cakes made with really good ingredients.

“We use so much butter,” says Fine with a laugh — sometimes as much as 120 pounds a week.

The men also are whizzes at custom birthday and wedding cakes (prices start at $100 for two layers with buttercream), and their French macarons come in a rainbow of colors and flavors. Fridays bring focaccia in savory flavors; weekend star plays include cinnamon buns, biscuits and  “heart tarts” filled with homemade jam.

Advertise with us

Everything is scratch made, including the chocolate syrup. They even hand-color their cupcake sprinkles. And the testing? It’s  exhaustive, “because we have to like it to put it out,” says Marrow.

Weekend specials include "heart tarts" filled with homemade jam. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Both men are skilled at what they do, but Marrow notes each has his strengths. Thanks to the painting, drawing and ceramics classes he took in high school, he’s more artistic, able to recreate just about any object in cake and fondant. For a recent wedding at Eden Hall, for example, he crafted a groom’s cake that captured the cartoon character SpongeBob SquarePants to a T. Fine, with his background in management, is way better at the business side and organization.

“I’m a bit of a mad scientist,” says Marrow, with a laugh, “but Ben’s a better baker.”

That said, they’re always on the same page. “He will say something while I’m thinking it,” says Fine.

Marrow works on one of his creations. (Pam Panchak / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Naming a business is always tricky, especially when the goal is to be thought-provoking without being weird.  A single name was “too trendy,” says Fine, so instead, they went with an amalgamation of their nicknames — BB for “Baker Ben” and “Bur”  for Marrow’s childhood nickname Wilbur.

Advertise with us

“We’re proud of what we’ve done, and pulled off,” Fine says. “We’re on a great street that we love, and the neighborhood response has been so good.”

“It feels great to know we have a great product,” agrees Marrow, “and I love seeing what customers like and don’t like every day.”

BB & Bur Pastry Kitchen and Bakery: 317 S. Trenton Ave., Wilkinsburg. Open 8 a.m.-4 p.m. Tuesdays-Saturdays, 9 a.m.-2 p.m. Sundays; closed Mondays.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pittsburghpgfood.