Fun Fact: Well before he began a decades-long television comedy career, actor Ed O’Neill was a star defensive lineman for the Youngstown State Penguins and in 1969 was drafted by the Steelers.

He didn’t quite have the stuff to beat out two other defensive lineman in his rookie class — the luminary “Mean” Joe Greene and L.C. “Hollywood Bags” Greenwood. That ultimately propelled him to Hollywood, where his work culminated in multiple Emmy nominations for his role as Jay Pritchett on ABC’s “Modern Family.”

That’s also where his incredulous Jay memorably learned the actual name of a well-curated meat and cheese board.

“That’s charcuterie? I’ve been avoiding that on menus for years. They’re killing themselves with that name!”

Advertise with us

He’s not wrong in the sense that charcuterie is just a gussied up way to say “awesome spread of stuff to nosh on.”

It is also the perfect paradox for a Super Bowl party — a crowd pleaser that’s also unpredictable.

Football is the ultimate team sport and so, too, is a proper charcuterie spread. The components should be complementary, with a wide variety of flavors and textures, ideally made to be grazed all day long while quaffing beers or heavy pours of red wine, while you’re frantically checking the status of your six-way parlay on FanDuel.

You’ve got your cheeses, the quarterbacks of the operation, the glory boys. You can assemble the greatest collection of meats and other stuff, but if you roll out here with Kraft singles as your field general, you’re done.

Defense wins championships, and its analogous counterpart here is the meat. These are the nose tackles and linebackers that bring the brawn.

Advertise with us

The carbs are the offensive linemen — the foundation, the building blocks. The whole thing falls apart without them.

Finally, all the rest of the accoutrements are the playmakers, the wide receivers, running backs and tight ends that bring the brine, the bite, the heat, the sweet, the savory. They’re what bring excitement to the spread.

To that end, the Post-Gazette Food staff has put together an ultimate Super Bowl charcuterie spread in the style of a fantasy football draft, using as many local products and purveyors as possible.

Goat Rodeo Farm’s Bamboozle is washed in beer. (Alexandra Wimley / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Round 1

Gretchen McKay: Manchego Gran Riserva cheese is a lead-pipe lock for a first overall pick. This 12-month aged firm Spanish cheese “will change you” per the description on the website for Chantal’s in Bloomfield. ($34.99/pound)

Advertise with us

Polly Higgins: Seltzer’s Lebanon bologna – An old school, throwback type a la Cam Heyward, Seltzer’s Smokehouse Meats has been making the savory-sweet meat for a century in Lebanon County and can be readily found at Giant Eagle. ($3.29 package)

Bob Batz Jr.: Tastebud touchdowns don’t score themselves and Artisan Sourdough Crackers from Nobby's Bakery in Scott are an ideal delivery device for whatever you put on them. Available in rosemary, cheese, sesame and sea salt flavors ($4 for a half pound).

Dan Gigler: Fresh off a best-in-show blue ribbon at the PA Farm Show, Goat Rodeo’s Bamboozle goat and cow milk cheese is like Bengals QB Joe Burrow — a can’t-miss stud. Described as a “supple, semi-soft texture with notes of prosciutto and peanuts,” it’s aged for at least two months and washed with “Tracks Again,” an unfiltered pilsner from Cinderlands Beer Co. in the Strip District. ($20.99/pound)

Salonika Imports in Lawrenceville is a must for olives. (Andrew Rush / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Round 2

DG: The ultimate firestick, Delallo’s Hot Pepper Dry Sausage is a traditional Italian air-cured hard sausage that’s “hand-rubbed with hot red pepper flakes for a taste of true Southern Italian heat.” ($9.99 at Giant Eagle)

Advertise with us

BB: Sticking with the heat, the call here is Lawrence County's Pasture Maid Creamery's spicy Frew Mill Fire, which is "A creamery farmstead cheese enlivened with dried hot peppers." ($7.99 at Giant Eagle).

PH: Call this Walter Payton, because Freedom Farms Fig Jam brings the sweetness, with the kind of viscosity that makes for versatility. It’s $6 for a 16-ounce jar at its namesake farmers market in Butler and the Bloomfield Saturday Winter Farmers Market.

GM: Every good team needs role players that come up big, and that’s what a pint of the Mas Portell Olive Cocktail Mix from Salonika Imports in Lawrenceville will do. Per its website, it is “the ultimate Spanish mix of specially selected whole green and black olives, small caperberries, gherkins, red peppers and garlic which have been marinated in their own extra virgin olive oil with a special herb seasoning to finish this collaboration.” ($4.99/pound)

BreadWorks Bakery offers plenty of options for your spread. (Bob Batz Jr. / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Round 3

GM: The Post-Gazette’s resident prosciutto expert couldn’t believe that Prosciutto Di Parma ($24.59/pound at Penn Mac) hadn’t been picked yet. This is like the Patriots taking a flier on Tom Brady 22 years ago.

Advertise with us

PH: Like a hybrid player with “positional flexibility,” as Mike Tomlin would say, BreadWorks’ Rustic Stick is kind of a baguette, kind of an Italian bread, and is easy to pull apart with that just-right ratio of crusty exterior to pliable interior. ($4 at the bakery)

BB: With apologies to Kordell Stewart, Penn Mac’s pepper shooters are the ultimate ’slash combo: pickled hot peppers, green and red, stuffed with prosciutto and sharp provolone. These are a must on game day snack trays ($12.39 per half dozen).

DG: The 1980s Miami Dolphins had a Killer B’s defense and the 2010s Steelers had a Killer B’s offense. Neither won a Super Bowl. And while any kind of honey would go perfect with the cheeses on the roster, go big or go home with Washington County’s Bedillion Honey Farm pure honeycomb ($19.99 for 12 ounces at Market District).

Head to Pitaland for baba ganoush. (Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Round 4

DG: Not unlike using a draft pick on a kicker or punter, this is a polarizing choice that people will love or hate. But Agostino Recca Anchovies in olive oil with hot peppers go fantastic with cheese and crackers ($6.39 at Penn Mac).

Advertise with us

BB: A vegetarian nod on a charcuterie plate? Why not. Brookline's Pitaland's stuffed grape leaves are just good, whatever your diet ($6 per half dozen).

PH: Blair County-based Clover Creek Cheese Cellar crafts numerous flavors, but if the goal is something a little extra-special, put their limited-edition wild mushroom cheddar in the lineup. It’s $4.99 for 4-ounces at the Clover Creek site, and can also be found at the East End Co-op, Stamoolis Brothers and Freedom Farms.

GM: Because hummus is basic, the pick here is smoky, silky Baba Ganoush from Pitaland — and pick up some pita while you’re there.

Round 5

GM: Located right on the lip of Rams phenom Aaron Donald’s hometown of Penn Hills, Allegheny City Farms is known for its hot sauce, but its Pittsburgh Pub Mustard is what’s needed here. This unique take on a traditional Bavarian beer “Pub Style” mustard infuses smoked porter from Rock Bottom Brewery and combines choice vinegars, brown and yellow mustard seed, wildflower honey and spices. ($14)

Advertise with us

PH: Spicy Whiskey Pickles are the John Riggins of this spread: It's a bit boozy and packs a wallop. These crispy slices, from Latrobe's The Pickled Chef, get an extra kick from dried chilis. ($9 Bloomfield Saturday Winter Farmers Market)

BB: Like a small-school pick that becomes a star, the smoked salmon from Bobbi Jo's Smokery is a sleeper. She smokes it (and bacon) herself, and it’s at a couple of Giant Eagles now (White Oak, Ligonier, soon Harrison City) and at farmers markets in season, including Mt. Lebanon's.

DG: The last pick of the NFL Draft is affectionately dubbed “Mr. Irrelevant,” but Bell-View Foods pickled pepperoncini is anything but — rather, it’s a classic. ($5.99 per 32-ounce jar at Giant Eagle)

Dan Gigler: gdgigler@post-gazette.com; @gigs412 on Instagram and Twitter.