An easy and safe way to carve a turkey
For the Thanksgiving dinner host, no job is as fraught with anxiety as carving the holiday turkey.
It’s the meal’s centerpiece, so the pressure is on. No one wants to ruin the moment by hacking the bird into unrecognizable pieces when the expectation is you’ll carve it into picture-perfect slices with a sliver of golden-brown crispy skin.
It can be especially scary for female cooks who haven’t had to carve in the past because that honor traditionally falls on the patriarch of the family. I’m a prime example. One of my dad’s most prized possessions was his electric carving knife. When he finally relinquished his role as head carver, he bequeathed it not to me, the actual cook in the family, but to my husband.
Neish Reed, a private chef and caterer who next month will open Lulu’s, a restaurant serving elevated Cajun and Creole fare in Wilkinsburg, has a theory on why so many are stressed by carving a turkey.
“It’s because it’s so big,” she says, noting that some birds weigh 20 or more pounds. Since it’s the meal’s highlight, “people are afraid to approach it.”
Yet “anyone can do it” with the proper tools and a bit of self-confidence, says Reed, a Woodland Hills graduate who studied to be a chef at the Art Institute of Pittsburgh and now lives in North Braddock. “It’s super easy.”
Read More
She breaks it down into seven easy steps that begin with doing nothing:
Give it a rest
Let the turkey rest for at least 30 minutes after it comes out of the oven, and up to 45 minutes for larger birds. Besides allowing the turkey to cool so you can safely touch it, resting lets the meat reabsorb its juices so they don’t dribble out onto the cutting board while you’re slicing.
Another friendly tip: Resist the temptation to reenact Norman Rockwell’s famed Thanksgiving painting, which depicts Grandpa standing at the head of the table, ready to carve. Carving is best done behind the scenes in the kitchen, where messes (and mistakes) are hidden from view.
Know avian anatomy
The first step in successfully carving a turkey, says Reed, is knowing its parts. Focus on six sections: legs, thighs, wings, breast, tenderloin (the thick strip of meat between the breasts) and wishbone. Also identify the dark, triangular keel bone in the center of the breast.
Get the right tools
The most dangerous item in any kitchen is a dull knife because it requires more pressure to cut, which increases the chance the knife will slip. So whatever size chef knife you use (Reed uses a 5½-inch Shun knife), make sure it’s super sharp so you have more control.
Also, trade the meat carving fork for your (gloved) hand. It will give you a better grip on the bird and won’t pierce or tear the flesh like a fork.
Start with the legs
The wings might seem like a good place to begin, but they actually add stability during carving. Reed starts with the legs, pulling them back from the breast to expose the hip joint. Then cut through the joint and any attached skin.
“The knife will show you exactly where you want to go,” she says, which is straight down in a natural line.
Use your hands to pop the leg back, then cut through the joint to separate the leg from the breast. Remove to a platter and repeat with the second leg.
Using a finger, identify the joint that connects the thigh and drumstick and cut through it. You can cut the meat off the thigh bone — which isn’t as pretty as a drumstick — by slicing on either side.
From 2015: Big Burrito Group executive chef Bill Fuller demonstrates his turkey-carving technique.
How to carve a turkey
The white meat
Remove the breast by feeling for the keel bone, then making a long, thin cut alongside it, following it all the way down along the breast bone.
“Let your knife do all your work for you,” Reed says, by pressing the back of the knife up while letting the bone tell you where to go. Then, make one slice on the side along the rib cage, and lift off the whole side of the breast in one piece.
Place the breast on a cutting board and slice against the grain (crosswise) into nice, even slices (thick or thin, your choice). Try to leave a bit of skin on each piece. Transfer the meat to the platter with the legs. Repeat with the other breast.

Wings off
Remove the wings the same way you separated the drumstick and thigh, by pulling the wing out until you see the joint. Twist or cut the wing away from the breast with the knife (it should pull away easily). If you like, separate the drummettes from the middle wings by cutting between the joint. Remove to the platter.
Because no one likes to waste food, least of all a chef, Reed always goes back and carves the rest of the meat off the carcass, both light and dark.
“I don’t believe in leaving any meat behind,” she says.
Reheat, repurpose
The turkey by now has cooled to room temperature. To warm it up, heat the carved meat in a 375-degree oven for about 5 minutes, then arrange on a platter. If you have extra herbs from the rest of your holiday meal, use them to garnish the plated turkey. Sage, thyme and rosemary work especially well.
Save the carcass for stocks and sauces, says Reed. “Nothing should go to waste” on the day we give thanks for all we have.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or IG @pgrecipes.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.