LOGAN, Ohio — Derek Mills is an IT guy, a job that requires him to be inquisitive, think critically and solve problems. Those same qualities also fuel his love of history, especially when it involves growing “weird things.”
He’s particularly fascinated by antique apple varieties, chief among them Decio, a small yellow-green fruit that dates all the way back to 454 A.D.
Another favorite is Court Pendu Plat, an extremely old French cultivar with a creamy white flesh, also known as the “wise” apple because it has the smarts to bloom late in spring.
Mr. Mills grows both in his 12-acre apple orchard in southeast Ohio.
The seeds of his passion were sown early: An Air Force brat who was born in Puerto Rico, Mr. Mills earned his Eagle Scout badge by identifying and labeling tropical fruits on an abandoned fruit-growing station on Ramey Air Force Base. The experience cemented a lifelong love affair for the fruit colonists once called “winter banana.”
Yet he didn’t try his hand at grafting and growing an old-school apple until 1983, after reading a magazine article on the history of the Newton Pippin.
Read More

One of the first apples grown in the U.S. (it originated in the late 17th century), the Newton Pippin also was one of the first apples to be exported to England, around 1759. But what really intrigued Mr. Mills, who was working as a network operations center analyst in Columbus, was the author’s claim that the late-harvest apple was one of George Washington’s favorites.
Curious as to how he gleaned that tasty bit of trivia, he wrote him a letter. The writer, in turn, told him about North American Fruit Explorers, a group of enthusiasts who share practical information about growing and enjoying fruits and nuts. Then, Mr. Mills sent a second letter to NAFEX asking for a cutting.
Someone sent one, and he successfully grafted it onto rootstock. An obsession was born.
Over the next two decades, he grafted 75 apple trees of 55 different varieties in a small orchard behind his home in Pinkerington. It was, he says, “a hobby that ran amok.”

In 2001, Mr. Mills and his wife, Lisa, moved south to a 55-acre property in Logan, Ohio, and started Hocking Hills Orchard at Four Seasons Cabins. Today, the self-described “apple geek” grows more than 1,700 varieties of apples in three spots. Many are common and popular modern apples, such as Braeburn, Fuji, Gala and Jonalicious. But he’s also made a name for himself with the orchard’s many heirloom and unusual varieties, such as the aforementioned Decio, which he says was eaten by the Romans before battles with Attila the Hun.
Named for the general who carted the apples to northern Italy from Rome, they’re not very tasty (The skin is bitter). But Mr. Mills loves the fact he’s growing the same fruit that ancient soldiers noshed on before picking up spears against their nomadic enemy. “It’s the history,” he says.
Other little-known varieties have their own interesting histories. The Court Pendu Plat “wise” apple also dates back to Roman times. Some are good for cider-making (Hen’s Turd, Muscadet de Dieppe) or have curious names (the bright-pink Hoary Morning or yellow Goose’s Arse). He selected others for their unusual colors; the orchard boasts some 260 varieties of red-, pink- and orange-fleshed apples like Burford's Red Flesh (aka Clifford), which has solid pink blossoms instead of the white flowers found on most apple trees.

The best part is that all are available to pick yourself on Sunday afternoons from late summer to late fall. Each comes with a “geek sheet” detailing the apple’s flavor, backstory and ribboned location among the rows. Mr. Mills admits that finding a particular apple can feel a little like a game of “Where’s Waldo?” on a hillside with 74 rows. A half-peck bag costs $8.
“Some people only make it to row 24 and quit,” he says with a laugh.
Apples can be shipped along with apple blossom honey from the orchard’s hives, and Mr. Mills sometimes conducts tastings in his backyard. (For details and to make sure U-pick is available, visit the orchard’s Facebook page or hockinghillsorchard.com.)
Eager to spread the gospel of old-school apples, he also sell scions for grafting so anyone can try a hand at propagating, and he offers apple education programs for schoolkids.
In addition, Mr. Mills grows 125 varieties of heirloom pears and 125 varieties of grapes, including a “Jesus grape” grown from a cutting he acquired from Catholic monks in Washington state.
Two hundred years ago, he says, apple lovers could choose from thousands of varieties in many shapes, sizes and colors — sweet and tart, some with stripes, others with splashes and dots. Today, only about 100 varieties of apples are grown commercially in the U.S., with Gala, Red Delicious and Granny Smith the most popular on grocery store shelves.
“I want people to come out and taste something new, and learn something,” Mr. Mills says. To that end, he grafts about 400 new trees a year.
What you find on any particular day depends on the time of year you’re picking. In August, Erwin Bauer and Red Devil are plentiful, while in October, Crow Egg (an oblong eating or dessert apple dating to the 1800s) and Black Gilliflower (a possible parent of Red Delicious) are among the stars.
On a visit earlier this month, Mr. Mills pointed out a tree laden with one of his favorites — plum-colored Raven, a dessert variety — before heading to his back porch to lay out a tasting of a half-dozen unusual apples. It included Purpurroter Cousinot, a red-fleshed apple from the Netherlands; Green and Newton Pippins; Cornish Aromatic Cornwall, a crisp dessert apple from England; and Esopus Spitzenburg, a reputed sweet-tart favorite of Thomas Jefferson’s.
He cautions visitors that his orchard doesn’t look like a “regular” orchard, with perfectly groomed trees and shiny, flawless fruit. Heirlooms tend to be less visually appealing than grocery store apples, with odd shapes, weird colors and sometimes lumpy or bumpy skins. He also doesn’t use an irrigation system or pesticides, which can lead to small fruit with surface blemishes and blotches.
He’s OK being a bit of an outlier.
“We’re not Kroger’s or Walmart,” he says. “We’re going for taste, not looks” in each delicious bite of history.
Hocking Hills Orchard is at 14435 Nickel Plate Road, Logan, OH 43138. For U-pick hours, available varieties and other information, call (614) 570-9859 or go to hockinghillsorchard.com.
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay or Instagram @pgrecipes.
_____________

Dutch Apple Cake (Appeltaart)
PG tested
This old-fashioned apple cake is a loaf version of a traditional Dutch apple pie. Choose a firm, tart baking apple such as Braeburn, Jonagold, Northern Spy or the all-time favorites Granny Smith or Honeycrisp. Serve it plain, or with a scoop of vanilla ice cream or dollop of sweet whipped cream. It’s also terrific toasted and slathered with honey butter for breakfast.
3 medium tart apples, peeled and cut into ¼-inch slices, about 3 cups
3 tablespoons plus 1 cup sugar, divided
1 teaspoon ground cinnamon
⅔ cup butter, softened
4 large eggs, room temperature
1 teaspoon vanilla extract
2 cups all-purpose flour
⅛ teaspoon salt
In large bowl, combine apples, 3 tablespoons sugar and cinnamon. Let stand one hour.
In another bowl, cream butter and remaining sugar until light and fluffy. Add one egg at a time, beating well after each addition. Add vanilla.
Combine flour and salt, then gradually add to creamed mixture and beat until smooth.
Transfer batter to a greased 9-by-5-inch loaf pan. Push apple slices vertically into batter, placing them close together.
Bake at 300 degrees for about 1½ hours, or until toothpick inserted in the center comes out clean. Cool for 10 minutes before removing from pan to a wire rack.
Serve warm.
Makes 1 loaf.
— Hocking Hills Orchard






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.