Pastry chef Selina Progar came home to Pittsburgh in 2016 to take a break. That didn’t really work out for her, though.

Instead, she was propelled into the most prestigious culinary position she’d held to date: executive pastry chef at Altius in Mount Washington, bolstering the city’s pastry scene while putting to the test the skills she’d learned over a nomadic culinary career.

Now, Ms. Progar has become head baker at Gluten Free Goat, a job that has her creating recipes and shepherding each product from start to finish.

The gluten-free bakery launched in 2017 as a retail business on Penn Avenue in Garfield. After pivoting to wholesale during the pandemic, it now offers its products at Adda Coffee & Tea House, Mediterra Bakehouse and the Speckled Egg while also taking orders for pickup and delivery on Tuesdays and Fridays at glutenfreegoat.com.

Advertise with us

The journey from culinary student to pastry chef was a meandering one that landed Ms. Progar, 29, in some unexpected places.

Ten years ago, after graduating from the Culinary Institute of America in Hyde Park, N.Y., she was considering an externship at Remini Gelato in Colorado that fit her passion for making truffles and ice cream. But it was unpaid. So she took a job at one of Pittsburgh’s most beloved bakeshops, Bethel Bakery.

Learning the ins and outs of a high-production bakery gave her a solid foundation on which to build her career. In particular, the many cakes she decorated on a daily basis helped hone her patience and precision. It’s a practice Ms. Progar keeps up today, as evidenced by her Instagram feed.

“That skill is just timeless,” she says.

She also learned, however, that a large-scale bakery wasn’t the perfect fit. She wanted her hands in every part of the process instead of being part of a greater assembly line of bakers.

Advertise with us

“I like going from flour and sugar all the way to watching the person eat it,” she says.

Ms. Progar eventually found that start-to-finish satisfaction in the early days of La Gourmandine in Lawrenceville, where she was hired part-time in 2012.

Then La Gourmandine took off, and so did Ms. Progar. “I went from being just a part-time girl who made pastry cream and tart shells to being the head baker.”

Armed with new business management skills but still quite young, she yearned for adventure, so she let spontaneity take the lead. It led her to a five-diamond restaurant in Nantucket, Mass., Toppers at the Wauwinet.

“My friend called me at, like, midnight, and was like ‘We need an assistant pastry chef, and I thought about you. Do you want to come work?’ And I was like, ‘Yeah, I do. That sounds like so much fun,” she says, laughing.

Advertise with us

It was fun — and busy. Nantucket island is notoriously packed every summer, which meant Topper’s was as well.

“It was 180 people every single night, for two months,” she says.

With their pre-fixe menu, pretty much everyone got a dessert.

“I’d plate desserts continuously,” she says, “but I loved the rush.”

Ms. Progar bounced to another five-diamond resort in Park City, Utah, then back to Topper’s the next summer, with a side gig at a farm on Nantucket. While she loved the nomadic life, at least for a while, “the hours were really intense,” she says. She was working 60 hours a week, sometimes more, and balancing two jobs.

Advertise with us

“I was beaten down by the end of the season and just needed to take a breather.”

So she came home for a long rest. At least that was the plan.

After making some calls to find an easy part-time gig, Ms. Progar suddenly found herself signing on to be the executive pastry chef at Altius. It was her first time in the top pastry position — at just 24 years old.

“I’m not sure I was really ready, but I made myself ready.

“I wanted to be the person who made the best desserts in the city of Pittsburgh.”

Advertise with us

Hers were up there, and Ms. Progar loved the work. Still, she was hungry for adventure. “I wanted to test myself and learn something different.”

She found it right in her own backyard, at Gluten Free Goat.

“With gluten-free baking, everything that you knew about baking and pastry is the complete opposite,” Ms. Progar explains. “Mixing times are different, how you add your products is different. You can’t just take a recipe that includes gluten and just sub out blends.”

She breaks down each recipe and builds it back up again, all while reducing the amount of gums and creating vegan options.

One of her best products is a gluten-free sourdough baguette. She also just added both savory and sweet “pop tarts” to the menu. Choices include mixed berry with hibiscus glaze, fudge and marshmallow, bacon, egg and cheese and a cream cheese “everything” bomb.

Advertise with us

If these sound good even to “glutenivores,” that’s the point.

“I want someone who doesn’t have a gluten intolerance to eat the food I’ve made and not say ‘That’s gluten-free.’ I just want them to say, ‘That’s food, and that’s good.’”

Ali Trachta: alitrachta@gmail.com or on Twitter @alitrachta.

Gluten-free Chocolate Chip Cookies

4½ ounces oat flour

Advertise with us

4¾ ounces brown rice flour

2¼ ounces potato starch

3-finger pinch of salt

1 teaspoon baking powder

1 teaspoon psyllium husk powder

Advertise with us

2 sticks butter, melted

5 ounces sugar

5 ounces brown sugar

1 teaspoon vanilla

2 eggs

Advertise with us

12 ounces chocolate chips

Combine dry ingredients and whisk until combined

In mixing bowl, add melted butter, sugars, vanilla and eggs. Add dry ingredients and mix to combine. Stir in chocolate chips.

Add cookie mixture to bowl of a stand mixer, and mix on medium-high (6/8) for 2 minutes. Remove batter to a large bowl, and chill in refrigerator for 2 hours or overnight.

Preheat oven to 325 degrees.

Advertise with us

Scoop cookie batter onto cookie sheets and bake for 12 minutes.

Makes 2 to 3 dozen cookies, depending on the size of scoop.

— Selina Progar, Gluten Free Goat