Like most local parishes, St. Sava Serbian Orthodox Church in McKeesport was hit pretty hard in the pocketbook when the coronavirus outbreak unfolded this spring.

Usually St. Sava can count on seven fish fries in the weeks leading up to Easter. “But of course we only got two,” said Dorothy Ikach, who has sung in the church’s choir since she was 14.

The tiny parish, which dates back to 1901, took another hit when what would have been its 61st annual International Village in McKeesport's Renziehausen Park was canceled in August.

In a non-COVID year, the three-day festival would draw upward of 15,000 hungry visitors, who would fill up on St. Sava’s lamb sandwiches, haluski, apple strudel and palachinke — thin, crepe-like pancakes filled with sweet cheese. Proceeds from the fest help pay for emergency repairs and renovations, a Serbian Diocese summer camp near Conneaut, and the preservation of the church’s heritage.

Advertise with us

So Mrs. Ikach and her fellow parishioners came up with a plan.

In early October, the church held a Small Taste of Serbia takeout event featuring classic Serbian foods and baked goods. So many people showed up that St. Sava not only ran out of stuffed cabbage on day one but also quickly exhausted its supply of 450 strudels and some 500 palachinke. It went through all 250 pounds of marinated boneless lamb for sandwiches.

“It was very difficult to project how much to prepare, because COVID restrictions kept changing,” said Mrs. Ikach of the planning that began in late July. But clearly, they were on to something.

“I counted wrong,” admitted Joann Rocknage, the Rev. Stevan Rocknage’s wife, who oversees the kitchen. “But I didn’t think we would sell out.”

To right the wrong of disappointing many its community members, the church will hold a second takeout event coinciding with the start of the Advent season — the Christian period of preparation for the celebration of the birth of Jesus Christ, which this year begins on Nov. 29 and ends on Christmas Eve.

Advertise with us

St. Sava’s first Advent Fish Fry will be held on Dec. 4 from 2 to 6 p.m. at the church’s social hall on Hartman Street. As billed, it will feature its popular fried fish sandwiches along with Serbian sides and desserts.

In a city that reveres a good fish sandwich, St. Sava’s is especially prized. The 12-ounce hand-breaded sammie took out 31 opponents to win The Incline’s 2020 Ultimate Pittsburgh Fish Fry Bracket.

The secret, says Mrs. Rocknage, is that the hard roll sandwiches are made fresh to order and feature the more flavorful haddock instead of the common cod.

“I’m not knocking anyone else who does it, but sometimes people get ahead of themselves and you can tell that it was just all done,” she said.

The haluski, a Serbian dish that combines noodles with cabbage and onion, also is made the day-of on the church’s big stove by an experienced cooking crew that ranges in age from about 60 to 80.

Advertise with us

The 900-plus palachinke planned for the December event, conversely, are already in the church’s two freezers, and the church ladies hope to have at least 900 apple strudels made by fest day, too. They have been baking and freezing hundreds of nut, apricot and poppy seed rolls since early October, as well  — 150 at a time during marathon baking sessions on Tuesday and Friday mornings.

COVID-19 has restricted the number of women in the kitchen at any one time to eight instead of the normal 15 from a rotating group of 20, Mrs. Rocknage said. The crew also had a heck of a time finding an additional freezer for all the baked goods “because all the hunters took them.” It finally found a last one at Rent-a-Center.

The fish fry is takeout only, and orders need to be placed by Wednesday. In addition to its $8 12-ounce fish sandwich,  the menu includes a variety of sides ($3), strudel ($4), palachinke ($2) and various rolls ($14, with a maximum of six). Payment is by credit card only; call 412-469-2955 to order.

Determined that supply meet demand this time around, Mrs. Rocknage said the church has ordered 300 pounds of fish, 20 more pounds than usual.

A number of  sandwiches also typically find their way to officers at the McKeesport police department. Sometimes they go to the town’s firemen, if the ladies can’t get the officers to come up the stairs to fetch them, Mrs. Rocknage said.

Advertise with us

“I can’t carry it down,” she said.

Mrs. Ikach noted that the Advent fish fry will provide a much-needed sense of fellowship for parishioners, friends and neighbors as they head into the holiday season, even if it’s not ideal circumstances.

“We do it as a community outreach,” she said.

Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.