The end of the local tomato season sends many marinara sauce makers wandering down the canned tomato aisle. With options ranging from the most famous of Italian tomatoes, San Marzano, to store-brand plum tomatoes, it seems timely to taste test and compare and see whether the imported fruits truly live up to the hype (and the cost) compared to the generic varieties.
Tubular and almost squash-like in shape, they are grown in the volcanic, ash-enriched soil found at the base of Mount Vesuvius in the Campania region of Italy. The unique conditions create their low acidity and fruity sweet flavor with additional marinara sauce-making bonuses like being firm and pulpy and having few seeds and a thick skin.
Marinara sauce spans from the utilitarian to the high end, depending on the ingredients used. It’s a favorite among busy families and picky toddlers, and also of those with refined palates wishing to marvel at the flavorful complexity in simple food. It is often quick to make and can be cheap to buy, though San Marzano tomatoes are anything but inexpensive: The cost of one large can of San Marzano D.O.P. (meaning Denominazione di Origine Protetta, the certification doled out by the European Union to denote authenticity in origin and preparation) tomatoes can be up to 10 times the cost of their generic counterpart.
According to Raeann Clark, store manager at M. Cibrone & Sons Bakery in Castle Shannon, that cost is worth every penny to her customers. Inside the small, Italian market in the South Hills, one can find any permutation of canned tomatoes, but it’s the San Marzano tomatoes that really sell.
“I think people would rather have quality,” Ms. Clark said. “If you’re going to take the time to make something, make it right.”
“Right” is a matter of taste, in this case, and nothing can answer the question like a blind taste test.
With two bowls labeled A and B, a collection of metal spoons and cubed Italian bread for resetting the palate, I camped out at school drop-off in the shade of my hatchback, luring the hungry, tired and curious with tomato sauces redolent with basil and garlic.
The San Marzano D.O.P. marinara and the one made with a generic store brand both began as a can of whole, plum tomatoes, and were crushed identically and seasoned minimally. The D.O.P. can cost around $7 and the generic $1.
Overwhelmingly, the taste-testers chose bowl B, which held the $1 plum tomatoes. They found the San Marzano tomatoes “sour,” “bitter” and “flat,” and in many cases, those words were said through pursed lips with hands eagerly reaching for a cube of bread to deaden the flavor.
It seems like a strange outcome, but Heather Ashby, sous chef at DiAnoia’s Eatery in the Strip District, offers an explanation.
“I think a lot of times it’s a comfort thing, something you’re familiar with,” Ms. Ashby said. “I don’t think it’s an acquired taste, but just maybe a little different, maybe a little too bright.”
The issue here seems to be one of culture and habit. We’re comfortable with the tastes presented by the cooks in our families, and those who consistently choose top-shelf tomatoes are in the minority. Even accomplished gardeners who can their own tomato sauce would not be able to deliver the flavor of San Marzano tomatoes grown in soil fortified with volcanic ash.
If grabbing the higher-end, brightly flavored can of tomatoes sounds like a good idea and the “proper” ones to use, here are some San Marzano pro tips to get the process moving in the right direction.
1. Let your palate adjust. The taste-test results were staggering in favor of the generic tomatoes, but if you’ve spent a lifetime eating tomatoes more common in our nook the world, it’s only fair to give this unique variety a few tries before reaching your personal conclusion. Even Ms. Ashby, who can now identify a San Marzano tomato by appearance, admits that her relationship with them had to evolve over time.
2. Learn the lingo. If you intend to purchase the most genuine of San Marzano tomatoes, be sure to identify D.O.P. on the label. Words like “certified” and “genuine” routinely appear on types that haven’t received that difficult-to-earn designation, making imposter-spotting tricky. Are they still San Marzano tomatoes? Probably (and they’re a few dollars cheaper), but their origin and growing conditions cannot be guaranteed.
3. Use them liberally. Wondering when to use this fruity variety? While generally considered unimpressive in their raw form, any time you intend to cook a tomato, San Marzanos should be a candidate.
According to Ms. Ashby, they handle warm spices very well and are great for breaking down meats, especially when making a ragu or for braising. And the brightness and fruitiness lends itself well to pizza sauce. Just ask any pizzaiolo.
Abby Mackey: Twitter @AnthroAbbyRN.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.