Owner of Cafe Agnes talks about making pupusas'

Twenty customers stood in line at Cafe Agnes during the Mellon Square farmers market one recent Friday when a woman approached the menu posted on the pop-up food stand and scrunched up her face.

Mouthing the word pupusa uncertainly, she paused, looked at the line and walked on.

Had it been in May — when Cafe Agnes’ owner Marcella Ogrodnik wondered whether she had made a terrible mistake and her mother, Yanira, was handing out free samples to attract passersby — the perplexed woman might have been an early convert.

Marcella Ogrodnik cooks pupusas on the griddle at her Cafe Agnes stand at the Mellon Square farmers market, Downtown. (Darrell Sapp / Post-Gazette))

It didn’t take long for Fridays to become pupusa day in Mellon Square, although the tamales at Cafe Agnes are popular, too. The loyal from Downtown offices get in line for lunch soon after they are available, and the line doesn’t diminish until the market winds down at 1:30 p.m.

Advertise with us

“What am I going to do when the farmers market ends?” said Brittany Conkle, an attorney who works nearby. “I had never heard of pupusas before, but now it’s my favorite food of everything here. I’m here every Friday.”

“I was considering whether to open a restaurant,” the younger Ogrodnik said during a rare lull. “I’ve been in the industry for 10 years and going back and forth on this, I decided the commitment to a restaurant wasn’t the lifestyle I wanted. Farmers markets were a way to get my name out there, to work outside, to be face to face with customers — and at a fraction of the cost.”

The pupusas at Cafe Agnes are filled with pork, refried beans and cheese or corn, shishito peppers and cheese. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

The former sous chef at Cure, the lauded Lawrenceville restaurant that closed in March, struck out on her own with a cuisine decision that honors her mother’s native El Salvador.

A food new to most Pittsburghers, pupusa is El Salvador’s signature taste treat any time of day. Ms. Ogrodnik wraps a corn flour dough around the filling made with ingredients such as refried beans and cheese, meat and cheese, or vegetables and cheese.

“I get what is plentiful at farmers markets,” she said, attributing the corn and shishito pepper pupusa to the current bounty.

Advertise with us

As her mother takes orders and Ms. Ogrodnik’s boyfriend, Nick Stockton, readies to-go containers and tends to the tamale steamer, she is in the back by the griddle, rolling the corn flour mix into balls. She flattens each by slapping it with her hands, then fills the disc with ingredients, wraps the dough around the filling and flattens it again before setting it on the griddle. Each disc is about the thickness of a pancake and the circumference of a CD.

The order comes with fermented cabbage salad — curtido — and salsa made from guajillo peppers.

Cafe Agnes is open every Friday from 10:30 a.m. to 1:30 p.m. in Mellon Square; every Sunday at the Squirrel Hill farmers market 9 a.m. to 1 p.m. in the parking lot at Beacon and Bartlett Street, and every other Thursday at the Market Square farmers market from 10 a.m. to 2 p.m. It opens at various other farmers markets through the season. For details, check the Cafe Agnes Facebook or Instagram page.

At 29, Ms. Ogrodnik has a solid resume already. A graduate of the Culinary Institute of America, she has worked at the esteemed French Laundry in Napa Valley and the popular Delfina in San Francisco. She also has been a bread baker at High Street on Market in Philadelphia.

After leaving Cure, she was ready for her own enterprise. Cafe Agnes started appearing at several farmers markets in the city. It is named for the Roman saint who was martyred as a young girl, Ms. Ogrodnik’s main influence is the woman who taught her how to make pupusas.

Advertise with us

Her mother was born in San Salvador, studied at Texas A&M University on a student visa in the 1970s and met Walt Ogrodnik, a Pittsburgher, there. Yanira and Walt raised three children — Carmen, Benjamin and Marcella — in Upper St. Clair.

Yanira said her decision to come to the United States for school was not fueled directly by tensions that were on the rise in her country, but she said many young people were leaving before the 1979 coup that triggered a 12-year civil war.

“El Salvador was becoming dangerous when I left,” she said. “I have extended family there, and we visited them in April. Of the many times I’ve been back, I have never felt safer.”

Corn-based dough is wrapped around the filling to make a pupusa. (Darrell Sapp / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

A taste of El Salvador 

Pittsburgh’s culinary scene has never been more robust or diverse, but it is deficient in the foods of Central America, all of whose countries have similar but distinctive cuisines that are different from Mexican fare.

Advertise with us

Of Pittsburgh’s two known pupuserias — the other is Comedor de la Tia in Beechview — Cafe Agnes has found its audience, so much so that Marcella often is too busy these days to hydrate.

“My mother sometimes holds a water bottle up to my mouth,” she said.

During one lunch hour, the line included four firefighters from the Uptown station.

“Hi Dave,” Marcella called to one of them.

“I married her sister,” said Dave Mizer by way of explanation. He and his station buddies come to the square on Fridays for tamales and pupusas, he said, “when everything aligns.”

Advertise with us

One regular, a man in a pork pie hat, got Marcella’s attention as he was leaving and called, “Good as always, all, thank you!”

Marcella said she is curious about all cuisines and has experience with many, but this venture is personal. “It made sense to me, to share something of El Salvador in a positive way with my Pittsburgh community. If I were not Salvadoran, I would not be attempting to do this. A huge part of this is honoring my family.”

Diana Nelson Jones: djones@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1626.