Wilmington, Ohio can claim its birthright to the banana split all it wants but it is Latrobe that has the certificate, or marker to be precise, to prove that the renowned sundae was born at its downtown drug store.

In 2013, the Pennsylvania Historical and Museum Commission installed a marker at the site of the drug store that reads: “In 1904 in Latrobe, the first documented Banana Split was created by apprentice pharmacist David Strickler — sold here at the former Tassell Pharmacy. Bananas became widely available to Americans in the late 1800s. Strickler capitalized on this by cutting them lengthwise and serving them with ice cream. He is also credited with designing a boat-shaped glass dish for his treat. Served worldwide, the banana split has become a prevalent American dessert.”

The National Association of Ice Cream Retailers, for its part, too, acknowledged in 2004 that Latrobe is the birthplace of the banana split.

If you go

Great American Banana Split Celebration is noon to 8 p.m. Friday; 7:30 a.m. to 8 p.m. Saturday; and 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. in downtown Latrobe.
to create line breaks.

When the classic banana split was created 115 years ago, it was beloved but was not an overnight sensation.

Advertise with us

Students from Saint Vincent College would frequent Tassell Pharmacy in Latrobe for its ice cream sundaes and one time one of the students requested something different. That got Mr. Strickler thinking about it and he created the first documented banana split, says Isaac McDaniel, events director of the Great American Banana Split Celebration.

“At that time the banana was considered exotic. It was grown in the Caribbean and had to be shipped here,” Mr. McDaniel said. “David Strickler took a banana, split in half lengthwise and placed three scoops of ice cream on top and the banana split was born.”

Thanks to the students, the word spread when they took the idea back to their hometowns and ordered it at the local pharmacies and creameries.

Mr. Strickler bought Tassell around 1910 and changed the name to Strickler’s Drug Store. He owned it up until the late 1940s-early 1950s, says Andrew Lazarchik, whose father, Thomas, bought the pharmacy from the second owner Charlie Poorman in 1965 and had it until 2000. “Mr. Strickler was also an optometrist and so you could get an ice cream, have your eyes checked and buy a greeting card all in one place,” he adds.

The soda fountain was in use until 1976. “But it was around then that drug stores started doing away with soda fountains as it was expensive to maintain them,” Mr. Lazarchik says. “So when banana splits became a thing in the 1980s, there was no magic recipe from David Strickler to show.”

Advertise with us

However, Mr. Lazarchik wanted to keep the banana split legacy alive and did it by selling trinkets such as keychains, postcards and posters.

Latrobe also joined in celebrating the sundae six years ago, and has since been hosting the Great American Banana Split Celebration in August to coincide with the National Banana Split Day, which is Aug. 25.

This year, the event will be held Friday through Sunday and feature live music on three stages, a 5K run, car show that will include a pickup truck converted to look like a giant banana, a banana cream pie eating contest and plenty of children’s activities.

It won’t be a banana split celebration without the namesake, which will be sold by Valley Dairy Restaurants.

So how traditional will the sundae be?

Advertise with us

“We would never make changes since we advertise it as ‘Serving the original Latrobe Banana Split,’” says Melissa Blystone, president of the restaurant group.

The sundae will have a scoop each of vanilla, strawberry and chocolate ice creams that are topped with pineapple, strawberry and chocolate sauces respectively. For a finishing touch, it will get crowned with whipped cream, chopped nuts and a maraschino cherry.

But unlike the 1904 sundae that came in one size and cost 10 cents, Valley Dairy will offer it in two sizes — $5.99 for the regular and $3.99 for the mini. Instead of being served in an elongated glass dish, the sundae will come in a footed stainless steel dish.

And will the banana split rivalry surface again between Wilmington and Latrobe?

“I think it’s a friendly rivalry,” Mr. McDaniel says. “We have done our due diligence to prove that Mr. Strickler invented the banana split in Latrobe. We are just happy that everyone enjoys a banana split.”

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.