Pennsylvania heard the scream for ice cream loud and clear when its inaugural ice cream trail wrapped up last year.

Instead of having one ice cream trail this year, the state Department of Agriculture, PA Tourism and the Center for Dairy Excellence have teamed up to hold three regional ones — western, south-central and eastern.

South Central Pa.
Ice Cream Trail


• The Nestling Box Market and Creamery, Kempton (Berks County)
• Way-Har Farms, Bernville (Berks County)
• Sugar Shack of Boiling Springs, Boiling Springs (Cumberland County)
• Sweet Treats & More, Elizabethville (Dauphin County)
• Urban Churn, Harrisburg (Dauphin County)
• Windy Knoll Farm Market & Creamery, Chambersburg (Franklin County)
• Fox Meadows Creamery, Ephrata (Lancaster County)
• Lapp Valley Farms, New Holland (Lancaster County)
• The Milkhouse at Oregon Diary, Lititiz (Lancaster County)
• Pine View Diary, Lancaster (Lancaster County)
• Patches Family Creamery, Lebanon (Lebanon County)
• Hall’s Ice Cream, Millerstown (Perry County)
• Perrydell Farm and Dairy, York (York County)

The trail was confined to the south-central region last year, but it was so “wildly successful” that the call was extended to creameries across the Commonwealth, said Carrie Lepore, deputy secretary for marketing, tourism and film.

It also is going beyond rural on-farm creamery experiences. “We have urban experiences, too, and have included unique ice cream shops,” said Susan Powers, press secretary of the Department of Agriculture.

Advertise with us

Participating creameries had to meet one criteria — their ice creams need to be processed on-site using Pennsylvania milk.

There are nine destinations in the Western Pa. Ice Cream Trail, 13 in the South Central trail and 10 in the Eastern one. Each place stands out for its original flavors or concept and some offer ones that reflect the local community such as Pittsburgh Pride at Betsy’s Ice Cream in Mt. Lebanon and the whoopie pie at Fox Meadows Creamery in Ephrata (Lancaster County).

Eastern Pa. Ice Cream Trail

• Chester Springs Creamery at Milky Way Farm, Chester Springs (Chester County)
• Manning Farm Dairy, Dalton (Lackawanna County)
• Crystal Spring Farm, Schnecksville (Lehigh County)
• Milkhouse Creamery, West Hazelton (Luzerne County)
• The Lands at Hillside Farms, Shavertown (Luzerne County)
• Freddy Hill Farms, Lansdale (Montgomery County)
• Merrymead Farm, Lansdale (Montgomery County)
• Klein Farms Dairy and Creamery, Easton (Northampton County)
• Creamworks, Waymart (Wayne County)
• Keatings Ice Cream, Lake Ariel (Wayne County)

To pursue the scoops, trailblazers can download a passport at visitpa.com/2019-pursue-your-scoops-ice-cream-trail or pick one up at one of the destinations. Those who have their passport stamped at five stops on one trail will get a T-shirt. They can claim a T-shirt and an ice cream bowl if they hit all the stops on a trail. A surprise recognition will be given to anyone who visits all 32 locations on the three trails, Ms. Powers said.

The trail runs through Sept. 2 and the stamped passport needs to be mailed by Sept. 30 to the Center for Dairy Excellence, 2301 North Cameron St., Harrisburg, PA 17110.

On the Western Pa. Ice Cream Trail, visitors can not only take in the sights and smells of rural Pennsylvania dotted with farmhouses and their grand silos, barns and homes adorned with five-point stars, rolling green pastures and rows of cornfields from the quiet windy roads but also meet the farmer and get a taste of good honest ice creams.

Advertise with us

Here are the nine destinations to hit in Western Pennsylvania:

A waffle cone with scoops of sea salt caramel ice cream (top), black cherry ice cream and butter pecan ice cream at Jackson Farms Dairy. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Jackson Farms Dairy, 6718 National Pike East, New Salem (Fayette County)

The cow to cone experience doesn’t get more real than this. Everything about the ice cream is made at the 828-acre farm owned by William Jackson and his brother-in-law, Kerry Harvey, since 1957. The milk is from the 200 Holsteins that they own and the ice cream mix is made from scratch by Mr. Harvey’s sons, Josh and Derek, at a newly built production facility that is between the farm and the ice cream store.

Jackson started its ice cream production in 1982 with 10 flavors. Today it features 25 to 30 flavors on any given day. Seasonal ones include strawberry-rhubarb, s’more, blueberry cheesecake and peach. The ice cream is smooth and has 16% butterfat but doesn’t leave that nasty layer of fat on the tongue.

A sea salt caramel is generously studded with chocolate pieces filled with caramel and black cherry is loaded with pieces of fruit.

Advertise with us

“We come up with a flavor based on the flavorings we can find and if it sounds good,” Josh Harvey said.

Widnoon Soft Serve in Templeton features a large peanut butter soft serve that is 12 inches tall. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Widnoon Soft Serve, 911 Mahoning Road, Templeton (Armstrong County)

Lynda Pozzuto is the third owner of this soft serve shop that sits away from the beaten path but is a go-to place for the locals.

The light and perfectly sweetened soft serves come in vanilla, chocolate, vanilla-chocolate twist along with the flavor of the week like pineapple, coffee, pomegranate and cotton candy.

Widnoon’s peanut butter ice cream is renowned, and is available only on its opening, closing and holiday weeks. The flavor does not smack you in the face and yet is assertive in a quiet way. Its next appearance is for the week of Labor Day.

Advertise with us

In addition to the ice cream in waffle cones that are made daily, other items on the menu are sundaes, tornadoes, parfaits, pecan balls and ice cream nachos, which are built with three ice cream flavors, topped with dried fruits and candy and served with waffle chip “nachos.”

The soft serves come in five sizes — baby, mini, small, medium and large. Order a large if you have a ginormous appetite and want to brag on Instagram. The towering swirl is 12 inches high.

Vale Wood Farms offers a flight of five ice creams on sugar cones for $10. Pictured from left are: Cucumber serrano, banana cream pie, butter pecan, Andies Candies and berry truffle. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Vale Wood Farms, 517 Vale Wood Road, Loretto (Cambria County)

Breathtakingly serene, the green pastures can cool your state of mind even when it is beastly hot and humid. Holsteins and Jersey cows roam the pasture near the ice cream shop and by a cute little gazebo. Then there are the hand-dipped ice creams, which are just as delightful to the senses and are made at the processing plant behind the store.

Interesting flavors this summer include a lemon-elderberry (has a citrus and floral note), cucumber serrano (tastes like the gourd but with a spicy finish), blackberry and coconut-chocolate cups (a riff on the Mallo Cups made in nearby Altoona).

Advertise with us

It is the only destination on the trail that offers a flight of ice creams. For $10, five scoops are served on five sugar cones. Now, that is the best way to taste a variety like Georgia peach, berry truffle, banana cream pie, Andies Candies (mint ice cream with candies) and peanut butter fudge.

It is easy to be mesmerized with the assortment of flavors but do take a look at the memorablilia in the shop. It includes a milkman’s uniform and cap worn by C.A. Itle, who started the farm in 1933.

The black raspberry soft serve at Stock's Dairy Delight is made with pureed black raspberries. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Stock’s Dairy Delight, 2491 Cove Mountain Road, Martinsburg (Blair County)

Pamela Stock makes a plea to those stopping by her ice cream shop. “Eat a lot of ice cream and drink a lot of milk to help the dairy farmers. They need your help. They are a dying breed.”

Twenty years ago, she opened the ice cream shop two miles from her family’s Fair Valley Farm, where she has mostly Holsteins and a few Jersey crosses.

Advertise with us

The milk from the 650 cows are shipped to Johnstown to Galliker Dairy Co., which makes the ice cream mix. ”We then get the mix back off of them for our soft serves,” she said.

The soft serves are a thing of beauty and come in vanilla, chocolate, vanilla-chocolate twist and the week’s special flavors such as black raspberry, cherry vanilla and orange-pineapple. There also is the Blue Moon, which has nothing to do with beer and everything to do with a fruity flavor that melds tangerine, pineapple and melon. One special flavor is featured Monday through Wednesday and a second one from Thursday through Sunday.

The shop also sells Italian ices, moolies (Stock’s version of blizzards in flavors like Boston cream pie, cupcake batter, coconut meringue and caramel pretzel), flavor bursts (vanilla based ice creams with flavored swirls) and sundaes.

Stock’s is cash only and the ice creams come in three sizes — small ($2.40), medium ($2.65) and large ($2.97). Caution: The serving is generous.

Among the popular flavors at Ritchey’s Dairy are salted caramel chocolate pretzel and graham cracker crumb cheesecake. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Ritchey’s Dairy, 2130 Cross Cove Road, Martinsburg (Blair County)

Advertise with us

Founded on Aug. 3, 1940 by Oliver C. Ritchey, the operation is now run by the fourth generation. Ice creams are made with milk procured from the neighboring farms in Martinsburg, including Kulp Family Dairy, one of Blair County’s largest dairy farms.

The rich and sweet salted caramel chocolate pretzel (chocolate butter fudge ice cream with salted caramel ripples and chocolate-covered pretzel chunks), graham cracker crumb cheesecake (cream cheese ice cream with crunchy graham crackers) and orange-pineapple (orange ice cream studded with pineapple) are among the 60 flavors made in the shop that sits against the backdrop of farmlands.

Cotton candy and banana ice cream with pieces of fresh banana are the summer flavors, said Keierra Long, a friendly and patient ice cream scooper.

The shop also sells individual ice cream cakes that look like frozen parfaits in flavors like crumb and fudge, strawberry shortcake and peanut butter.

Ice cream flavors at Windy Ridge include pistachio, raspberry pretzel salad and caramel pretzel. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Windy Ridge Dairy, 457 North Tower Road, Fombell (Beaver County)

Advertise with us

Cake is the common denominator for the newest flavors at this shop that sits on a 100-year-old dairy farm.

“We just came out with a pineapple-upside down cake [made with white cake batter and pineapple chunks but no cherries] and are thinking of a blueberry cheesecake or pie ice cream at the end of July,” said co-owner Chris Fisher. “Then there is the German chocolate cake that has coconut, pecans and caramel.”

Her daughter, Lindsay, is the brainchild behind the 100-plus flavors featured over the course of the year. That includes Cow Plop, a chocolate ice cream with Oreos, peanut butter cups and chocolate chips, and Calf Plop, a peanut butter ice cream with the same add-ins.

She makes her recipes with mixes. She does not use milk from the Windy Ridge cows because the farm only produces whole milk, and sells all of it.

Hand-dipped ice creams are available in one scoop ($1.70), one-and-a-half scoops ($2.45), two scoops ($2.85) and three scoops ($3.55).

Advertise with us

“We give generous scoops. That’s what excites people the most,” Ms. Fisher said.

Betsy's Ice Cream features 125 ice cream flavors and among them are the blueberry cheesecake and Pittsburgh Pride. (Arthi Subramaniam / Pittsburgh Post-Gazette)

Betsy’s Ice Cream, 664 Washington Road, Mt. Lebanon

The shop in the heart of the uptown district sells 125 ice cream flavors made with milk from Turners Dairy on a rotating basis. The ice creams have 15% butterfat and flavors include lemongrass (made with natural lemongrass extract), cannoli (mascarpone cheese), black pepper chai (tea ice cream with crushed black pepper), Mexican chocolate (with hints of chili pepper and cinnamon) lavender-raspberry, blueberry cheesecake (with cheesecake chunks and blueberry swirl) and banana pudding. Sorbets and vegan options also are available.

The one standard is the sweet Pittsburgh Pride, which is made with cake batter ice cream, Oreo cookies, brownies and chocolate swirl. “People go into a tizzy if we don’t have it,” said owner Ryan Miller. A 14-year-old middle school girl came up with the black-and-gold hued ice cream for the Create Your Flavor contest in 2012, and it has been a best seller since.

Named after Mr. Miller’s wife, Betsy, the shop churns out 80 to 100 gallons a day. Strawberry pretzel salad is a new flavor that Mr. Miller is working on, and it will be available before the end of the month.

Advertise with us
Egg nog is among the Christmas in July ice cream flavors at Kerber's Dairy. (Kerber’s Dairy)

Kerber’s Dairy, 1856 Guffey Road, North Huntingdon (Westmoreland County)

Ice cream flavor choices run in the triple digits at this agritourism farm that once was a dairy farm and housed Holsteins. The 135 flavors during the course of the year are made with Turner’s milk and have 14% butterfat. At any one time, there are 45 ice creams to choose from.

“We cannot put out anymore as we have only that many dipping cases,” owner Thomas Kerber said.

His son, Thomas Jr., creates the flavors and runs the ice cream show. He has a Christmas in July line for this month and it includes egg nog, rum and raisin, Winter Wonderland (with red and white peppermint candy), butterscotch-almond, pumpkin and pumpkin pie cheesecake with graham cracker pieces. His deep dish apple pie will be part of the fall flavors in August.

His creations come from trial and error and that’s how he ended up with three types of coconut ice cream. “It all comes down to finding the right combination. For example, if I had a really good drink, I try to make a frozen version,” he said.

Advertise with us

But the top sellers are vanilla followed by chocolate. And that’s the way it has been for 35 years.

The mango sherbet is a new summer flavor at Penn State Berkey Creamery. (Michael Houtz)

Penn State Berkey Creamery, 119 Rodney A. Erickson Food Science Building, University Park (Centre County)

The creamery is as iconic a landmark as the Nittany Lion Shrine at Penn State. It was established in 1865 in the “College Barns” behind what is now Old Main and moved to its current home in 2006. Milk for the ice cream comes from the university’s 200 Holsteins.

It features more than 70 flavors including Grilled Stickies (cinnamon bun ice cream with sticky bun dough pieces), Monkey Business (banana ice cream, peanut butter swirl and chocolate chips) and Arboretum Breeze (mint-vanilla ice cream, chocolate chips and raspberry swirl), and dips 24 flavors at any given time.

Peachy Paterno isn’t the only ice cream named after a Penn State personality (Joe Paterno). Cherry Quist honors the late John Almquist, a pioneering dairy physiologist, and Keeney Beany Chocolate is dedicated to Philip Keeney, who is renowned for his work in ice cream and chocolate technology.

Advertise with us

The new flavors this summer are mango sherbet and raspberry vanilla sundae (raspberry sherbet with vanilla ice cream swirl). The hand-dipped ice creams in the store come in one size, cup or cone, and are $4.25.

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.