NEW CASTLE, Pa. — They’re saucy, these ladies.

The Ladies of the Dukes always have been saucy.

The women’s club traces its roots to a few Italian wives of Italian men who belonged to the Duca degli Abruzzi, an Italian social club on this Lawrence County town’s Italian east side. Women didn’t belong to such clubs. But in the early 1960s, a small group of women, who played cards together and who wanted to do good works, asked if they could form a ladies auxiliary to the Dukes.

According to one version of the ladies’ history, “Those of us of Italian descent know that Italian men don’t like to have their space, and especially their clubs, encroached upon.” After a month, the men decided they didn’t want the ladies there and kicked them out.

Advertise with us

“Not to be deterred,” the history continues, “the ladies formed their own nonprofit organization and called themselves The Ladies of the Dukes.”

The Ladies incorporated as a nonprofit on Sept. 24, 1963. They gathered at other social halls and raised money through raffles and their Italian cooking, which gained a good reputation. By the spring of 1972, they had enough money to purchase their own building, the former Cozy Inn restaurant on Croton Avenue.

There, they continued their tradition of preparing their own pasta and red sauce during the week and then serving the food to the public on Sundays.

That tradition continues to this day, and the restaurant — extensively expanded and remodeled in 2004 — is more popular than ever.

But it’s still open only on Sundays.

Advertise with us

“That’s what they’re known for,” says Debbie Cameron, the manager of the restaurant and one of about 20 paid employees. Most of them are members of the club and most of them are women.

But the Ladies do allow two men to make their famous sauce, and a few other men work in what’s now a big and modern kitchen.

By hand and from scratch

Just about every single food is made in a distinctly old-fashioned way — by hand and from scratch — and on certain days of the week. Ms. Cameron carefully tracks each Sunday’s sales so they know how many “cavats” — cavatelli, the most popular order — and “ravs” — ravioli — and “homemades” — spaghetti — and meatballs to make for the next one. The ravioli, each one is hand-crimped with a fork, are pre-boiled, too, so they can just be heated up in the sauce. Last year, they sold 2,691 orders of ravioli.

They tried, for a short time, also being open on Wednesdays. But because they make everything with such care, if they’d tried to do it more often, “We’d never be able to keep up,” Ms. Cameron says. They did recently start catering banquets on other days. They also sell the T-shirts workers wear graced with this simple slogan: “GOT SAUCE?”

Advertise with us

Some of the key cooks still are older ladies, such as Teresa Lucchini, who still has a strong accent that she brought from Italy. She helps make pasta during the week and then works long days on Sundays, too, before going home and making traditional Italian Sunday dinner for her extended family.

At the big work table on a recent Wednesday, aka Ravioli Day, wearing hairnets and cranking out sheets of pasta and jumbo-filled ravioli, there are younger ladies, too, such as Gabriella Marino. Since the late 1990s, her dad, Antonio Lucchini, and his brother, Graziano Lucchini, who is Teresa Lucchini’s husband, have made the pasta sauce. And as Raelyn Cook says as she boils pots of ravs, “It’s their secret sauce. No woman knows the recipe!”

It’s “a little bit of this and a little bit of that,” says Graz, as everyone calls him. On a recent Sunday morning, he started at 6 a.m. to get 29 huge stockpots full of sauce and meatballs ready to go for the ladies. “They can’t lift the pots,” he said with a shrug. “Otherwise, we wouldn’t be here.”

Meet the saucy women of The Ladies of the Dukes

Customers crave the sauce

And even before the takeout window officially opened at 10 a.m., customers were coming to pick up sauce and meals to go, many of them carrying their own pots and pans so they can simply heat it up at home.

Advertise with us

For about 20 years now, New Castle’s Gary Sansone has come almost every Sunday to get a pan filled. “They call me the quart-and-three guy,” he says, holding his quart of sauce with three meatballs in a pan, the lid to which one of the young ladies has secured with two rubber bands.

“They’re all wonderful,” he says. “The food’s always excellent.”

Neshannock’s June Snow, who waits in her car for the dining room lights to come on at 11:30 a.m., says, “Their sauce is better than sauce anywhere.”

There are many red-sauce Italian restaurants in New Castle, throughout Western Pennsylvania and Eastern Ohio and beyond. But it’s hard to imagine another restaurant like this — anywhere.

“You know what? It’s a tradition. We’re trying to live by it and and keep the tradition that they started,” says Ms. Cameron of the Ladies, one of whom was her late mother. She also is a member of the club, even though her ethnic background is Syrian. The club has about 100 members and still meets on Tuesdays and still makes donations every month to several charities and causes around New Castle.

Advertise with us

“They’re very generous,” says Diane Dattilo, who’s president of the New Castle Cancer Support Group. She also is a longtime member and fan of the Ladies of the Dukes, whose full-on-Sundays auxiliary parking lot abuts her yard. “Listen to me, honey,” she says. “The food speaks for itself!”

The men’s Dukes club is still open, too, just down the street. But Ms. Cameron says, “We don’t have anything to do with the men’s. And they don’t have anything to do with us.”

Five hundred to 700 people eat at the Ladies of the Dukes every Sunday. And then there are up to 200 others who come for takeout. Phone calls roll in all morning. “There you go, sweetie,” Helen McKissick tells customers after they pay her through the sliding takeout window. “Have a wonderful day!”

And the place seems to just be getting busier, with some customers on a recent Sunday waiting for two hours.

“They’re dedicated,” as one staffer put it.

Advertise with us

Customers crave the sauce. It’s $6.50 a quart, which looks to be the amount on a typical plate. The drenched pasta and meatballs dinners come — with salad, bread and butter — in small, large and “XLarge” — for about $7 to $20. The “Homemade Platter” gives you two ravioli, cavatelli and spaghetti with two meatballs for $15.25. There are a few other dishes and some sandwiches, but if you’re coming here, you’re coming for the sauce.

“I haven’t had sauce this good since homemade,” says Laura Ruffing, who comes all the way from Mercer — and people come from much farther. She always takes extra sauce and meatballs home.

The dining room has other charming touches, including retro paper place mats decorated with the boot of “Beautiful Italy.” If a customer is wearing his or her Sunday best, and especially if it’s of a light color, a server will tie on some protection in the form of a plastic spaghetti bib.

Not long after opening, the room and most of its 29 tables are full and humming with the sounds of people enjoying their meals while Frank Sinatra and other Italian music plays. As people finish, one of the young women brings around a tray of homemade sheet cakes and pies. A lot of customers walk out carrying bags.

In the entrance way hangs a plaque with a photo, from 1960, and the names of eight founding ladies. They are smiling.

Advertise with us

•

The Ladies of the Dukes is at 1114 N. Croton Ave., New Castle, PA 16101. Reservations are accepted, not required, but recommended. The phone is 724-658-9258, the fax is 724-658-9407 and the website is http://www.ladiesofthedukes.com, It’s open only on Sundays — for takeout meals from 10 a.m. to 5:30 p.m. and for dining from 11:30 a.m. to 6 p.m. (on-site catering is available on other days of the week).

Bob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.