When Domenic Mantella was growing up in Morningside and later in O’Hara, his aunt in Italy used to ship his family olive oil because it didn’t like the ones sold in American grocery stores.
Now Mr. Mantella, a first-generation Italian-American, has taken this practice commercial. Mr. Mantella’s uncle owns a winery in Piedmont, Italy, and when he recently began carrying a new olive oil, he told his nephew he thought Americans should be able to enjoy it, too.
Since September, Mr. Mantella and his business partners, Tony Pica and Rocco Cozza, have distributed Tavolo Pazzo olive oil in the Pittsburgh area. Five stores now carry it — Pennsylvania Macaroni Co., Stamoolis Brothers and Heirloom Superfood Market in the Strip District; Merante Gifts in Bloomfield; and Narcisi Winery in West Deer. Chefs at Cucina Bella in Bridgeville use the oil, and Mr. Mantella is hoping more retailers and restaurants will catch on.
On Feb. 10, executive chef Jeremy Reed will feature it in a Tavolo Pazzo Olive Oil Tasting Dinner at Wheelfish in Ross.
“I fell in love with the olive oil when I tasted it,” Mr. Reed said. He decided a dinner featuring it would allow him to experiment outside his usual “barbeque, bourbon and blues” restaurant format.
The oil is “100 percent single estate,” meaning all the olives are grown on one Sicilian farm, Mr. Mantella said. The olives are then cold-pressed on the same day they're picked. The harvesting, milling, bottling and labeling are all done on that farm, he said.
“It leaves the farm and comes straight to me. I tell people that the last time the oil hit air, it was back in Sicily,” he added.
In discussing the menu for his dinner, Mr. Reed is most loquacious about his first course, an olive oil-poached scallop with jalapeno mango mojo.
“Scallops are lean. They’re like the filet mignon of seafood,” Mr. Reed said. That’s why people so often make bacon-wrapped scallops as appetizers — not only for the flavor of the bacon but also “to lard the food and add additional fat to really lean muscle.”
He decided to try to get the same effect with the olive oil that chefs usually get with bacon. He brought the oil to a low temperature point, around 160 degrees, and then poached the scallops in it for about a half hour.
“That olive oil flavor transfers into the scallops and gives them the extra tenderness they need,” he said. “It’s such a divine cooking method. You could take a spoon and pull it through the scallop like pudding.”
He sears the poached scallops for a bit of crisp browning just before they’re served.
For the smoked beef carpaccio course (filet mignon quick-smoked and rolled paper-thin with a cured egg yolk, smoked olive oil aioli, capers, lemon zest, pickled radishes, Parmesan and olive oil, served with bread), he will place the olive oil in a pan and put the pan in the smoker for an hour to an hour and a half “to get that cherrywood smoke flavor in the oil” for the aioli.
The remaining dinner courses will include pasta carbonara, Tuscan pork and beans and a caprese salad. For the salad, Mr. Reed will infuse the oil with basil, and for the carbonara, he’ll infuse the oil with sundried tomatoes. For dessert, Mr. Reed worked with Mr. Mantella’s mother to develop an olive oil cake with lemon curd, olive oil gelato, sweet and spicy almonds and meringue.
The six-course dinner with drink pairings can be seat 50 guests and will start at 5:30 p.m. Feb. 10. Tickets are $75. Grignolino from Allora Wine Group is one of the wines Mr. Mantella distributes from his uncle’s winery. That wine and a Piedmont Red Blend, which also is from his uncle’s winery, are available through special order at Pennsylvania Fine Wines & Good Spirits stores.
The olive oil retails for $20 for a 500 milliliter bottle, and Mr. Mantella says he’s had a couple of chefs tell him it’s underpriced for its quality.
“My goal is not to cash out on this,” he said. “I want to share good food with everybody.”
His next venture will be to import balsamic vinegar from the Italian province of Modena this spring, as well as to begin marketing a pepper sauce spread that comes from a family recipe of Mr. Cozza. Both of those products will also be distributed under the Tavola Pazzo label.
“Food was always the center of everything for my family,” Mr. Mantella said. Distributing high-quality Italian products “is almost a necessity for myself because I love good food.”
Rebecca Sodergren: pgfoodevents@hotmail.com; @pgfoodevents.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.