Two area women are this week’s $10,000 champions of The Food Network’s “Winner Cake All.”

An entirely self-taught baker, Cathy Burnheimer, of Buffalo Township in Butler County, began baking about 14 years ago under the name, “Cathy’s Custom Cakes.” About four years ago, she felt her skill set had reached a point where she needed to rebrand herself.

“Cathy’s Custom Cakes sounds like someone who bakes cakes in her basement, which I do,” she said, noting she has a licensed in-home bakery. “But I needed to sound more upscale.”

She renamed her business Frosted Envy to better communicate the level of expertise she has reached — enough expertise to design such mind-blowing cakes as inverted cakes that literally hang from chandeliers.

Advertise with us

And enough expertise to win $10,000 on national television and bring three Broadway princesses to overwhelmed tears.

Ms. Burnheimer asked her friend, clay polymer sculptor Lesley Polinko Wasielewski, to be the other half of her team on Food Network’s new cake contest, “Winner Cake All,” hosted by Giada de Laurentis.

The theme of the segment that aired on Monday was “It’s a Broadway Princess Party.” The concert series by that name features the original Broadway actresses who played Cinderella, Belle and Jasmine, performing together in concerts around the country. They were celebrating the third anniversary of their concert series, and they wanted a spectacular birthday cake for the celebration.

Cathy Burnheimer, left, and Lesley Polinko Wasielewski with their "Broadway Princess Party"-themed cake, which won the top prize at Food Network's "Winner Cake All." (Frosted Envy)

In the fifth episode of season 1, four two-person teams had an hour to create fairy tale-themed cake toppers. Even though Ms. Burnheimer burned her hand while pouring boiling sugar, the duo created one of the two cake toppers that most wowed the judges. One of the other teams was eliminated, leaving three teams to compete to make the best birthday cake for the princesses in a five-and-a-half-hour time slot.

Ms. Burnheimer and Ms. Wasielewski created a 3 feet by 3 feet cake depicting a sparkling, blue-gowned princess, sitting down and gazing deeply into the eyes of a tiny “fairy godfairy,” a little winged man standing on her palm.

Advertise with us

Stars of the “Broadway Princess Party” — Laura Osnes, Susan Egan and Courtney Reed — judged the cakes, and had tears in their eyes when the team wheeled their cake out for judging.

Ms. Wasielewski, of Swisshelm Park, has worked with Ms. Burnheimer for several years on cakes, yet she had never actually handled any of the edible elements. She has often sculpted keepsake cake toppers for Ms. Burnheimer, and she has helped Ms. Burnheimer with the design phase for some of her cakes.

But when Food Network came calling, Ms. Wasielewski, who uses “LES Polinko” as her sculptor name, was in the middle of Renaissance Faire season. She makes fantasy-themed sculptures such as dragons and fairies, so summer and fall are busy times for her, selling her wares at festivals.

Filming for this episode of “Winner Cake All” took place in October, when she was still very busy. Four days before flying out for filming, she resorted to YouTube cramming — and she discovered that modeling chocolate is nothing like polymer clay.

But apparently the cramming did the trick because she helped her friend to achieve her dream of becoming a Food Network champion.

Advertise with us

“This was Cathy’s Super Bowl, really,” Ms. Wasielewski said.

Ms. Burnheimer watched the episode at home with her family when it aired Jan. 21. Contractually obligated not to divulge her win ahead of time, she had told only her husband. Her daughters, ages 6, 10 and 13, watched with her, unaware that Mom would be the star.

Her 6-year-old had a fever and was lying on the couch. When the winner was announced, “‘She put her head up and said, ‘Mommy, you won,’” Ms. Burnheimer said.

What will they do with the money?

“Pay taxes,” Ms. Wasielewski joked. “We’ll have enough left over to go to Red Lobster.”

Advertise with us

The “Broadway Princess Party” episode of “Winner Cake All” will air again at 2 p.m. Feb. 2, 11 p.m. Feb. 4 and 2 a.m. Feb. 5 on Food Network.

Rebecca Sodergren: pgfoodevents@hotmail.com; @pgfoodevents.