We LOVE that we’ve been hearing from lots of readers about the Pittsburgh Red Sauce Project.

Many of you have told us your favorite places, ranging from Piccolo Forno in Lawrenceville to Silvioni’s in Ross. But the favorite favorite so far? Calabria’s Restaurant in Castle Shannon. Here are some of those several votes:

‘Satisfies our yearning’ 

Red Sauce Project We want to hear from you

Nominate your favorite Italian-American dishes and tell us about why they're great. Reminisce about family-owned places that you currently love or that are no longer with us. Send emails to redsauceproject@post-gazette.com or hashtag #redsauceproject on Instagram.

I can't say enough about Calabria’s Restaurant! Over the years, we have thoroughly enjoyed their Italian cuisine. Their expansive menu satisfies our yearning for a taste of genuine Italian food. Some of my favorites are the eggplant parmesan, pasta Calabria and decadent homemade cream-puffs for dessert. For both me and my husband, our all-time-favorite is the Michael’s Potatoes, an original recipe created by Grandfather Calabria for his newborn grandson, Michael. Whereas potatoes tend to be a filler for me, the Michael’s Potatoes are to be truly savored. Their entire staff are courteous, professional and very pleasant folks, who will go out of their way to enhance your dining experience.

Advertise with us

Gail and George Siebert

Perry North

‘Proud to know’

As a regular customer of Calabria’s Restaurant in Castle Shannon, I am recommending that if you want excellent Italian food and want to be able to enjoy it with a family, you can be proud to know this should be your choice.

Bill Wells

Advertise with us

Scott

‘A wonderful family’

I’d like to nominate Calabria’s for the most amazing eggplant Parmesan around! It’s the best I’ve ever had! Not only do they have wonderful food, but also the Calabrias are a wonderful family!

Brittany Kryzosiak

Shaler

Advertise with us

‘To-die-for’

My favorite family Italian restaurant is Calabria’s Restaurant in Castle Shannon. It has a great, warm atmosphere where you are made to feel welcome and appreciated by the owners and staff. We have had many meals and catered events provided with great care and love by the Calabrias, including my parents’ recently celebrated 70th-anniversary party.

Some of my favorite dishes include the Eggplant Parmigiana, Veal Parmigiana, the Hot Sausage Hoagie and, for dessert, their to-die-for Cannolis.

Mangiare!

Dean Mackin

Advertise with us

Moon

‘Hooked’ 

The Pasta Calabria and Chicken Milanese are some of my family’s favorites, but recently I am hooked on the Chicken Marsala.

Kim Bissert

Green Tree

Advertise with us

‘This starts with Dave Calabria’

We recently had our moms 60th birthday party in their banquet room. The food was as excellent as it always is. But what sets them apart from other restaurants is their staff. No matter who you are they always treat you like family. This starts with Dave Calabria, the owner. He is always there to greet you with a smile and to make sure you have a great experience. He did not disappoint for my mom’s party. Dave and his staff went out of their way to make sure my mom and our family had a great time. They made sure to greet everyone that came and were very attentive throughout the party. We would highly recommend Calabria’s for any family function or just a night out for some great red sauce.

Donny Pasquinelli

Peters

‘Especially Jason’

Advertise with us

I like [Calabria’s] food. It is delicious, they are friendly and the service is excellent — especially Jason.

Rina Haines

Pleasant Hills

Kudos to other restaurants

We’ve also gotten some great feedback about other red sauce landmarks, both long-gone and still serving.

Advertise with us

‘First to put Gorgonzola on salads’

I have enjoyed your stories about the Italian food scene in Western Pennsylvania. Having grown up here, my favorite was Louis Tambellini’s, first on Southern Avenue on Mount Washington and then on Route 51 in Brookline. My parents used to take me there as a child in the late 1950s or early ’60s. It was always a big treat.

When we moved to Shadyside, we loved Pasta Piatto, now gone. Went there often. My favorite dish was gambari and salcicce over linguine with peppers. They were the first to put Gorgonzola on salads. What a loss.

Did you know that many of the local Italian restaurants were founded by immigrants from Lucca: Tambellini, Sgro, Sodini, Carmassi, etc. My good friend Henry Deluca (at Deluca’s in the Strip District) knows a lot of this history. We go to Lucca often with Henry and see a number of the families whose relatives founded restaurants in Pittsburgh.

Bruce Wolf

Advertise with us

Shadyside

‘A tasty combination of tomatoes and seasonings’

I love Carbonara’s in Mt. Lebanon. My husband, Mike, and I think their meat sauce has a tasty combination of tomatoes and seasonings. A couple of years ago they began selling jars of their sauce and surprisingly to me, the bottled sauce tastes just like their fresh sauce in the restaurant! Also, their pizza is delicious and has a light airy crust with flavorful cheese as sauce.

Patti Cosgrove

Mt. Lebanon

Advertise with us

‘I go every week — sometimes twice’

Osteria 2350 on Railroad Street in the Strip District has a wonderful red sauce. It is rich in flavor and texture. The meatballs are the best in Pittsburgh. Combine the two, and it’s a great meal for an incredible price of $12. It’s a fun space with very nice employees. I go every week — sometimes twice — for the spaghetti and meatballs.

Russell Kuehner

Ben Avon

‘In Verona’

Advertise with us

I’m amazed that you never were in or nobody ever mentioned the Verona Inn, which is an Italian restaurant on Verona Road in Verona. I just wanted to let you know, their food is fantastic. The place is small. But it’s all homemade and everything is delicious. I appreciate all your articles on the other restaurants. I’ve been to most of them.

Patricia Milko

Braddock Hills

‘Everyone around that region just loves them’

I really love your series I’ve been reading in the paper about the region’s red sauce restaurants.

Advertise with us

I wanted to mention Ciccanti’s [Ciccanti Ristorante]. They are on Route 51 in Jefferson Hills. They have been around — well, I am 69 years old and I have to say, they’ve been around forever. As far back as I can remember.

They’re a family-run restaurant and the owner, Frank Ciccanti, he’s still there. Everybody in that region just loves them. (My husband and I always have to get the Artichokes Romano.)

Also right up over the hill on Route 51 before you go into Elizabeth is Francesco’s. That’s also a family-run Italian restaurant and they’re excellent also. (My son loves their seafood pasta.)

P.S. My father was old-school Italian: Everything had to be cooked at home. The only time he would go out was to go to Ciccanti’s, because he had to get the tripe.

Michelle Fisher

Advertise with us

Brentwood

‘We’re good to go’

My wife, Nancy, and I really enjoyed your articles in the paper. There are a couple of restaurants that we believe deserve to be on a list of Pittsburgh’s Best Italian Restaurants.

One is Scoglio’s in Green Tree. Scoglio’s is known for its (many) fish dishes. So good. And, the chef’s homemade marinara red sauce is to die for. Nancy and I often call ahead and ask for a quart to go after our meal.

Unfortunately Scoglio’s is a bit of a hike for us. We live in Franklin Park. Fortunately, we have a wonderful Italian restaurant close to home: DiPietro’s Restaurant on Route 19 in West View. It has passed the test of time by offering excellent Italian meals, at moderate prices, served by dedicated servers.

Advertise with us

My wife and I frequent restaurants that have food that we crave. Menu items that bring us back again and again. Welcome to DiPietro’s: They have Hot Banana Peppers on the appetizer menu. Oh my gosh! These are the very best in town. Delicious homemade sausage filling with a delectable red sauce. And yes, these banana peppers are HOT.

An entree that I can’t resist is Fettuccine Carbonara, a delightful mixture of bacon, prosciutto, cream and imported Romano cheese mixed with fettuccine noodles. I always ask the chef to add four large shrimp to my order. Totally awesome.

And the portion is so big that I always take some home for lunch the following day.

Another item that my wife and I crave is DiPietro’s White Pizza. It is just so very good. The White Pizza, an order of Hot Banana Peppers, a small side salad for each of us, and we’re good to go.

Oh, I should also mention that a glass of wine, or a gin martini, are very reasonably priced.

Advertise with us

Just writing about DiPietro’s makes me want to go there right away — tomorrow or Saturday evening for sure.

Cliff Miller

Franklin Park

‘Always a story’

For comfort food, Italian style, it’s Ida’s Place in Lower Burrell. It’s set up so she prepares the food in the kitchen in sight of her guests. Ida Peluso, the owner and chef, is an older firecracker of a woman who still carries an Italian accent. She cooks only with red sauce. Her food is simple and delicious. She offers large portions. I love her meatballs, chicken parm (not a breaded patty but a cooked breast ), lasagna, stuffed red peppers and stuffed zucchini and really good chicken pastina soup with lots of chicken in it. Salads are simple with homemade Italian dressing. She also has a daily whiteboard with specials. Not one for substitutes — it’s her way or the highway. She will come out and talk to her guests but she is as unfiltered as one could be. Not the best place for younger kids. Most nights in the summer she is in cargo shorts, sweatshirt and crocs with socks and lots of jewelry. When she gets on a roll, especially about her ex-husband, watch out. It’s like a floor show with dinner. Best to go with a regular for the first time until she gets to know you. Reservations preferred. She doesn’t always seem to care about turning tables. Always a story to share after going to Ida’s.

Melvin Cohen

O’Hara

‘Now it would be Lidia’s’

The best? Of course, it’s Carbone’s started in the 1930s in a basement [but it closed this year].

Lasagna, onion rings, red sauce, pizza, pecan balls — now it would be Lidia’s! (especially when she’s there). Locally, it would be the Village Restaurant on Main Street in Mount Pleasant. Family owned. Pizza is the best — the crust! Gnocchi. Everything is great!

Janet Zozula

Mount Pleasant

‘Keep alive the Italian traditions’

Thank you so much for writing about Italian-American food and highlighting the classic restaurants opened by immigrants who arrived 100 years ago. I wrote a book, published this March 2018, that documents the food history of the Italian-American people, “Authentic Italian: The Real Story of Italy's Food and Its People.”

In it, I mentioned your article on Rizzo's cavazoons. It is stories like these that keep alive the Italian traditions and continue to show the positive contributions Italian Americans made to the United States and the impact they had on foodways here.

About your article on Angelo's Restaurant: In my book, I have a chapter devoted to spaghetti and meatballs. Unlike what contemporary food media says, it is an Italian dish from Southern Italy. It is traditional, not created in America. Thank you for writing about Angelo’s to show that Italian-American food is Italian.

Here’s a link to an article I wrote about Italian Americans and their impact on American food, that I published with the Italian Sons and Daughters based in Pittsburgh: https://www.orderisda.org/culture/italian-living/italian-immigrants-forever-changed-the-american-palate.

Dina M. Di Maio

New York City and Raleigh, N.C.

Oral histories of Italian immigrants

So thrilled to read your article about Angelo’s. Washington is my hometown — and I was hoping Angelo’s would be recognized in the Red Sauce series. You did a terrific job capturing the story.

Just FYI — I wanted to let you know that I did an oral history of Silvio Passalacqua for the Italian Heritage Collection at Citizens Library in Washington, Pa.

The collection recognizes the contributions of Italians who settled in Washington during the years of large-scale emigration, 1880 to 1930.

Please note that we are still working on getting the audio files uploaded to the web page, so his audio is not there yet: https://www.primoitaliano.org/family-history.

Tina C. Calabro

Highland Park

‘Nobody has been able to figure out they made it’

I read your article about red sauce and Italian restaurants. There is one restaurant that should be mentioned: Locante’s in Beechview.

It was by far the most popular restaurant in the 1950s, ’60s and early ’70s. They had one of the best dishes that even today, nobody has been able to figure out they made it. It was Stuffed Rigatonis. The major supermarket wanted it, but that’s a whole other story that sometime I will tell to you. Besides that dish, they also had one of the best lasagnas made — different than any other restaurant’s. They were written up by many magazines and the Post-Gazette. I was the Chef back then and I have the article the PG wrote about us back in 1969 that made me one of the top chefs in Pittsburgh and also brought me more attention from other magazines. Thank you. l will never be able to thank the Post for what they did for my career.

Pete Locante

Brentwood

Enter our Red Sauce special projectBob Batz Jr.: bbatz@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1930 and on Twitter @bobbatzjr.