Tangy. Vinegary. Creamy. Interesting. Not-Thousand-Island-dressing-tasting. Well-balanced. Convenient. Stupid. Why?

They were some of the reactions that PG staffers had when they taste tested Kraft Heinz’s new Mayochup with french fries.

The Thousand Island-hued condiment’s texture is akin to mayonnaise and the taste is, well, like a combination of ketchup and mayo with some tartar sauce mixed in. Mayochup does have a distinctive vinegary edge but does not have the spicy kick of Heinz ketchup, and it could work with deviled eggs or tuna melt and even in potato salad.

Everyone of the taste testers in the PG newsroom had an opinion about the “saucy sauce.” One editor said he liked the tangy condiment more than he thought he would. When he bit into the first fry topped with Mayochup, he opined that he could not think of eating it on anything other than fries. But by the time he was into his third or fourth fry, he felt he could use it on baked tomato slices in place of mayo.

Advertise with us

A second editor said he, too, enjoyed it, adding that he could also see Mayochup working well in a roast beef sandwich along with horseradish and on burgers.

But a third one was more in the dismissive camp and wanted to know why Kraft Heinz was messing with ketchup. She said her daughter who loves ketchup on everything would be mad about this. “Heinz has come out with another product only to keep going,” were her final words.

A self-proclaimed ketchup-or-nothing-else guy was pragmatic about Mayochup, which he called interesting. “I can make it myself,” he said as he processed the taste. “But I know this [holding the bottle] is going to be consistent in its taste every time. And I don’t have to mix it.”

In April, Kraft Heinz had tweeted a question to its American audience asking if it will support the ketchup-mayo mashup and promised to introduce the condiment if it had 500,000 votes. At final count, 930,691 people weighed in with 55 percent saying yea, and 45 percent going nay.

Some Tweeps questioned the very name, Mayochup, saying it would have been phonetically better and smoother if it were called Tomayo or Metchup or Ketchonaise.

Advertise with us

Last week, the company again took to a Twitter poll to find out where Mayochup should be launched — Culver City, Calif., Chicago, Brooklyn, N.Y., or your city. Chicago prevailed.

To clarify things, it’s not like the concept of a mayo-ketchup sauce is Kraft Heinz’s brainchild. The fry sauce, a ketchup-mayo concoction that has a cult-like following in Utah, has been around since the 1950s, according to The Salt Lake Tribune. And Puerto Ricans have been known to use the hybrid sauce on all things fried from time immemorial.

Mayochup comes in a 16.5-ounce squeeze bottle with the iconic Heinz keystone label. There are 160 calories in two tablespoons of Mayochup and the first five ingredients listed on the bottle are soybean oil, high fructose corn syrup, tomato concentrate, distilled white vinegar and egg yolks.

It’s priced at $3.79 and can be found in the mayo, not ketchup, section in the condiment aisle.

All the PG taste testers said that they won’t have any qualms paying $3 and change for the bottle, except one, who questioned, “Why pay for it when you can just combine whatever ketchup and mayo you have in your refrigerator yourself? It’s a stupid gimmick and a prepackaged ketchup-mayo hybrid is just wrong.”

Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com or 412-263-1494.