The debate over whether tomato is a fruit or vegetable has raged on for years.

Botanically it is a fruit - since, after all, it is a seed-bearing product of a plant, but legally it is not because the Supreme Court says so.

In 1893, the court ruled that since people neither prepared nor ate tomatoes like fruits they should be taxed as vegetables.

And then there’s us, the average eaters who call it a vegetable when it is a savory pie and fruit when it is in a dessert.

Advertise with us

Heinz Ketchup has jumped into the debate, too, and is selling a limited quantity of ketchup made from “tomato fruits” and “tomato vegetables.” Both types are the same type of tomato-based ketchup - the bottles just have different labels.

We know that but these Post-Gazette staffers don’t, and here’s their take on the two varieties.

Heinz revives the tomato debate: Fruit or vegetable?