State College’s Herlocher Dipping Mustard can now be found at 300 Subway stores in the commonwealth.

Before partnering with Subway, before being a staple in Pennsylvania grocery stores, before it was an integral part of the Penn State experience, there was just a restaurant — the Train Station Restaurant, owned and run by Charles Herlocher.

While customers were waiting to be seated, the restaurant would give out pretzels along with a dipping mustard to hold them over. This is hardly unusual, except customers kept asking for more of the mustard.

They wanted the Train Station to allow them to take the mustard home. Then they wanted the local grocery stores to carry the mustard. When Penn State students left State College they couldn't leave the dipping mustard behind either. One time, Mr. Herlocher received a letter, along with a check for $20, which read, “Dear Mr. Herlocher, I moved to California after graduation, and I cannot live without your mustard. Please send me whatever this will get me.”

Advertise with us

The business grew from there throughout the 1980s. Mr. Herlocher’s son, Neil who is aka Charles Herlocher II, joined the family business in the early 1990s and is now the president of Herlocher Foods Inc.

The younger Mr. Herlocher spent much of his education away from State College getting a bachelor’s degree from Boston University and a master’s from Bentley University. While furthering his education he did not see himself taking over the business, acknowledging that not every business can survive the familial generation gap. To figure out if the arrangement was a recipe for success or disaster he and his father made a deal: Neil Herlocher would spend two years at the company and when the time came he could choose to stay or go.

He has now stayed for more than 20 years. His father, who is not quite retired, still comes to the office and sits across from him. The younger Herlocher said he wouldn't be opposed to working with his own children someday, but added predicting the future can be hard.

“I’d love to, but my children are 14, 12 and 9. Who knows what their interests will be or where they’ll want to live,” he said.

In an attempt to offer healthier foods, Subway has vowed to remove all artificial ingredients from its menu by 2017. Subway’s decision to feature Herlocher Dipping Mustard on its recently launched Artisan Pretzel Roll sandwich, a round pretzel bun instead of the signature foot-long bread, is part of that promise. The mustard is gluten-free, fat-free and salt-free and has been that way since its inception, he said.

Advertise with us

Subway is selling the Artisan Pretzel Roll sandwich, which comes in ham or turkey varieties, at Pennsylvania locations on a trial basis for a limited time, but he has high hopes.

“There’s a lot of people who don’t know our product. But Subway is a way to introduce it. Hopefully they’ll try it, see how delicious it is, and pick it up in their local grocery store,” he said.

In addition to getting the dipping mustard served on Subway sandwiches, the younger Herlocher also has been able to get Kroger to ship the mustard worldwide.

What advice would he have for his younger self?

“Probably listen to your father. He was pretty much dead on about everything,” he said.

Atiya Irvin-Mitchell: 412-263-1197, airvinmitchell@post-gazette.com or Twitter: @atiyawrites.