Have you ever noticed that your urine smells odd after you eat asparagus?

Many people have noticed the unpleasant odor, sometimes as soon as 10 or 15 minutes after eating asparagus, but may never have mentioned it, either because they think the question is a wee bit indelicate or because they think they may be the only ones who produce the smell.

Well, it isn't indelicate, and they are far from alone.

The asparagus-odor connection has puzzled mankind since the time of the pharaohs, and most particularly since the ancient Greeks began consuming wild asparagus and the Romans began cultivating it. In 1781, Benjamin Franklin, never one to leave a bodily function unscrutinized, wrote a letter to the Royal Academy of Brussels about this matter, as well as about other gaseous emissions from human bodies. In more recent times, scientists have been pondering this problem with such urgency and frequency that they often must attend to the matter several times during the night.

Advertise with us

There are two theories about what’s going on: No. 1, so to speak, is that not all people produce the malodorous chemicals, while No. 2 is that everybody produces the chemicals, but not everyone can smell them. Only recently has a consensus begun to trickle forth.

What is not in doubt is that asparagus contains certain compounds that, when metabolized, may produce a mixture of sulfur-containing chemicals that have a strong, distinctive odor and are excreted in the urine.

Read More

Roasted Asparagus

In 1891, Polish chemist Wilhelm Marceli Nencki reported that the odor was due to the chemical methanethiol, and for nearly 100 years, that was thought to be the answer. But in 1975, Robert H. White at the University of California, San Diego, using modern analytical techniques, identified several sulfur-containing compounds as suspects, but found no evidence of methanethiol.

In 1987, researchers at the University of Birmingham in England found as many as 60 chemicals, this time including the elusive methanethiol, but without any convincing evidence of malodorous ro culpability. The chemical identity of the offending vapors is still as much up in the air as the vapors themselves.

In your genes

Advertise with us

Scientists generally do agree, however, that genetics determines which people experience the asparagus-urine phenomenon and which people don't, but they disagree on how. It appears that only certain people’s DNA contains the gene for producing the odor, which we may call the producer gene or the, uh, P-gene. On the other hand, there is a different gene for the ability to smell it; we’ll call it the smeller gene or S-gene.

To my knowledge, no studies have been done to determine whether people who have the P-gene are more or less likely to have the S-gene. Or, for that matter, whether a smeller person can detect the odorous products of other people’s P-genes. The latter experiment has not been done, perhaps because it would require certain highly awkward observer-to-subject maneuvers.

In 1956, A.C. Allison and K.G. McWhirter found that 40 percent of 114 subjects apparently have the P-gene, while Mitchell, et al. (1987) found evidence of it in 43 percent of 800 subjects. On the other hand, a study by M. Lison, S.H. Blondheim and R.N. Melmed (1980) concluded that everyone produces the odoriferous chemicals, but that only a minority of people have the ability to smell them.

A later study by C. Richer, et al. (1989) detected the P talent in all of 103 French subjects. In their report, however, the researchers neglected to describe certain essential details of their experimental methods, so it is possible that their conclusions are all wet.

To muddy the waters even further, a group of ebullient undergraduate students at Carleton College in Minnesota dove into the gene pool and, using a double-blind “whodunit” protocol, found that every one of them was a producer and every one of them was also a smeller. Their conclusions may not hold water because of several flaws in their sample-collection techniques. Moreover, no record was kept of the amount of beer that flowed during the experiment that might have compromised the observers’ perceptions.

Advertise with us

How it all comes out

The current state of understanding, then, is that both the production and the detection of odorous post-asparagus compounds are genetically determined, with most people being producers, but fewer than half having the ability to detect the odor.

In summary, if your urine contains the asparagus-produced odoriferous compound, whatever it is, your DNA contains the P-gene. But you may not able to detect the odor because you lack the S-gene. And if you think your urine smells like the flowers in May, you may still have the P-gene but lack the S-gene. Or you may have neither.

None of the research has attempted to determine whether people who say they “smell it” are all detecting the same chemical compounds. And in light of the mixed chemical results, it may be that different individuals produce different collections of asparagus metabolism products, and that different individuals have differing olfactory sensitivities to those different products.

If that is indeed the case, it would be hard to think of a more frustrating set of circumstances for scientists, who are straining to find a definitive, universal solution to the Great Asparagus Piddle Riddle.

Advertise with us

We’ll just have to hold our breath until they figure it all out.

Robert L. Wolke, professor emeritus of chemistry at the University of Pittsburgh, is a scientist, author and satirist who wrote a syndicated column on food science for The Washington Post. He can be reached at wolke@pitt.edu or 412-481-1620.