Lucy Koutsavlis will be celebrating Easter twice this year — with thumbprint cookies on Sunday and with leg of lamb and koulourakias on May 1 — as she was raised Catholic and her husband is Greek Orthodox.
The thumbprint cookies are especially close to her heart because the recipe is from her grandmother, who was very dear to her.
“I don’t know what it was about Grandma Ivy’s thumbprints but they tasted different and delicious. They had a rich flavor and were coated with finely ground walnuts,” says Mrs. Koutsavlis of Munhall. ”We always looked forward to them.”
Ivy Quinlan was 42 years old when Mrs. Koutsavlis was born. “She was very strict, but she also was loving and caring,” she says of her grandmother. “She was a devout Catholic. She played tag with my sisters and me. And being an avid reader herself, she got us to read.”
When Mrs. Koutsavlis’ grandfather met her grandmother in England during World War I, it was love at first sight. She was 17 when she got married and came over to the United States. But tragedy struck early in her life. She was 39 when her husband was killed in World War II and their oldest son (Mrs. Koutsavlis’ uncle) was killed 11 months later when he was 19, also in the war.
She converted all that pain into her love for baking. “She made the most wonderful pies and the word spread quickly about them. She was the chief baker at Isaly’s,” Mrs Koutsavlis says.
Her grandmother also made all kinds of cookies and nut rolls. One of Mrs. Koutsavlis’ favorites were her thumbprint cookies, which she calls Grandma Ivy’s Thumbprint Cookies. The recipe was never written, but Mrs. Koutsavlis had it down pat through observation when she baked with her grandmother.
The best baking advice Mrs. Koutsavlis got from Grandma was not to work the dough too much. “My grandmother used to say the dough is ready for the cookies when it feels right. It has to be really soft. And she would tell me to push the cracks back together after making a dent in the cookie with the thumb.”
Grandma Ivy’s Thumbprint Cookies
PG tested
1½ cups Crisco
1/2 cup butter
1 cup brown sugar
4 eggs, yolks and whites separated and whisked
1 teaspoon salt
2 teaspoons pure vanilla extract
4 cups flour
1¼ cups walnuts, finely grounded
Preheat oven to 350 degrees.
Mix Crisco, butter, brown sugar, egg yolks, salt, vanilla extract and flour.
Form dough into balls about 1 inch in circumference.
Dip each ball into egg whites and then roll in ground walnuts.
Place on cookie sheet, pushing your thumb into the center of each ball.
Transfer cookie sheet into oven. After about 10 minutes, pat down cookie (it will have puffed up during baking).
Bake cookies for about 20 to 25 minutes in total, depending on oven.
Remove cookies gently from sheet. Allow to cool. Fill with your favorite jelly or chocolate or icing.
Makes about 5 dozen cookies.
— Lucy Koutsavlis, Munhall





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.