Macy’s Thumbprint cookies are back — sort of.
No, the Arcade Bakery at Macy’s Downtown store hasn’t reopened, but Prantl's Bakery is selling a flat butter cookie with a tall, thick swirl of icing and no indentation, which looks identical to the famed Macy’s Thumbprint. It also tastes like or very close to it, according to almost all the consumers interviewed last week at Prantl’s Downtown store off Market Square.
How did Prantl’s come up with this so quickly after the Arcade closed on July 31? It hired Kevin Ulrich, Macy’s chief Thumbprint baker, who had baked the cookies for 30-plus years. He told a Post-Gazette food writer when the Arcade closed that he did not have the recipe written down — he had it in his head.
And at Prantl’s, he still does not follow a recipe.
“It’s a scratch cookie, and there’s really no recipe; everybody does it differently. It’s just my knack, I guess,” Mr. Ulrich said. The one thing, he stressed, a Thumbprint needs is good-quality ingredients. “I don’t have to taste my Thumbprints to see if they are OK. I just know it. I use my sight and smell,” he said.
Prantl’s gave away 300 Thumbprints for free at noon last Thursday, and within 30 minutes every crumb was gone. A steady stream of tasters was waiting in line from 11:40 a.m. to sample the comeback cookie, and immediately bought up an additional 200 cookies that were for sale.
Read More
Co-owner Lara Bruhn said Prantl’s wanted to fill the void when Arcade closed shop and so came up with its own recipe of Macy’s Thumbprint. She called the attempt a wild success. “Macy’s Thumbprint cookie was near and dear to people’s hearts,” Mrs. Bruhn said. “Our cookie either matched their memory or was better than they remembered it. Either way our customers are happy about it.”
Prantl’s Thumbprint sells for 99 cents a piece and comes in two flavors — one covered with Jimmies and topped with a swirl of vanilla buttercream, and the other coated with crushed, salted nuts and donning a fudge icing swirl.
Its new-found fans called the Thumbprint “a delicious substitute.”
Mary Edwards of West Mifflin was going through a Macy’s Thumbprint withdrawal, and so she was thrilled when her co-workers told her about the Prantl’s version. “I wanted to see how it compared. I could not find the Macy-style Thumbprints anywhere. They were unique and the icing they used was amazing,” she said. “Now, I love these, and will be stopping by for more.”
“This is phenomenal,” said Maryann Janssen of Allison Park. “The cookie is very close to the ones at Macy’s.” The cookie also was “very good and comparable” for Shelley Grimm of Scottdale, who said she was happy to have an option for ordering the Macy’s-style cookies again for special occasions.
A couple of the tasters even pledged allegiance to Prantl’s cookie. “I like how the cookie is much thinner. The Macy’s cookie was so thick,” said Lisa Bello of the South Hills. Amy White, also from the South Hills, concurred that Prantl’s Thumbprint trumped Macy’s. “The frosting at Macy’s was too sweet; there was too much icing. There’s a better balance here. The cookie is good and flaky.”
Mr. Ulrich said the Thumbprints at Prantl’s are not the same as the ones he did at Macy’s. “The icing is completely different from Macy’s. This is Prantl’s icing.”
Mrs. Bruhn also said that the icing was the most different component of the cookie. “Buttercream has a thicker consistency,” she added.
There were customers who could tell the difference, too. When comparing the Prantl’s and Macy’s versions, Barbara Zaladonis of Munhall said, “The buttercream is not as buttery, and I am a butter person. The cookie is almost the same. But Prantl’s did a good try.”
To Angela Starr, an aficionado of Macy’s Thumbprints, the cookie tasted exactly the same, but not the icing. “The vanilla is just not the same,” she said, after taking a bite, and then quietly repeated that to herself after a second bite.
But then customers like Meagan Grau of Brookline, who have never had the Macy’s Thumbprint, found Prantl’s cookie to be “delicious, buttery and spot-on.” “I will come back to get these,” she said.
And that is all that matters for Mrs. Bruhn. “People really like our Thumbprints, and so we are definitely going to keep them. We would be fools not to.”
Arthi Subramaniam: asubramaniam@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1494 or on Twitter @asub






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.