Serious wine buffs are serious about the soils from which the grapes grow, and toss around words such as “alluvial” and “loamy” as if the rest of us might know what they’re talking about. Same deal with Scotch — certain soils and peats, not to mention a host of other climate particulars, impart certain taste characteristics upon the barley and the final product.
Stands to reason that the same might be true for rye whiskey, and Monongahela rye in particular.
Wigle Whiskey, the Strip District distiller, aims to find out.
“There’s this notion of how a sub-par growing environment can influence the flavor profile of a grain,” said Meredith Grelli, co-owner of Wigle Whiskey. Sub-par, at least, in terms of yield per acre, a measurement by which Pennsylvania farmers lag behind those in other states.
Yield aside, perhaps there is something about the regional terroir — that’s the French word meaning, roughly, “the land,” referring to the region’s innate geography, topography and climate, which then mix with the soil and interact with plants in a way that brings out different agricultural qualities — that made Mon rye such a desirable commodity in the first place.
Put another way: Does Pittsburgh dirt and rain make the booze taste good?
Monongahela rye was “sweeter, more robust,” writes Paul Clarke in a 2009 Imbibe magazine article. “Maryland ryes [tended] to be brighter in flavor, with a grassy character.” True? Perhaps. Then again, whiskey historian John Lipman notes that the term Monongahela rye was a catch-all phrase that included some un-aged “white lightning,” and the phrase as used in the late 1700s might have little relationship to what the whiskey tasted like a century later:
“[Mon rye] didn't taste exactly like the rye whiskey we know today, and it probably didn't taste anything like the blended Canadian whisky that Americans tend to call rye. It became popular enough that the style was copied in other places, such as eastern Pennsylvania [and] especially Maryland.” But given that the source grain for “Mon” rye — despite its name — would have often come from the fertile Eastern half of the state, and given that 18th-century Pittsburgh-area whiskey may have been aged in molasses-tinged rum barrels, and given that there were no regulations to speak of that would have guaranteed consistency or production value, well, we’re right back where we started, terroir-wise.
History tells us, if nothing else about the terroir, that Pennsylvania produced a lot of rye grain — in 1840, Pennsylvania was producing nearly 7 million bushels of rye. By 1900, the yield was 4 million (second behind Wisconsin in terms of total yield, but way down the list in terms of bushels per acre). Once Prohibition began, production nosedived here.
So let’s define “here.” The Pittsburgh Plateau is a silty loam, an acidic mix of clay shales and sandstones. Even within that area, which stretches from Indiana County at its northeast corner all the way down to Greene County, there is substantial variation: The further southwest you get, the more topsoil you have, with roomier root-zones and better water-holding capacity, according to the Penn State College of Agricultural Sciences. Allegheny Mountain soil — which covers much of the Laurel Highlands, itself a historically fertile ground for distilleries — is less friendly to agriculture, a bit rockier and with a steeper landscape, and the growing season there is less than 100 days. Further east, you get into the rich limestone soils of the Ridge and Valley Province; go west, and you’re in Ohio’s Lake Plain soils and the Eastern Corn Belt.
The goal, says Ms. Grelli, is to settle on a zone that might reasonably be called the Western Pennsylvania “terroir.” Right now, Wigle buys organic grain from farmers in Ohio and Pennsylvania, and tries to source all of its other grains within a 300-mile radius of Pittsburgh, not so much to focus on the Pittsburgh terroir as to be good environmental stewards. But 300 miles in any direction takes you all the way to Toronto if you head north, Greensboro, N.C., if you head due south, Indianapolis if you go west, and New York City if you head east — all substantially different agricultural zones.
So Wigle hopes to grow rye clones (probably “Danko,” a high-yield winter rye) in the Pittsburgh area, plus South Dakota, Kentucky, New York and perhaps New England, then compare the technical qualities of those clones. The grains would be analyzed for differences in starch content, moisture, and protein levels, and, if possible, analysts would try to figure how Pittsburgh humidity, precipitation and other environmental aspects shaped the growth.
After analyzing the grain itself, a lab would also look at the clear, un-aged first distillation run, and then the final aged product, to see how environmental influences continue to affect the whiskey. Pittsburgh has wilder weather swings, and more summer humidity, than, say, Ireland. Temperature affects oxidation and barrel “breathing”; humidity levels, meanwhile, can affect ethanol and water-evaporation rates.
Throughout the whiskey-production process, there are a number of entry points by which other environmental influences might affect the taste of the final product — during fermenting, there may be yeast or water variables, for example. But if the distillation process could be standardized, eliminating variables, it might be possible to home in on the rye, and terroir, itself. The process might take two or three years.
Seems like a lot of effort, no?
“Part of it is that it’s tied up in our brand,” said Wigle co-owner Alex Grelli. “But part of it is just natural curiosity. ... What we’d like to claim is that our rye tastes different” than those ryes made by distillers who buy bulk, mixed grain from farmers across the country.
Even if Wigle can identify a specific, geographic Pittsburgh terroir, with its own unique flavor profile, that doesn’t mean the distillery will stop buying grains from Ohio or New York, he said. But it could give Wigle, which specializes in niche products, the flexibility to offer a limited-release “Pittsburgh” rye, with grains grown solely in the Pittsburgh terroir.
And such limited-release products, focusing on a specific geography, could help boost organic-rye production in that geography. In just its third year of operation, Wigle is the biggest consumer of organic rye around — so much so that, in 2014, the distiller ran out. (Wigle produced 11,000 proof gallons of booze last year, and once Wigle installs a new still and fermenter, probably this autumn, annual capacity will grow to 24,000 proof gallons.)
“Certified organic grain is really hard to find,” Ms. Grelli said, and rye remains a niche product within those organics. That’s one reason Wigle began producing its first bourbon last year, due out this summer (bourbon is a corn-based whiskey). Wigle hopes to avoid last year’s self-created organic-rye shortage by strengthening existing relationships with organic farmers — by promising to buy all the rye produced by Twin Parks Organic Farm in Wayne County, for example, and offering to mill the grain themselves so farmers don’t have to — and by cultivating new relationships with small family farms that are sitting on fallow plots, or itching to try something new.
That raises another, hidden element of the terroir — man’s agricultural interaction with the land.
“Was it used for corn? Was it pasture?” said Melissa Tosiano, a University of Pittsburgh researcher with a master’s degree in environmental health and toxicology who works for Wigle on the side. Corn, she said, sucks nitrogen out of the soil at a faster rate than other crops. Part of Wigle’s research might involve interviewing individual farmers to see how they and their predecessors have used, or abused, their cropland.
“Rye can grow from very poor circumstances,” Ms. Tosiano said. “It’s a very hardy grain ... perhaps a more stressful environment [means] it’s doing something to overcompensate.”
■
As of March, there were 51 limited distillery licensees in Pennsylvania, with 37 of those currently licensed to operate by the U.S. Treasury Department’s Alcohol and Tobacco Tax and Trade Bureau. Seven years ago, when Boyd & Blair shipped its first cases of premium potato vodka, there were only two (Boyd & Blair’s Pennsylvania Pure distillery, and Philadelphia Distilling, which makes Bluecoat American Dry Gin.)
The explosion in distilleries can be traced to a change in state law, enacted in 2012, that allowed spirits manufacturers to sell their products on-site, the same way small wineries do.
New distilling licensees include Foxburg Wine Cellars in Clarion County, Nittany Valley distilling in Centre County, Conneaut Cellars in Crawford County, Battlefield Brew Works in Gettysburg, and DR Distillery in Slippery Rock. Pending licenses (not yet approved by the state, or the Treasury Department) and inactive and “safekeeping licenses” (those that are not in use) include Mason-Dixon distilling in Gettysburg, Mingo Creek Craft Distillers in Washington County, Ridge Runner Distillery in Fayette County, and Tall Pines distilling in Somerset County. In Green Tree, Port of Pittsburgh Distillery LLC has filed its business incorporation papers, but has not yet received a distilling license.
■
One distillery not on that list of 51 is the the Old Overholt distillery at West Overton, the birthplace of Pittsburgh industrialist Henry Clay Frick. Frick’s grandfather, Abraham Overholt, founded the distillery that eventually made Old Overholt rye whiskey.
In January, the West Overton Village & Museums announced that the historical organization hopes to open a distillery that would reproduce Old Farm Pennsylvania Pure Rye, a namesake that, like the distillery, dates to 1810. Prior to 1810, Abraham Overholt and his brother, Christian, operated a private family distillery (it may date to 1796), but in 1810 they began selling to the public, and Overholt was thus one of the first commercial distilleries in these United States. That 1810 distillery was torn down and replaced by a larger one, and it’s in that larger building that the museum is now housed.
West Overton Village, in Westmoreland County, also is planning a whiskey festival for this fall.
Bill Toland: btoland@post-gazette.com or 412-263-2625 and on Twitter @btoland_PG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.