Markie Maraugha always has adored cooking and baking, but what she loves most about the food biz is customer service.
The 22-year-old Ohio native says, “What makes me happy every day is helping people.”
With her new venture in Wilkinsburg, she’s doing just that.
On Feb. 10, she and partner Greg Stocke reopened the former Nancy’s Restaurant at 616 South Ave., once again giving locals a non-fast-food place to get a home-cooked breakfast or lunch.
A neighborhood institution since the 1970s, the family owned diner was shuttered last year when owner Nancy Bielicki fell ill with pancreatic cancer. She died last month at age 82 after cooking for Wilkinsburg residents for more than 30 years. Her children had hoped someone might want to continue the business.
The saviors of sorts proved to be Ms. Maraugha and Mr. Stocke, who after touring the site last fall were completely enchanted by its retro, kitschy 1970s decor. So much so, that despite having no hands-on experience running a restaurant, they ended up buying all the diner’s fixtures and appliances after signing a three-year lease with the building’s owners, NBT Holdings.
“I just felt it was me,” says Ms. Maraugha, who grew up in the North Hills. “The interior just charmed us. It had a special energy.”
It didn’t hurt, she adds, that the diner was a “proven concept” within the community, has plentiful parking for those not within walking distance and has an audience eager for weekend hours.
The renamed Nancy’s East End Diner brings the number of locally owned food and drink establishments in Wilkinsburg to 17. That’s good news for the struggling borough, says Marlee Gallagher, communications and outreach director for Wilkinsburg Community Development Corp. And it’s a wider variety than you might think, from stalwarts Soul Food Connection and Al’s Fish & Chicken to newbies Leona’s Ice Cream Sandwiches, which opened last year (and sells to local markets and coffee shops).
Founded in 2007, the nonprofit WCDC works to foster economic development and improve the community’s business corridor, which over the past few decades has fallen on some hard times. But there’s always hope for a turnaround: Last year, the group initiated a series of case studies to showcase established businesses as well as to profile the young entrepreneurs who are pumping life into the community with new ones.
Ms. Gallagher says the WCDC decided to start by promoting the food portion of the project because it ties in with WCDC’s recent campaign to get a liquor-license referendum on the 2015 primary ballot. Except for two years after Prohibition, when a lot of bars and restaurants opened up in the business district, Wilkinsburg has been a dry town.
Not only would liquor sales help increase revenues, but also it would appeal to a wider demographic, says Ms. Gallagher. It would also encourage people to sit and eat in restaurants rather than do takeout.
“We’re looking at [the referendum] as a economic-development tool for existing businesses,” she says, noting that longtime establishments such as Salvatore’s Pizza House and Biddle’s Escape are on board.
A similar effort failed in 2013, but volunteers have until March 9 to get the 1,059 signatures needed for the measure to go forward, and are buoyed by the 900 signatures they managed two years ago.
There won’t be any liquor on the menu at Nancy’s, of course, just traditional breakfast and lunch dishes along with fresh locally roasted Tanzania peaberry coffee from Fortunes Coffee in the Strip District — what Mr. Stocke calls the “best diner coffee in Pittsburgh.”
The couple has had to invest in a few updates, adding a fire-support system and new electric. But that’s about it. Brightened by fluorescent lights, the wallpapered diner looks pretty much the same as when it opened in 1980, after a six-year run as Nancy’s Luncheonette on Penn Avenue. That’s a good thing because that gives it a certain charm,” says Mr. Stocke. “It’s like 1975 in here.
“Come on, look,” he adds, gesturing to the booths that line a wall decorated with snapshots of customers from back in the day. “It’s awesome.”
The couple plan on keeping much of Nancy’s menu the same, but they’ll also up their game just a little with more local fresh ingredients. Along with homemade mac ’n’ cheese and hand-cut “skinny” fries, the diner will offer a Havarti and Apple Grilled Cheese on Mancini’s raisin toast, a variety of scramblers (omelets with home fries mixed in) and some of the best bacon sausage in Pittsburgh. That house specialty is made by DJ’s Butcher Block in Bloomfield.
The sweet potato pie also is homemade, “and I have a 50-pound box of yams in the kitchen to prove it,” says Mr. Stocke. And grits are coming.
It’s a small staff: just a couple of waitresses, two cooks (including Pops Arentz, who’s cooked for years around the city) and Andy the Dishwasher, who worked for Nancy for 30 years. The “Tuesday-Friday” girl, Jaymee Lutes, found the job via Craigslist.
“It’s all about the hometown diner,” she says. “You get real people in here, which is right up my alley.”
Ms. Maraugha and Mr. Stocke hope the reopened diner will share in the love being showered these days upon Pittsburgh’s East End. The first few days, at least, have been extremely busy.
“My friends think we’re absolutely crazy, but Nancy was quite the legacy,” says Ms. Maraugha, who worked as a tax preparer before turning restaurateur. “She was a legend for treating people like family. ... Those are big shoes to fill.”
Maybe too big?
She says, “Failure is not an option.”
Gretchen McKay: gmckay@post-gazette.com, 412-263-1419 or on Twitter @gtmckay.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.