My kitchen was small and crooked, wedged into a second-floor apartment that had been sliced from an old Victorian home in Lincoln, Nebraska. The floorboards creaked; the oven door creaked, but I had a pantry and a huge old-fashioned porcelain sink that I loved. That day the windows steamed up as I chopped and sauteed, proofed and preheated.

I was making dinner for a guy I’d just met. He sat across the circle from me in a graduate-school fiction workshop, the program’s “new guy.” Having survived an episode of extreme heartbreak the previous semester, my ears perked up a little when he sat down.

By this day, as the oven door opened and closed on my whole-wheat baguettes, we’d had drinks together once. We’d talked at a party. I’d visited O’Rourke’s where he tended bar. He’d given me a free beer. What does that mean? I asked myself and my friends, who thought I was dense.

I was making spicy green bean-and-sweet potato turnovers. (I know they don’t really go with homemade baguettes, but this is what I made that day back in 1995. I’m sure of it.) Although they aren’t technically that hard to make, the turnovers are impressive in appearance and ridiculously tasty with a flaky outer crust and a sweet-spicy interior. I’m sure I also made a pie -- most likely coconut cream or lemon because that was what I was into those days. I’m pretty sure we didn’t make it to the pie that night, though.

Advertise with us

Rick Schweikert had promised a friend he’d go to the Huskers football game with him. He promised me he would leave the game early in order to show up for dinner. A high-stakes meal. And he did it.

In retrospect, I see that Rick had no idea that this dinner was important. He isn’t a natural-born foodie and instead only married into the vocation. But three important things happened that day. He was on time. He stopped short in the kitchen doorway and said, “Wow. This looks amazing.” And even though he actually doesn’t like sweet potatoes, he didn’t tell me that then. Instead, the turnovers worked their siren song, and if truth be told, it wasn’t the first time they had lured a man to my rocky coast.

Once we were dating properly -- er, rather, once Rick moved in two month later -- I had perfected the pecan pie. Because truly, pecan pie is the way to Rick’s heart. I tested at least 10 different recipes before I hit on the perfect, luscious, gooey combination of nut, crust and sweet -- a treat I still make to good heart-lusting effect 17 years later.

The idea of the seduction meal -- this concept that we all have at least one within us -- came up a few months ago at an early pre-Thanksgiving dinner. My colleague Marc Nieson asked each person around the table to name their meal of seduction. His is risotto. It has to do with the stirring, he said. It shows patience; it allows time for conversation. He made risotto for his wife, Beth Corning, and wham, yep.

The way we’re seduced is tricky though. One size doesn’t fit all. Carolina Loyola-Garcia remembers how her second husband — before he was her second husband and they were boyfriend and girlfriend — made banana milk and brought it to her in bed each morning. She was new to Pittsburgh and what she remembers most is the anticipation she felt as she heard him making the leche con plátano. She remembers those sounds of preparation more than the taste. It reminded her of home.

Advertise with us

“It was connected to Chile, to childhood and nostalgia, yes,” she said, “but it was also part of the excitement of a new relationship in Pittsburgh.” It was a way of showing love, this idea of bringing something to bed as an offering. “We would share stories and linger,” Carolina said, smiling softly as she told me this story over coffee. Although that relationship didn’t last, the memory of that time is a sweet one. Recently, she and her partner, Colter Harper, visited her family in Chile. He made omelets for everyone at their beach house. “It takes such care to make them one at a time like that,” she said. “It’s such a generous act.” Hers arrived topped with a tiny heart-shaped mushroom.

A late-night email discussion with my friend D. Gilson revealed that he tends to catalog his love- life’s lusts through coffee. “It’s true. My love life, especially my Pittsburgh love life, seemed to largely center around coffee shops,” he said. “The first man I dated there was a graduate student at Pitt and a barista at Tazza D’Oro. We first talked Britney Spears and fixed-gear bicycles over double espressos at Commonplace, Squirrel Hill. Two dates later, over burnt Americanos at Kiva Han, may it rest it peace, he dumped me because my politics were elitist. My elitism, he argued, mirrored by my preference for the country’s top coffee roasters (namely Intelligentsia).”

D. also admitted that although his favorite foods are cheese and eggs, he has twice become a vegan for love. “The first relationship failed, he became a Buddhist monk and I returned to eating meat. The second blossomed into a friendship, and that adamant vegan remains my best friend.”

Sometimes a person stumbles upon a one-hit wonder. Peter Trachtenberg doesn’t remember what he made that night, he just remembers it was saturated in garlic. “Indian? Italian? Chinese? I can’t remember,” he said. But he was sure he’d made a mistake. It was 1989 in Baltimore. Peter had gone out with the woman once or twice before he’d asked her over. “What I remember is her saying, ‘It’s the garlic.’ And in a daze, just peeling off her clothes. I remember her clothes dropping like rain,” he said. Peter and I agreed that garlic doesn’t work that way for everyone, at least not every time. That night, though, it was magic.

Some people’s seduction meals are so stealth that they prefer to not go on record for this essay. Seduction is serious secret business when you’re dating, I agree, so let’s say I met Peitho, the Greek goddess of seduction, for lunch. My friend whom I’m calling Peitho has various stages and types of seduction meals that she employs depending on the circumstances. Weeknight date meal? “Basic roasted chicken,” she said. “It looks good. It smells awesome in the house. What could go wrong?” She has been making this chicken for more than 20 years, and it pairs well with anything: roasted sweet potatoes, green beans, anything. I asked her if it had ever failed. She looked me in the eye and said, “Recently? I cooked a lovely meal. It was lovely with the chicken and the smells? The person said nothing. Nothing. I said to myself, ‘This is going nowhere.’” Right. How about Saturday-night dinner? “The Morrocan Lamb thing,” she said. “It isn’t more difficult than the chicken, but it looks fancier.”

Advertise with us

This one has been particularly successful for Pleitho. “Lamb is a little sexy, right?” she said. “It isn’t for the faint of heart.” If the date makes it through meals levels one and two? “The family sauce,” she said, nodding slowly. Everyone in Pleitho’s family makes it, but it tastes different depending upon who makes it. She learned it as a kid from her grandmother; her brother, sister, and mother make it, too. “Basically, this sauce is not going away,” she said. “I need to have known the person long enough, to be into it enough, that I could handle it if he didn’t like the sauce.”

I met Terrance Hayes and Yona Harvey late one night over drinks at Butterjoint to talk seduction and meals. I’d heard about an early dating grits controversy, but I wanted the story in person. Yona immediately put her hands over her face when I brought it up. It seems that back in the late-’90s she wanted to woo Terrance with a classic Southern meal: grits, chicken, dressing. “It was the heaviest, largest meal,” she said laughing. “I learned very quickly that despite his height and muscle, he’s not a big eater.” There were a lot of leftover grits, which she (not being from the South as is Terrance but instead from Ohio) put in the refrigerator. You do not eat leftover grits. “No one has leftover grits,” Terrance said. Southern-man-wooing fail.

But Terrance was quick to point out that soon thereafter Yona made him an elaborate couscous dish. “Grits, sure,” he said. “Couscous? Never heard of it. I thought, ‘Exotic cook. Exotic lady.’ ” And with that they’ve been married 17 years.

Sherrie Flick is a fiction and food writer living in Pittsburgh (sherrieflick.com): sdflick@hotmail.com.

■

Advertise with us

Do you have a seduction-meal story and/or recipe to share? Send it to us at food@post-gazette.com or c/o Food, Pittsburgh Post-Gazette, 34 Blvd. of the Allies, Pittsburgh, PA 15222. We’ll share the best with our readers.

■

A PECAN PIE THAT SEALS THE DEAL

Single 9-inch pie crust, unbaked

3 large eggs

Advertise with us

1 cup maple syrup

1/4 cup honey

1/4 cup raw cane sugar

1/4 cup unsalted butter, melted

1 teaspoon vanilla

Advertise with us

1/4 teaspoon sea salt

Grated zest of 1 orange (optional)

Splash of bourbon (optional)

1/2 cup chopped pecans

1½ cups pecan halves

Advertise with us

Preheat the oven to 425 degrees. Make your favorite pie crust and line a 9-inch pie pan with it. Set aside. Put on some nice music. The Sinatra Pandora station works well.

Whisk the eggs, maple syrup, honey, and sugar together. Stir in the melted butter, vanilla, salt, orange zest, bourbon, and chopped pecans. Smile because you are making an awesome pie. Drink the splash of bourbon instead of putting it into the pie if you’re so inclined.

Line the bottom of the piecrust with the pecan halves. Eat a few because you deserve them.

Pour the goo over the pecan halves, making sure they’re all coated or the naked ones popping up will burn. Bake for 15 minutes, then reduce the oven temp. to 350 degrees and bake 25 minutes longer or until the filling has puffed up in anticipation. Serve warm, with love.

— Adapted from the Maple-Pecan Pie recipe in “Pies & Tarts: The Williams-Sonoma Kitchen Library” (Time-Life, 1992)