The queen of desserts in Naples, Italy, sfogliatelle is a beautiful pastry filled with sweetened semolina, ricotta and candied orange peel, yet hardly any place makes them in the region. Colangelo’s and Enrico Biscotti in the Strip District along with most local Italian bakeries have them shipped in frozen from out of state.

I wanted to try homemade sfogliatelle because such an elegant pastry should taste as delicious as it looks. In my quest to find it, I was delighted when I learned from an Italian expat that Moio’s — now in Monroeville — has been making sfogliatelle since Raphael Moio moved from Calabria and opened the bakery in East Liberty in 1935. The bakery moved to Monroeville Mall Annex in 1972 and then to its current location at 4209 William Penn Highway, near the intersection of Route 48, in 1991.

Admired for its texture and a subtle sweetness, sfogliatelle is often eaten for breakfast to accompany an espresso. It comes in one of two forms. The first is the eye-catching sfogliatelle ricce, a cone-shaped pocket with ridges like tree rings. The other is the less elaborate sfogliatelle frolle, shaped like bombolini, little Italian doughnuts with a far better name.

The origins of sfogliatelle reach back to the late 1600s, when history points to the Santa Rosa Conca dei Marini as the origin for the filling, wrote Rosetta Constantino and Jennie Schacht in their book “Southern Italian Desserts: Rediscovering the Sweet Traditions of Calabria, Campania, Basilicata, Puglia, and Sicily” (Ten Speed Press, October 2013).

Advertise with us

Ms. Constantino is from Italy and moved to San Francisco when she was 14. She said that even though the pastry is from Naples, sfogliatelle has become popular all around Southern Italy.

Locally, Tony Moio inherited his family’s bakery when his parents died in 1977 and found help among family members, especially his uncles. Today, Mr. Moio works at the bakery with his Aunt Dolly, his sister Michelle, his wife, Meg, and his daughter Lisa.

Since the late 1970s, Tony’s Uncle Ralph had been the only one in the family who made sfogliatelle until he died in 2012. He followed the recipe Tony’s grandfather Raphael gave to him that remained a secret to everyone else at the bakery, including Tony.

“Several years ago, I had to fight my Uncle Ralph for the recipe so it would be passed on and the pastry would remain what it has been,” Mr. Moio said. “You know, Italians will give you the ‘recipe,’ but they’ll leave out the salt or something. I kept tasting it and I knew it wasn’t the right one. I finally got it, written on a piece of tattered paper in a script that was so hard to read it was like hieroglyphics.”

Now Tony is the only one who makes sfogliatelle, even though he employs 18 full-time bakers, including head baker Ron Silvio, who’s been at the place since 1977.

Advertise with us

“That’s fine by me,” said Mr. Silvio, who worked across a table in a prep room. He was making pignoli cookies for a holiday cookie box. “A sfogliatelle is way too much work.”

At Moio’s, making sfogliatelle is a three-day process, which is one of several reasons why they’re not widely available. Like a Neapolitan pizza, sfogliatelle requires time and skill.

Mr. Moio’s recipe for sfogliatelle ricce varies from the one in “Southern Italian Desserts,” but the gist of how it’s made starts on the first day, when the baker mixes flour, honey, salt and water, followed by a few minutes of kneading a ball of dough and a rubdown with lard or shortening.

After it rests, on the second day, the baker passes the dough through a pasta machine several times, which makes it very smooth, flat and thin like stockings. It’s brushed again with lard or shortening then rolled into a single tight roll that has to rest for a half to a full day. Then it’s cut into ½-inch slices.

All this before starting on the filling, which includes a semolina and sugar mixture, ricotta, eggs, candied orange peel or fruit slices, orange blossom water and cinnamon. Some recipes incorporate limoncello, marmalade or pastry cream. The l’aragosta version, named for the lobster, has a long, cream-filled tail. These are not for the traditionalist.

Advertise with us

I visited Moio’s on the third day of the process, after Mr. Moio had cut the dough log, made the semolina mixture and was incorporating candied fruit and ricotta into the filling. Wearing a white baker’s uniform, he leaned over one of several mixers to scrape the sides. Half-inch slices aligned three sheet pans across from him.

The day before, he had cut the log into discs and stretched each disc into ovals. This is a variation of a technique that requires a baker to shape discs into cones, where the filling goes before it’s sealed.

When he finished mixing the filling, Mr. Moio placed an oval in one hand and with the other, he scooped a spoonful from the mixing bowl. Then, in a one-two move, he slapped it closed and slipped the filled pastry back to the sheet pan.

“It’s kind of like an empanada,” he said. “It’s a type of Italian turnover. But it’s flaky and sweet.”

He cited sfogliatelle from Termini Bros. Bakery in Philadelphia as a smaller and flakier variation on the pastry. “People make them differently but this is the way we learned,” he said. He has never been to Italy to try them.

Advertise with us

Mr. Moio said he makes two pans a day during the week and three pans a day on weekends. He aligns 20 on each pan, which bake for about a half hour covered, then uncovered for 15 to 25 minutes, depending on the weather. Humidity and temperature affect the dough, he said.

Today through Dec. 23, he anticipates the bakery will sell 55 pans. On Christmas Eve, he’ll sell 25 to 30 pans. “When I’m making over 700 sfogliatelle, my hands start to cramp up.”

Before serving them, he likes to crisp and brown them in an oven, which is what he did for me before he cut the palm-sized pastry into four pieces.

Moio’s sfogliatelle is significantly larger than others I’ve had and tastes more of fruit than candied orange, but it was warm and creamy and delicious, with dough like phyllo. It flaked into shards and littered a plate with powdered sugar when I took a bite.

“For customers that haven’t had one, I know they’ll love it, but they have to taste it first,” he said. “But before they do, most customers see sfogliatelle and say, ‘Eh, I’ll have a cream puff.’ ”

Advertise with us

They’re missing out.

Melissa McCart: 412-263-1198 or on Twitter @melissamccart.