Megan McGinnis thought her idea of a cheese wedding cake was unique. That is, until, through online research, she discovered these artfully stacked and embellished wheels of savory cheeses are popular across the pond and are catching on in different parts of the United States, as well.

Not to be confused with traditional cheesecake, these multi-tiered cakes made of cheese can be served with appetizers or following dinner as a dessert alternative for those without a sweet tooth.

“When planning the wedding, my (husband) and I decided we wanted non-traditional to bring out our personalities. Also, cheese being my favorite food, I thought it would be cool,” said Ms. McGinnis, 34, who was married to Edward Smith on Sept. 28.

“Cheese is becoming more of a staple at wedding receptions. It’s not surprising, especially if the couple is cheese lovers who want something different,” said Alix Wiggins of the Wheel and Wedge Cheese Shop in the Pittsburgh Public Market.

Advertise with us

And that’s exactly what Ms. McGinnis, who also is the manager of the Brentwood McGinnis Sisters Special Food Store, was going for at her 100-guest cocktail wedding reception held at Morning Glory Inn in the South Side.

She entrusted the design of the 12-inch-high cake to Susan Selby, cheese manager at the McGinnis store in Adams. She incorporated four different cheeses in a variety of shapes when she built the cake at the reception site the morning of the wedding.

The base was a mild, buttery double cream Henri Hutin brie with 60 percent fat.

“It’s one of the best well-known French bries out there,” said Ms. Selby.

Above that was DCI Cheese Company’s Saint Angel, a 5-inch square of sliceable, buttery French triple cream, somewhat higher in fat content.

Advertise with us

The top two layers were American-made cheeses that included a 1-pound piece of artisan goat and sheep cheese called Humbolt Fog from Cypress Grove Chevre, a manufacturer in Arcata, Calif., and a dome-shaped Vermont Creamery and Butter Co. coupole made from goat milk with a “wrinkling appearance on the outside,” said Ms. Selby.

“Our soft ripened cheeses look like cake. Humboldt Fog is known for layers with an odorless, edible vegetable ash through the center,” said Cypress Grove’s marketing director Janne Rasmussen.

For those still needing icing with their cake, regardless of its makeup, a brown sugar-laced mascarpone from Vermont Creamery was piped along the bottom.

Embellished with wine corks intertwined in a grape vine, peacock feathers, raspberries and blackberries, the cake sat atop an old wooden cheese box. With plenty of available cheese slicers, guests helped themselves to any section of the cake that was served at the antipasta bar station with traditional baguettes and breads.

“Since cheese does taste much better at room temperature, this makes for a great party food. It will be good for several hours on a wedding table,” said Ms. Selby.

Advertise with us

To store leftovers, if there are any, Ms. Selby suggested wrapping them in cheese or wax paper and placing them in a refrigerator, not the freezer, for a few days.

A cheese wedding cake will fit everyone’s budget, said Ms. Selby, and she advised that brides consult their local cheesemonger who has access to the largest variety of different cheeses.

“Like any wedding cake there are extras for different icings and toppers, such as flowers and fruit,” she said, adding that a three-layer cheese wedding cake with fruit and mascarpone icing can start at about $150.

Cypress Grove lists a three-tiered, unembellished 8-inch-tall, 9-pound cake on its site that costs $205.

Two to four ounces per guest is the suggested allowance when considering size, said Sara Hill, education director at the Wisconsin Milk Marketing Board.

Advertise with us

Earlier this month, Ms. Hill, a 25-year veteran of the cheese business, crafted her first cheese wedding cake for her niece. It consisted of six wheels of cheese, including bries and mobay, and was decorated with sugared grapes, berries, baby’s breath and roses that matched the bridesmaids’ bouquets.

Having no traditional wedding cake, the couple ceremoniously cut their cake after dinner and served each other a slice of mobay.

“The guests had never seen anything like it,” she said.

“I think these cakes are a growing trend because people are becoming aware of their sugar intake, they’re gluten-free -- or they just love it,” said Cypress Grove’s Ms. Rasmussen. Cypress Grove has generated interest using wedding cheese cake photos, posted by brides on the company’s Facebook page.

Three years ago, the company received rave reviews for a cheese wedding cake it created for the Specialty Food Association’s Fancy Food Show in New York City, said Louise Kramer, spokeswoman for the Specialty Food Association.

Advertise with us

“Specialty food had $88.3 billion in retail sales in 2013, and cheese is the largest category,” she said. “There’s clearly a love of cheese in this country so it’s only natural that it crop up at weddings.”

According to Nigel White, secretary of the British Cheese Board, cheese manufacturers throughout the United Kingdom are experiencing increased demand for cheese wedding cakes.

“The trend really started to take hold in 2006. Now there are over two dozen British companies creating cheese wedding cakes for couples up and down the country, all reporting either steady or increased sales,” he said.

Most British cheese wedding cakes, he said, represent a traditional cheese board and a few unusual cheeses, he said, adding that popular choices include: Blue Stilton; mature cheddar; British brie or camembert; creamy Lancashire and cranberries; and White Stilton with apricots.

John Natlacen, owner of Churchmouse Cheeses in Cumbria, England. said he builds about 12 cheese wedding cakes a week, with that number more than doubling during the English peak wedding season in August.

Advertise with us

“It now forms a large part of my company's business, so much so that I have stopped sending out individual orders of small pieces of cheese online to solely concentrate on Wedding Cakes,” he said in an email.

He said about 30 percent of his customers completely forego the traditional cake, opting for just the cake of cheese on their special day.

The most popular cake of the 10 listed on his website is the Tatton Tower, named for Tatton Park, near Manchester.

“I think it is popular because it contains a wide variety of different tastes, textures and types of cheese, so all bases are covered -- a strong, tangy white cheese as the base (Lancashire or a farmhouse cheddar cheese), an ‘exotic’ one (Cornish Yarg, covered in nettle leaves), a blue cheese (Blacksticks Blue), a fruity one (Wensleydale with cranberries), a goat's milk cheese (Tovey) together with wonderful heart-shaped bries from France (Neufchatel),” he said.

He dresses the tower with grapes, fresh figs, kumquats, star fruit, redcurrants and serves it with chutney, celery, biscuits “and lashings of port.”

Advertise with us

Unable to freeze any of the portions of her cheese wedding cake, Ms. McGinnis said she is planning to enjoy a smaller Saint Angel version of the cake next year when she celebrates her one-year anniversary.

“You don’t have to be traditional,” she said.

As the sign next to her cake stated, “Sweet dreams are made of cheese. Who am I do dis-a-brie.”