The House Next Door: Historic farmhouse in O'Hara
From a very sturdy one-room log cabin built in 1797, this O’Hara home grew over more than two centuries into the charming two-story farm house that captivated Drs. Kevin Carl and Nadine Champsi Carl.
The couple, their two children and three cats have only lived there since February but have become very attached to the house, the neighborhood and the history.
“We were really attracted to the quiet street, the nature reserve and the home’s character,” Dr. Carl said. “There are a lot of old and historical parts of the house.”
The room built by James Powers is the oldest part of the home.
“He was the original white settler in the area,” Mrs. Carl said. “As the legend goes, he had come up the Allegheny River and ended up going up the stream [behind the property], which is now known as Powers Run, and finding an abandoned wigwam.”
Powers lived in the house before purchasing the property. The original log cabin with its hand-cut stone fireplace has since been incorporated into the house.
Read More
“The previous owners added the wood-burning stove,” Mrs. Carl said.
Today the house sits next to the Margaret Weil Nature Reserve. Margaret “Peggy” Weil and her husband, Andrew, were the sixth owners of the home.
“Andrew wrote an unpublished history of the house,” said Mrs. Carl. “It was depreciation land from the Revolutionary War.”
Depreciation lands were given as payment to Revolutionary War soldiers. They were west of the Allegheny Mountains and north of the Ohio River.
This home was a farmstead at one point in its history, and old farm tools have been found around the house. Using a metal detector, the owners have found a musket ball, a 1925 liberty head dime, horseshoes and other interesting artifacts. An arrowhead was on the windowsill when they moved in. The Carls have kept it along with old maps and other documentation of the home’s history.
“There is a certificate of the depreciation land and a map of Pittsburgh from 1795,” Mrs. Carl noted.
This summer, the family discovered the magic of summer nights at the homestead, with what seemed like a million fireflies illuminating the property. They honored that with firefly wallpaper in the hall from Spoonflower.
“Peter Weil, who lived here as a child with his parents, told us he remembered sleeping on the screened in porch in the summer. He would catch fireflies just to release them in the screened in porch so he could lay there and watch them,” said Mrs. Carl. “On a summer night in June and July, there are so many fireflies it’s like the entire world is sparkling.”
The kitchen’s bay window faces the woods. Their son loves to try to identify the birds who perch in the trees.
“We think the bay window is the best part,” Dr. Carl said. “It is a great place to eat breakfast, and you feel like you are up in the trees since it is so elevated.”
His wife said they’re pleased to see their son and daughter out exploring nature and building forts in the woods. “We love the perennial gardens that were here, too.”
During the pandemic, the family was able to safely entertain on the screened porch with an old wagon wheel chandelier.
“We got a heater so we could be out here,” she explained.
“Having this room off the kitchen is just so wonderful,” added her husband.
They joke about using the Dutch door that leads into the cabin room to hand out candy on Halloween. It will be their first Halloween in the old house.
“We do not have ghosts here,” she laughed when asked.
Patricia Sheridan: psheridan@post-gazette.com.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.