If you’ve taken a stroll recently along Walnut Street in Shadyside, you might have noticed something missing. A couple of longtime retailers in the neighborhood opened the year by closing their doors.
J.Crew announced in late February that it would close its shop at 5433 Walnut St. by spring. Meanwhile, Talbots has moved out at 5428 Walnut St., leaving an empty two-level storefront in its place.
These losses stirred up worries for some local shoppers. (The Post-Gazette even received emails from a couple of them.) Is Walnut Street in trouble? Are there more closures to come?
Not likely. The consensus among shop owners and neighborhood officials is that these recent closures are part of the natural evolution of any retail district, not a sign of distress.
“We got caught up in the mix of national retailers that have decided to go a different direction,” said Richard Rattner, president of the Shadyside Chamber of Commerce.
J.Crew has closed dozens of stores nationwide in recent years, while management shakeups and slumping sales have plagued the brand.
“Each year we review those leases that are coming to their end, and this year, like last year, we made the strategic decision to close those stores where it made financial sense to do so,” a J.Crew spokesperson told the Post-Gazette in an emailed statement. “We will continue to have an integrated physical retail store presence and online sales platform that best allows us to connect with and serve our customers through both channels.”
The Shadyside store was J.Crew’s only location within Pittsburgh’s city limits. The retail chain still has a store in Ross Park Mall and a J.Crew Mercantile (an outlet store that sells brand clothes and accessories at lower price points) in The Block Northway, both in Ross.
The Pittsburgh Business Times reported that the lease for Talbots’ storefront was up this year, so the company decided against renewing it. The store had been in Shadyside for more than 30 years. Remaining Talbots locations in the area include inside Ross Park Mall, The Galleria mall in Mt. Lebanon, Robinson Towne Centre in Robinson and at 400 Broad St., in Sewickley.
It didn’t take long, though, for another store to move into the neighborhood. J.Jill, a women’s apparel retailer formerly owned by Talbots, is set to open this spring in J.Crew’s old site on Walnut Street. The space vacated by Talbots is still empty for now.
“Over the last two or three years, we’ve lost retailers, but we’ve had a lot of good retailers come and take their place,” said Ronald Friedman, who owns the women’s shoe store Ten Toes at 5502 Walnut St. It’s done business in the neighborhood since 1974. “I call it a good mix between the smaller individual boutique stores and the chains.”
Ventura, Calif.-based outdoor clothing company Patagonia picked Walnut Street to open its first Pittsburgh store in late 2017. Another recent newcomer is Apricot Lane at 5533 Walnut St., which will celebrate its first year in business next month.
“It’s been going really well, and we are very happy to be on this street. We feel lucky because spaces come and go pretty quickly,” said Taylor Jamieson, who owns the trend-oriented women’s clothing boutique with her mother, Debbie. Their store is the first Pittsburgh location of this California-based franchise. “We had some customers come in like, ‘Can you believe J.Crew closed?’ From a business perspective, it didn’t alarm me, just because I know how publicly hurting they are.”
She also wasn’t surprised when Talbots closed because “every time I went in there there wasn’t [much] foot traffic,” she said.
The ease of internet shopping has forced some merchants to adapt their inventories in order to keep shoppers coming back year after year.
“We try to bring in things that people don’t necessarily have in their closets. That has kept us alive. There are different items you can get here that you’re not going to find on the internet,” said Antoinette DePasquale, manager at Maxalto at 5426 Walnut St., which has been in business for more than 30 years. The designer women’s boutique is known for curating an eclectic mix of pieces by the likes of Y-3, Alexander McQueen and Vivienne Westwood. “People need to start getting off their couches, getting in their cars or walking to these stores. That helps support their community.”
Making sure the neighborhood looks and feels welcoming is another approach to maintaining a healthy business district, Mr. Rattner said. The Shadyside Chamber of Commerce is working on a streetscape program that includes replacing lights, trees and garbage cans along Walnut Street and Ellsworth and Highland avenues. The organization also is gearing up for several spring and summer events, such as the Great Shadyside Yard Sale (April 27), the Jam on Walnut concert series (runs May 25 through Oct. 26) and the annual Shadyside sidewalk sale (July 24-28).
“I think the chamber and our merchants work very hard to keep the neighborhood clean, safe and current,” Mr. Rattner said.
Sara Bauknecht: sbauknecht@post-gazette.com or on Twitter and Instagram @SaraB_PG.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.