There’s a debate happening these days in politics and it has nothing to do with the federal government shutdown.
Since members of the 116th U.S. Congress were sworn in earlier this month, there’s been a lot of talk about what some of them wore — particularly women — and whether it should even be a subject of discussion.
The hot pink pantsuit that House Speaker Nancy Pelosi wore was a “beacon of fuchsia in a sea of blue,” wrote Harper’s Bazaar when she was shown seated alongside new Democratic committee chairmen earlier this month.
The California U.S. representative also turned heads in a vibrant pink dress at the Capitol as she once again became House speaker. She took “back her power looking both fierce and feminine,” according to a column on the Washington Post’s website.
U.S. Rep. Alexandria Ocasio-Cortez of New York showed up for her first day on the job in a white pantsuit accented with oversized gold hoop earrings and red lipstick.
“I wore all white today to honor the women who paved the path before me and for all the women yet to come,” she shared on Twitter. “From suffragettes to Shirley Chisholm, I wouldn’t be here if it wasn’t for the mothers of the movement.”
Read More
The press and public pontificating on politicians’ clothes is nothing new. Even male lawmakers have been called out for the fit of their suits and choice of tie color (or tie length in President Donald Trump’s case). But the record number of women who won seats in Congress this term has put the topic back on the table.
Is that fair? It depends on who you ask. Vanessa Friedman, The New York Times’ chief fashion critic, argued in a column that it’s not sexist for her to dissect the way Ms. Pelosi dresses after the newspaper received letters to the editor and comments on social media that suggested otherwise.
“For starters, dress is, without question, an important part of a politician’s tool kit,” Ms. Friedman wrote, adding that she’s also written about Mr. Trump’s suits, Jeb Bush’s shirt sleeves and Marco Rubio’s shoes. “In an increasingly visual age, how you look is part of the message you are communicating.”
Do local women in politics agree? The Post-Gazette asked a couple of them to weigh in on the subject of politics, gender and personal style.
Marita Garrett
Ms. Garrett, the mayor of Wilkinsburg, says personal style can be a way to send a message. That’s why she often sports an “Unbought & Unbossed” pin on her lapel. It’s associated with Ms. Chisholm, a New York Democrat who became the first black woman elected to Congress in 1968.
“Her legacy [had an] impact on me,” Ms. Garrett said. “For those unfamiliar with Congresswoman Chisolm, it provides an opportunity to share about her significance.”
As more women become involved in politics, they’re “changing the narrative” of what a politician looks like, Ms. Garrett said. She credits former first lady Michelle Obama as a personal inspiration.
“To me, she is the trailblazer [for] why you see more women in politics making bold, bright statements with their clothing choices,” she said.
Ms. Garrett typically wears blazers; some are more colorful, some more conservative. “I want to stand out so it helps people remember who you are and whom you represent.”
She sees both sides of the argument over what politicians wear and whether it matters. What’s also interesting to her is who does most of the commentary.
“Most of the criticism I see in the media comes from other women,” she said. “I believe the definition of professional attire is changing.”
Gisele Fetterman
When former Braddock Mayor John Fetterman was sworn in earlier this month as Pennsylvania’s lieutenant governor, his wife saw it as an opportunity to tell the story of her own journey from undocumented immigrant from Brazil to a U.S. citizen and the state’s second lady. She commissioned a custom-made pin by Studebaker Metals, a metalsmith company in Braddock, that reads “Immigrant.”
“I’m not sure if a formerly undocumented person ever stood on that stage before, but I sure hope others stand there again,” she said.
Even before her husband’s political rise, Ms. Fetterman said she was thoughtful about her fashion choices.
“I’m usually overdressed, if that’s possible. Part of it has been compensating for John’s casual style,” she said.
When he was Braddock’s mayor, Mr. Fetterman often appeared in shorts and short-sleeved shirts that showed his tattoos. For his inauguration in Harrisburg, he wore a suit and tie.
Ms. Fetterman’s personal style also is a way for her to convey her social and economic values.
“One of the papers asked if they could interview the designer of my inaugural dress. I said they would have to call the mall because it was a 70 percent clearance markdown at Macy’s,” she said. “I love accessible and affordable clothes.”
When it comes to discussing what people in politics wear, she recognizes that it comes with the territory.
“As long as the discussing and analyzing does not lead to policing,” she said.
Sara Bauknecht: sbauknecht@post-gazette.com or on Twitter and Instagram @SaraB_PG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.