Aerie’s latest photo campaign has been stirring up a lot of buzz -— not for the lacy underthings in it, but because of who’s wearing them.
No stick-thin, all-white, photoshopped-to-perfection supermodels here. The lingerie and loungewear brand, sub-owned by American Eagle on Pittsburgh’s South Side, captured on camera real women: black, white, curvy, petite, bald, young, mature. One had vitiligo (a condition in which the skin loses its pigment cells), others had stretch marks and smile lines around the eyes. Wheelchairs, colostomy bags and body hair were celebrated instead of hidden. None was retouched; all were beautiful.
For an industry that’s long been smacked on the wrist for its lack of diversity, this is a rah-rah moment. Aerie, which stopped photoshopping its ads in 2014 and saw sales spike as a result, created a campaign that invites a range of women to see themselves represented.
While this is indeed a step in the right direction for fashion, it’s also a reflection of what’s still wrong. That is, when industry critics and consumers alike tend to praise the brands that get it right while not doing more to call out the ones that still miss the mark.
Sure, an ad as tone-deaf as Pepsi’s 2017 protest party commercial starring Kendall Jenner got its fair share of criticism (and was eventually pulled). Same for Dove’s photo series that showed a woman of color removing her shirt and, in turn, becoming a white woman. But what about the high-fashion European brands that still send a parade of WASP-y models down the runway, season after season? Or the magazines or blogs that will applaud a brand like Aerie, yet don’t take radical steps to shake up their own spreads and covers?
This is when we need to channel our inner Bethann Hardison. The supermodel turned fashion activist has been a voice for change for years. In 2013, she wrote an open letter to the governing bodies of major fashion cities, including New York, London, Milan and Paris, that didn’t mince words about which brands weren’t doing enough to diversify their runway shows. (Marc by Marc Jacobs, Calvin Klein, Prada, BCBG, Celine, Versace and Proenza Schouler were among those on the list.) For doing this (and more), The New York Times called her “a persistent thorn in the side of an industry that often prefers to ignore the issue.”
“That’s all you can do is try to keep educating,” Ms. Hardison told the Post-Gazette before her visit to Pittsburgh last year.
So, what can we do to keep being a thorn?
If you’re a consumer: Put your money where your morals are. Or perhaps don’t be so quick to share or like on social media brands that don’t do their part to broaden standards of beauty. If you’re a fashion critic or blogger: Keep calling out the industry’s success stories in this area, as well as its shortcomings. Plus, look for opportunities to be an agent for change yourself.
And if you’re a fashion company? Well, take a cue from Aerie.
Sara Bauknecht: sbauknecht@post-gazette.com or on Twitter and Instagram @SaraB_PG.





Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.