Matt Yurkovich remembers wanting to “save the world” when he decided to study environmental resource management at Penn State more than 20 years ago.

For many years, the Brighton Heights native pursued that goal, helping with conservation efforts and working in regulatory compliance to protect natural resources for companies in Pittsburgh and Boulder, Colo.

But it wasn’t until he got a job as a seasonal employee for Tree Pittsburgh after boomeranging back home in 2013 that the North Catholic High School grad discovered pawpaws. A few years later, he learned to make beer with it.

In 2014, Yurkovich got a seasonal job planting and trimming trees for Tree Pittsburgh, a Lawrenceville nonprofit. Then, inspired by the local brew culture in Colorado, the avid homebrewer in 2016 opened  Allegheny City Brewing, a craft brewery on the North Side, with his sister, Amy, and co-founder Al Grasso. (The brewery’s name invokes the North Side’s former identity as an independent sister city to Pittsburgh, which annexed it in December 1907.)

Advertise with us

When Tree Pittsburgh decided in 2017 it’d be fun to feature the “mysterious” native fruit at its annual Arbor Aid fundraiser, Yurkovich had been brewing his signature Deutschtown Brown Ale, Cool Water Kolsch and Oceanic IPA in a former coffee shop on Foreland Street for almost a year. So when organizers asked if he might want to try brewing a beer with pawpaws to demonstrate the fruit’s versatility, he didn’t hesitate — even while wondering if pawpaw beer was actually a “thing.”

He ended up making around 30 gallons of an American wheat ale called Pawpaw Funkhouser using locally sourced fruit.

Following a nine-year hiatus due to a demanding brewing schedule, the 48-year-old is again providing beer for the nonprofit’s 10th annual Pawpaw Fest on Sept. 26. The event runs from 2-7 p.m. at Tree Pittsburgh’s five-acre campus along the Allegheny River in the Upper Lawrenceville.

This time around, he’s developed a sour ale whose tart, acidic flavor lends itself better to the tropical notes of pawpaw than a wheat ale, he says.

It’s called Patch Pawpaw Sour Ale and he’s made enough of it in the brewhouse’s seven-barrel system — around 220 gallons — that even those who don’t have tickets to the sold-out fundraiser should be able to sample a pint over the next few weeks. It will be served until supplies run out at the brewery’s taproom and beer garden on East Ohio Street and its new taproom on California Avenue in Brighton Heights, which opened in April.

Advertise with us

A pint will cost $7.50 and a four-pack $18, and having just been brewed, “it will taste really fresh,” he says.

Poor man’s banana

Not familiar with the oblong fruit that gives off a distinctive, slightly sweet and fermented aroma when ripe? You’re hardly alone. But if you’re an adventurous eater (or drinker), it’s probably time to get acquainted with pawpaws.

A staple food for Native Americans and others into the early part of the 20th century, the pawpaw is North America’s largest edible native tree fruit. Because of its fruity flavor and creamy, pudding-like texture — it’s easily scooped with a spoon — it earned the nickname “poor man’s banana” during the Great Depression. Others know and love it as the “American custard apple” or “Hoosier banana.”

Depending on the variety and individual tree (there are more than 200 named historical and modern cultivars of Asimina triloba), the fruit can measure anywhere from a few inches to half a foot, weighing more than a pound.

The understory trees, which grow best along rivers, creeks and streams, are extremely prolific once their roots take hold. But the fruit is so easily bruised and perishable that it is rarely shipped even short distances to grocery stores; it becomes mushy within just a few days of being harvested.

Advertise with us

You can find pawpaws at local farmers markets for a few fleeting weeks in early fall. (If you’re lucky, you might have neighbors who grow them in their backyard.)

Which could explain why Yurkovich had not only never heard of the forgotten fruit when he started working for Tree Pittsburgh, but also why he couldn’t get anyone to spill the beans on where pawpaws could be found.

“It seemed like such a big secret,” he recalls with a chuckle.

He likens it to the tight-lipped foraging culture of ramp harvesting. “No one would tell me where they were.”

Pawpaws taste like a mango, a pineapple and a banana somehow had a baby — sweet and custardy and intensely tropical. That makes the Appalachian wild food ideal for recipes, including not just sweet desserts like ice cream, pies, custards and quick breads, but also marinades, vinaigrettes and barbecue sauces. It also pairs perfectly with yeast-forward beers that either complement its tropical flavors (such as a German-style Hefeweizen) or provide a crisp contrast to its dense texture (an India pale, sour or fruited ale.)

Advertise with us
GTECH Strategies provided funding to allow Tree Pittsburgh to plant pawpaw trees on a vacant lot in Brighton Heights.(Matt Yurkovich)

‘Fresh as possible’

One of Tree Pittsburgh’s missions is to promote native trees. So organizing a festival to shine a spotlight on one that grows in moist, shady places in the eastern half of the U.S. was a natural. It certainly had a storied precedence: Ohio’s famed three-day pawpaw festival in Nelsonville has been drawing crowds since 1999, and another in York, Pa., celebrates its 22nd year on Sept.19.

Yurkovich admits it took a bit of trial and error before he got the flavors right. That’s largely because this time around, he used frozen pawpaw puree sourced from Integration Acres in Albany, Ohio, instead of enlisting his parents to help him scoop and separate countless “big ol’ seeds” from pawpaws supplied by Tree Pittsburgh the night before brewing. They also used fruit collected from a friend’s property in Stanton Heights.

Because the puree is almost a liquid when it’s thawed, “you have to figure out the right quantity to keep it at the right alcohol level” of 5% alcohol by volume, he says. He’s learned from making beer with raspberry, plum, blueberry and other purees over the years that adding sugary fruit gives yeast extra fuel to convert into alcohol, raising its alcohol level. On the plus side, it’s a lot less messy to work with frozen pawpaw pulp than fresh.

He started the 10-day brewing process on Labor Day, adding the first of three five-gallon buckets of puree at the tail end of the boil and circulating it for a half-hour with hoses and pumps before transferring the mixture to the fermenter. Each bucket holds about 45 pounds of puree.

Two more buckets were added directly into the tank when the beer stopped fermenting; it was then transferred to a brite tank to be carbonated and allowed to settle. It will be canned and kegged on Sept. 23 to be “as fresh as possible” three days later. Adding the fruit after fermentation, he says, brings out more flavor and aroma in the final product.

Advertise with us

The 16-ounce cans will bear a vintage, botanical label designed by local graphic designer Frank Dreyer, who became a good friend after meeting Yurkovich and his partners at the Foreland Street location. It was inspired by a drawing from one of Tree Pittsburgh’s past interns.

Yurkovich notes that while many of his regular customers might be trying pawpaw beer for the first time, he expects at least a few seasoned fest-goers will be looking for it. To make it easier for newbies, the brewery plans on having some fun educating the 21-plus crowd about its fruity glory not just with samples, but by passing out some of the fruit the brewer grew from trees he purchased from Tree Pittsburgh’s nursery a few years ago and planted on his property.

“Everyone should try Patch to taste for yourself what pawpaw is,” he says.

He might also direct customers to a pair of fruit-bearing pawpaw trees that in 2015 were planted with other native species on the Allegheny Mountains Lot just a few blocks from his Brighton Heights tasting room, at the corner of California and Benton avenues, as part of a vacant lot program through GTECH Strategies.

People might be drawn to pawpaw and beer made with it because it’s a fun name to say, Yurkovich says. But it’s so much more.

“It conjures a connection to Appalachia and a history of the region that feels a little familiar but also mysterious in a way.”