Michelle Lynch says she loves when customers ask whether the bar she and her husband and business partner, Gary, installed at the Park House is new. It’s not — they restored and refinished the original one with a cherry stain in service of a top-to-bottom refurbishment centered around preserving a room that regulars would still recognize the moment they step into the East Ohio Street space.
That balancing act carries weight at a bar that traces its current identity to 1933, when it reopened after Prohibition and received one of Pennsylvania’s earliest liquor licenses.
Built in the late 1800s and long regarded as one of the commonwealth’s oldest continuously operating bars, the beloved North Side pub’s closing at the end of 2020 felt like a gut punch to the city’s dwindling historic neighborhood bar scene.
“The biggest anxiety we had going into this was how we would live up to past versions of Park House while still being ourselves as owners,” Michelle Lynch says. “We need to honor the essence of what it holds for people, and we think we’ll be able to do that.”
Most of the changes at The Park House, which reopened on Repeal Day (Dec. 5), are designed to look seamless or disappear entirely. The Lynches used a lineup of local experts to install new HVAC and plumbing systems, replace the floors behind the bar, rebuild the tap lines and add new equipment to the basement kitchen. They sandblasted and cleaned brick walls, replaced the old wallpaper with historically accurate paper in the art nouveau style and restored the ceiling to a warm golden hue.
Powder-height stools, slightly shorter than traditional bar stools, give guests a little more room at the bar. (You’ll find the taller, classic stools at the high-top tables in the front of the space.) An antique mirrored back bar anchors the space, paired with a newly built service kitchen designed to mirror the original. Much of the detailed carpentry work on that was done piece by piece by Mennonite craftsmen.
Read More
Lynch came to Park House with a background that blends hospitality, construction and real estate. In 2020, she and Gary initially planned to purchase the building as an investment; they also acquired the liquor license and bar when longtime owner Zamir Zahavi decided to step away after 16 years.
The goal is to run a spot that keeps the relaxed vibe while adding a bit of a spruced-up atmosphere.
Longtime North Side bartender Lauren Serra serves as Park House’s bar manager.
House cocktails, listed for $11 each (a wicked good price for a bespoke cocktail compared to most other spots around town) as of last weekend, lean into classics and spins on them.
Prices for bottled beers and hard seltzers range from $4 to $8, with draft beers at a similar price point. Both bottle and draft draw from a mix of national brands, imported brews and Pittsburgh-area locals.
Guinness, run through special tap lines, is the top seller so far, with the bar going through three kegs in the first two weeks of service.
Lynch initially envisioned the food menu as simple and bar-forward, as the space has limitations. It does not have venting for a deep fryer, and the hood system is self-contained, providing fire and smoke protection without venting outdoors.
Nevertheless, the plan shifted when Isaac William DeBoer, a chef with a globe’s worth of experience and best known locally for his Thai cuisine deadfish pop-ups, returned from an extended stay abroad and submitted a resume. He was hired in November.
“The blueprint was written for the menu — ideas of food that they wanted to serve — and then I just came in and wrote recipes for them,” DeBoer says. “It isn’t groundbreaking, but we’re doing all the little things the right way. Whatever we can make here is what we’re going to try to do.”
I’m looking forward to diving into DeBoer’s concise menu, which pulls from Irish and Italian staples including Guinness beef stew with root vegetables and house-made bread, sandwiches such as meatball and artichoke Parmesan, and pinsa Romana (an antique Roman-style flatbread).
Lynch says music, long a part of Park House’s identity, will return gradually, though (at least as of now) the Wednesday bluegrass jam popular in the previous era isn’t going to be part of the mix. The aim is to host live acts at least once a week, with programming expected to increase in February.
“We’re looking forward to keeping a tradition of live music,” Lynch says. “But it’s going to happen in baby steps.”
403 East Ohio St., East Allegheny; parkhouse412.com.






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.