Because it’s across the street from the Pirates’ baseball stadium and gets tagged as a sports bar, Mike’s Beer Bar at 110 Federal St. on the North Side doesn’t get the credit it deserves as a Steel City beer mecca.

“When people visit Pittsburgh, they want to try a Pittsburgh beer,” says Mike Sukitch, a North Sider who had a corporate career with Procter & Gamble before buying the old North Shore Tavern in 2018.

“I’m fourth generation in the beer business. My grandparents were one of the first distributors in the state after Prohibition. I grew up driving a beer truck.”

With 500 beers available — including 350 local, and 80 on tap — old-school folders with lists intelligently grouped by category printed on real paper and a European beer hall feel, Sukitch says Mike’s Beer Bar qualifies as one of those rare places you can go in Pittsburgh for a beer experience.

Advertise with us

“It’s like coming to a flea market,” says Sukitch. “Regulars come in and ask, ‘What’s new?’”

What’s new right now is holiday and/or winter beers.

Around this time of year, people often come in asking for seasonal craft classics like Great Lakes’ Christmas Ale or Sierra Nevada’s Celebration. Product manager Taliah Banal likes to steer them toward Pittsburgh seasonal brews.

“We have so much to offer,” she says.

The catalog currently lists 11 seasonal Pittsburgh beers on tap, including Hazel Grove’s HazelGood, Penn Brewery’s St. Nikolaus Bock, Rivertowne’s Rudolph’s Red and Cinderlands’ One More Sleep.

Advertise with us

A Christmas beer is heavier in alcohol than most beers, and usually spicier, with a good body and a toasty finish. A new generation mixes in cinnamon, clove and other spices and offers sweet touches reminiscent of Christmas cookies and fruit cake.

However, as Banal points out, “They have a reputation as sweet, but a lot of them are just a darker lager.”

That’s the case at Hofbrauhaus Pittsburgh, the German-themed beer hall two rivers away on the South Side.

“For me, a Christmas beer is something that reminds me of a cozy night by the fire,” says assistant brewer Alexandra DeRose.

When I stopped by, she was getting ready for the celebratory release of their annual Weihnachtsbier, made with three kinds of hops. Every year, Hofbrauhaus brews over 25 barrels’ worth. A bartender poured me a sample. It was lighter and hoppier than most Christmas beers, with a smooth, malty finish. It’s a good beer to drink while eating, and it's safe to have more than one.

Advertise with us

One reason it’s not sweet is that Hofbrauhaus, DeRose explains, respects the German purity code of using only water, barley, malt and hops as ingredients.

The tradition of brewing winter beers goes back to ancient Scandinavia. The Vikings liked to have something stiff to quaff on the feasts around winter solstice as they honored their famously hard-partying Norse gods.

It wasn’t until the 1970s that American craft breweries, led by Anchor Brewing Co. in California, began making Christmas beers. The tradition, of course, includes beers branded as winter or holiday ales. You don’t have to celebrate Christmas to make merry in the dead of winter.

“When you’re coming into the Christmas time you want something that’s darker and richer,” says Chris Rudolph, head brewer at Penn Brewery in Troy Hill. This year, the well-established brewery is making its classic St. Nikolaus Bock, as well as a reserve version sold in a bigger bottle with a red velvet sleeve, and a new offering, Nut Roll Ale, made in collaboration with Oakmont Bakery.

The brewers are making the beers because Pittsburghers are fans of the genre.

Advertise with us

“The generally darker, heavier Christmas beers match up well with the cold weather, and higher alcohol content give you a little extra warmth,” says Dave Matlin, an engineer with Pittsburgh Regional Transit who’s organized Christmas beer swap parties at his house where guests bring a case of a different Christmas beer and trade with each other.

On Christmas Eve, Matlin says, “My wife and I like to cozy up with a couple of Corsendonk Christmas ales.”

With its front parking lot, open courtyard and big garage entrance, one of Pittsburgh’s newest breweries, Hazel Grove Brewing, at 4609 Irvine St. in Hazelwood, has a fun Florida beach vibe. It’s a terrific brewery to visit in the summer with children, or for live music. In winter, it offers a well-stocked shelf of board games and its own Christmas beer.

HazelGood delivers a satisfying multilayered taste experience, with banana notes fronting a more complex aftertaste of pepper and ginger.

“We didn’t want this just to be a Chai spice bomb,” says co-founder Steve Hartman. “Christmas beers are meant to bring back the nostalgia of the holidays in a fun way. You see those beers on the shelves, and you think ‘Hey, it’s Christmas time.’”