A neon “Mary’s” sign punctuated with a heart substituting for the apostrophe has shined over the 5100 block of Penn Avenue for years.
Lilac lighting emanated from behind fogged glass windows, giving the impression the bar could open any minute. Yet week after week, month after month, year after year, the space remained shuttered.
“Is Mary’s ever going to open?” became a longstanding question asked by neighborhood residents and attendees of events such as First Fridays that take place on the artsy corridor that runs through Friendship, Garfield and Bloomfield.
In late November, following a seven-year journey full of twists and turns, Mary’s opened.
“It was a steep learning curve,” says first-time bar owner Laura Longenecker.
Longenecker plans to operate Mary’s as a “local glam dive,” which she characterizes as a queer-positive neighborhood bar that’s welcoming to people from all walks of life.
Read More
“It can be really hard for queer people living in the world right now,” she says. “Having places like Mary’s is important because people can come, talk, share ideas and feel safe building community.”
People can also celebrate. Mary’s programming will feature DJs spinning tunes for themed dance parties and live drag performances from local and national acts, as well as more laid-back events such as bar trivia.
Longenecker is a self-proclaimed fan of Bravo television’s shows such as the various “Real Housewives” series, so look for viewing events on Mary’s numerous television screens, too.
“Let’s watch Bravo here like people watch sports in other bars,” she says.
Longenecker was working in nightlife as an event producer and promoter in Portland, Ore., when she visited Pittsburgh for Pride in 2014.
“I fell in love with the city, and particularly this neighborhood. It just felt like a magical place,” she says.
It was around that time she started talking to the owners of Portland clubs where she booked shows with talent from “RuPaul’s Drag Race” and other queer nightlife legends about the kind of space she wanted to open.
Longenecker’s family has Pennsylvania roots — her father grew up in the central Pennsylvania town of Port Royal – and Pittsburgh was much more affordable than Portland, so after some searching she decided to purchase the former Toro’s space on the Friendship side of Penn Avenue in 2017.
Shortly thereafter, Longenecker set about rehabbing the 100-plus-year-old building.
“I love doing interior design and creating a fantasy,” she says. “It wasn’t just building out a functioning bar space. It’s about doing it to the nines.”
What was meant to be a quick-ish turnover turned into one of the longest opening sagas in recent memory. There were significant setbacks along the way.
Longenecker says hiccups in renovating the old building quickly expanded the scope of the project. Early on, she tried to manage the build-out remotely while living in Portland. But, as the situation dragged on through various contractors, she eventually relocated to Pittsburgh and now lives in Friendship.
Shattering her leg in an accident and the universality of delays brought on by the COVID-19 pandemic added to the logjams, too.
“Basically, there was a lack of master planning on my part that I realize now is essential to doing this type of thing. I’ve learned so much in this process,” Longenecker says. “Now, I’m getting my general contractor’s license.”
As the build-out ebbed and flowed with physical delays, Longenecker says she gained a deeper awareness about the importance of working with longstanding neighborhood groups, particularly as it pertains to opening the first late-night bar on the stretch (one that will feature live events and entertainment) in years.
She says she came to a memorandum of understanding with neighbors on hours of operation and when and how often the bar can host live shows. She plans to meet with them again in approximately four months.
“They’ve been reasonable in our conversations,” says Longenecker, who also owns the former Graveyard Grill space down the block. “I’m hoping with Mary’s I can show people that I’m a responsible business owner who lives in the community and shows that I care about the impact of the space on the community.”
Longenecker says her long friendship with Aaron Coady, better known by the stage name Sharon Needles, added complexity to the perception of Mary’s.
Coady is a longtime friend of Longenecker (who also used to work as her booker) and provided creative input for Mary’s in the early stages of the process. A more significant role was discussed but never materialized.
As Sharon Needles, the popular Pittsburgh drag queen rose to fame as the Season 4 winner of “Drag Race,” she has a track record of courting controversy in her provocative performances, which have often taken on tones perceived by many as racist and transphobic.
Longenecker says that while she remains supportive of Coady, he is not in any way involved with the ownership or management of Mary’s. She is the sole owner of the establishment.
“People take bits and pieces they hear and turn other people into monsters. Context matters in art, but that’s also a generational and subjective point of view on my end. If I didn’t know her personally, I would probably think a lot of that, too,” Longenecker says.
Longenecker says her focus is on what happens now that Mary’s is open: creating a safe, inclusive space at a time when such places are increasingly vital.
“I will not tolerate anyone’s terrible behavior in the bar,” Longenecker says. “People are nervous about how things are right now. Trans people especially, but all queer people. I’m hoping that Mary’s can provide a sense of solace, safety and escapism. I’m happy that we’re finally open and have another place to offer people to go.”
5128 Penn Ave., Friendship; maryspgh.com






Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.