Like the burn of a flaming Dr. Pepper, nothing lasts forever.

After 85 years serving up warmth to regulars and newcomers alike on the South Side, McArdle’s Pub’s long run will come to an end on St. Patrick’s Day, the business announced via social media “with a heavy heart and soul” on Wednesday.

“We have loved serving the community, making memories, and being a place where ‘everybody knows your name,’” read the announcement. “If you are from Pittsburgh, more than likely you have come across our pub and left with a memory.”

The family-owned Irish pub at 1600 Bingham St. has operated since 1939; a plaque on the exterior of the building reads “House of McArdle, established June 19, 1937.”

Advertise with us

In 1999, Raymond H. McArdle formally handed off the 3,000-square-foot, 2 ½-story building in which the 1,025 square-foot pub resides to Michael P. McArdle of Bethel Park, according to real estate records.

“Mike has been with you all, sharing some of your best and worst of times,” the announcement continued. “We are sure he has given you a good laugh, a great drink, or an even better story. For some - the memories start as far back as his father, Ray (Big Mac), before his son took over.”

The Bingham Street building had been listed for sale online since June 2023, with the latest price set at $280,000. It’s now labeled “under contract,” on several real estate sites, though Allegheny County real estate records have not been updated to formally reflect a sale. Calls to both ownership and the listing agent for further information were not immediately returned.

Well wishes have been pouring in via social media since the announcement was made.

“It was like the ‘Cheers’ of South Side,” commenter Matthew Lenger wrote. “There was a lot of good memories I had there with Mike McArdle and the kids. Just so you know, you guys are gonna be greatly missed and there’s never gonna be another bar like McArdle’s. Thank you for all the years of fun [and] excellent drinks.”

Advertise with us

“This place is an institution,” added Scott Tizzard. “I've been coming to this bar with family and friends all the way from Canada for close to 40 years.”

“How many of you met your significant other in this pub?” posed Barb Schrader in a comment that received several likes.

“McArdle's may be closing, but the stories and spirit will live forever in our hearts,” said Jude Lettrich.

Despite the looming closure, there’s still time to make last-minute memories, as the post invited the public to stop by for one last “hoorah” on its final day, St. Patrick’s Day, March 17.

“We hope you stop down, have one last Flaming Dr. Pepper, and send us off with a smile,” the announcement concluded. “Thank[s] for years of support and dedication. We love you all.”

Josh Ewers: jewers@post-gazette.com