My pineapple growing began around eight years ago, on a whim.
I’d just started a new job out of town that meant I’d be home only on weekends, so I was looking for things that would keep me in touch with our twin daughters, then in high school. One Sunday after dinner, I took the base of a romaine lettuce and dropped it in a glass of water, telling them it would grow into a new head. I warned them I’d be checking regularly to make sure they were changing the water, and would be very upset if they weren’t keeping up with it.
It worked … sort of. The lettuce took root and we planted it. Each morning, I’d ask for proof-of-life photos so I knew my plant was safe, and predicted we’d have a salad together when it got big enough. But one weekend, I came home to a withered, unwatered spindly lettuce plant, and two daughters who, of course, each pointed the finger at the other as I stood glaring.
A few weeks later, I tried again, this time with the crown of a pineapple. It was a lark, but the pineapple head actually grew roots, and when I stuck it in dirt, somehow stayed alive. We put it out on the patio, and in the fall, when it was, amazingly, still alive, took it inside.

Each summer, we carted it out onto the back patio. It spent a year or so in a quart-sized pot, then a gallon pot for a couple years, then a 5-gallon bucket. Finally, it made its way into a huge stoneware pot one of our neighbors was trying to throw out (my wife Gretchen made me get up early on trash day to steal it from the curb).
After a few years, I named it “Piney.” Piney eventually got big enough that at Christmas my wife strung it with lights and decorated its spikes. All very cute, but at some point, Piney got so heavy I could no longer carry it for more than 5 feet at a time. And pineapples, turns out, have needle sharp points at the end.
With no handles, the stoneware pot was a bear to hold on to. I came to dread the biannual pineapple move. In the fall of 2019, I came storming into the house with a hole in my forehead so deep that I thought I’d need to go get it sewed up. As Piney grew, it became a menace inside the house, too, with needle barbs waiting for innocent passers-by. Our dog almost lost an eye.
This had started as a bonding experience with my daughters, but they’d gone off to college, then work, and now were on their own. The only bonding that was happening was Piney had become a spiky albatross I couldn’t get off my back. I pictured someone finding me crushed under the monster pot, run through with pineapple barbs.
Then, last April, as I was complaining (whining) that I was not going to put my life on the line to move this infernal pincushion one more time, I found that Piney was with child. There, in the middle of all those razor sharp spikes, was a baby pineapple the size of a golf ball. We did some research and learned it could take months and months, but that this was the final sacrificial act for a pineapple. Once the offspring was picked, the parent plant’s days were numbered.
My wife joyfully announced to friends that our efforts had finally borne fruit, and that once it was ready to pick, we were going to celebrate with a piña colada party. Piña colada is the ultimate, most noble fate for pineapple. The other extreme is, of course, Hawaiian pizza, which everyone hates, including most Hawaiians. I agreed to bring Piney out one last time so the fruit could ripen in the summer sun.
This changed the whole equation. Living in Pittsburgh, we had absolutely no experience raising tropical fruit. Does a potted plant produce a full-size pineapple? What does a ripe pineapple even look like? How would we know when to pick it? My only experience was one Christmas when my wife made a Colonial fruit decoration for the fanlight above our front door. The pineapple at the center went bad and dripped sticky residue all over our porch. There’s still stains on the threshold.
All summer, each time I passed Piney, I’d poke the growing (but still pretty small) fruit. I’d squeeze gently, but that showed nothing. Pineapples, even the ones at the supermarket, are pretty rock solid. By fall, the fruit was as big as a softball. Is that when you pick it? Making our move too soon might mean an eight-year buildup to … nothing. My wife consulted an expert who said when pineapple is ready, you can easily pluck the spikes out of the top. Piney’s spikes were holding firm. At the end of the summer, we took it inside, and all fall debated whether it was time to do the honors.

By December, I had a growing sense that maybe we’d waited too long. The fruit was starting to look sort of oozy, but my wife assured me that the spikes were still on firmly. Finally, at Christmas, we decided we may have missed the window. We bought a bottle of rum, and with great ceremony, harvested the fruit and took it into the kitchen for slicing.
I did the honors and stood back in disappointment. The flesh inside was stringy and desiccated, with some spots beginning to turn brown. After all this waiting, we’d missed our chance. But I was not going to let eight years go down without at least a taste. I cut off a part that seemed the least decayed, and put it in my mouth.
Ever try something you could, technically, swallow, but are pretty sure will end up in a stomachache? I spit it into the trash.
As I stared at Piney, now destined to wilt away quietly, I realized he was a lot like me. He spent the past eight years getting bigger, fatter and more prickly, annoying a lot of people along the way. He had only one real purpose: to produce offspring that would carry on after he was gone.
I went into the kitchen, twisted off the spiky head of the fruit, and put it in a glass of water. When (if) it takes root, I’ll pass it on to one of my daughters, and let them carry on the tradition. Maybe eight years from now, when I am close to 70, they’ll call and tell me it’s ready, and they’ll invite the old man over for a piña colada.
Peter McKay is a former syndicated humor columnist and a long-time author of the Post-Gazette’s “Homemaking” column.
PIÑA COLADA

PG tested
My homegrown pineapple rotted before I could use it for this cocktail, but luckily you’ll have no trouble finding one at the grocery story.
Made with frozen pineapple, coconut cream and rum, piña coladas are a summertime favorite. But they can also brighten a dreary winter day, reminding you that warmer weather will be here before you know it. I used Coco Goya Cream of Coconut, available in cans in the Hispanic food section.
½ fresh pineapple, peeled, cut into 1½-inch pieces
6 ounces sweetened cream of coconut
6 ounces white rum
2 tablespoons fresh lime juice
Pineapple and lime wedges, for serving, optional
Maraschino cherries, for serving, optional
Place pineapple pieces in a resealable plastic bag, laying them flat. Freeze until solid, at least 3 hours.
Shake cream of coconut in the can before measuring. Purée pineapple, cream of coconut, rum, lime juice and 3 cups ice in a blender until smooth.
Divide among chilled glasses, garnish with pineapple or lime wedges, and serve immediately.
Makes 4 cocktails.
— Gretchen McKay, Post-Gazette




Comments
Welcome to Post-Gazette subscriber-only commenting community. Please review our community guidelines.